Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Space bar won't open photos in Mojave

I just updated to Mojave and now, in Photos, when I have a thumbnail selected, hitting the space bar no longer functions to open (or later close) the image. This really inhibits my ability to quickly toggle into and out of images. I've seen a couple other scattered reports of this on the big wild web, but am wondering if anyone else here is experiencing it?

59 replies

You are not alone with this sentiment, see:

Re: Is v.4 of Photos (Mojave) different than v.3?


The spacebar is now used to start and stop videos - a video will play a preview in the thumbnail and I can start and stop it by hitting the space bar. It is now similar to iMovie, but to quickly open or close an image i have now to use the return key.

I went to the Preferences > Keyboard > Shortcuts > App Shortcuts > Added Photos. For Menu Title I entered "Open Viewer" and for the keyboard shortcut I pressed Fn with Space.

At the same time, I followed the procedure for closing picture preview.

Preferences > Keyboard > Shortcuts > App Shortcuts > Added Photos. For Menu Title I entered "Close Viewer" and for the keyboard shortcut I pressed Fn with Space.

Until Apple fixes this, upon loading Photos, just hit the Return key once, then the space bar will work. No need to use your mouse to invoke the image menu.

I hate this as well. Now you must hit the "return" key to have the function previously used by the space bar. I do not like this. Was looking to see if we could change this by a setting but I haven't found it yet.

Same annoying problem here. I tried hitting the return key when first opening Photos since it was the default way to open a thumbnail (besides double clicking), and it no longer works, but after tapping the return key once, then the space bar works without clicking in the Image pull down.


Funny that Apple left the spacebar as a way to, say, look at a pdf file in a Finder window, but someone thought the spacebar was not the way to open a photo!

This worked after a restart and several closing and openings of the photos app


Thanks

Go to preferences > keyboard > shortcuts > app shortcuts > Photos > and add a shortcut. For Menu Title enter "Open Viewer" and for the keyboard shortcut press the spacebar whilst holding the Fn key. Add another one for "Close Viewer". Problem solved

Go to the previous page in this discussion. "Eric in Boca" totally and completely solves this blunder by Apple. You might have to use Return once at the start of a Photos session (when you open Photos anew), but then the spacebar will work exactly as before! There is another answer marked "solved" but it doesn't solve anything. It just tells you to use the Return key.

You may want to look at the date of the post, artist999, September 26, 2018. That was two days after Photos 4.0 and Mojave had been released. At that time we were still wondering, if this is a bug or intentional. The day before the Photos User Guide had still been describing the space bar shortcut like it has always been, so it looked like a bug. I posted my reply after I had seen, that Apple had updated the list of keyboard shortcuts to include the new behavior, when it became clear, that the changed behavior is unfortunately fully intentional (Photos keyboard shortcuts on Mac - Apple Support). If it were a bug, unexpected, incorrect behavior - we could hope for a bug fix. But with a new intended behavior - broken be design, there is not much hope for a fix by Apple.

I haven't been able to make it work with a new shortcut key, or clicking the image menu, or clicking the return key when first opening photos. The only thing that works for me is the return key. Frustrating. I left feedback on the link to apple.

You can also use trackpad to preview or close a photo. Just double tap the trackpad instead of pressing the space bar. Perhaps Apple wants us to use more gestures instead of the keyboard.

I'm experiencing the same thing. I have to click "IMAGE" before this shortcut will work. Small price to pay for a great fix to an otherwise stupid decision.

AGAIN, YES AGAIN, JUST CLICK ON YOUR RETURN KEY ONCE WHEN FIRST OPENING PHOTOS, THEN THE SPACEBAR SHORTCUT WILL WORK.

Go through all the posts again carefully. It DOES work, but you have to enter the names of the 2 shortcuts exactly as the instructions say: case sensitive. And remember, in a NEW session, like when you restart your computer and open Photos, you have to hit Return the first time you want to Quick Look a photo. But after that, the space bar will work.

Nope! I spent 2 hours this morning fiddling and tinkering around with no luck, so have just left things as described in my answer to Léonie further down. But do send Apple feedback about this, the more the merrier! www.apple.com/feedback


Regards, Ian.

I love Apple, but sometimes they do the stupidest of things. Why change the spacebar function?? Going on a limb here and saying people take more photos than videos, so it makes more sense to use the function for PHOTOS! At the very least, give us the option to choose which one we prefer.

The logic of Apple design is becoming stranger and stranger. Why change spacebar to return? People usually use the right hand to navigate in the trackpad and the left one to open file. now you can navigate and open the photos using your right hand only and it's not the best way to do this.

Eric, I second @Ramblinmanva's comments - thanks for the post!


That said, I'm experiencing the same shortcoming - the spacebar shortcuts only seems to work after I've invoked the "Image" menu. Still looking to Apple for a fix...

This doesn't work for me. Nor does clicking on image. Is this the image menu at the top of the screen? Just click on it then let the drop down menu close and then the space bar is supposed to work. That also doesn't work. only the return key works to open and close images. anyone else having this problem?

johnesquivel,

The "Photos" item will be added to the list, when you click the "+" button to add a new shortcut, and then select "Photos" from the "Applications" drop-down menu at the top of the panel. It is safer to restrict your new shortcut to Photos, so it will not interfere with other applications.


User uploaded file

Thanks! I just followed your link and left this feedback for Apple:


This is one of the most ridiculous, unnecessary, and out-of-touch changes I've ever seen. I have way more photos than videos, so your trying to somehow be consistent with video viewing in your shortcut change has caused me a huge amount of trouble. There is a good workaround published on line. You should check it out.

https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8554200?answerId=33928019022#33928019022

If you want to get the Space bar functionality back and make the rest of your workflows more efficient use a macro app like Keyboard Maestro which can be used to launch apps, open folders and or documents, enter text, etc. with a single keystroke or simple key combination. I use it and have over 250 macros which I use to shorten my workflow and speed it up. Entering the Keyboard Maestro URL link was one of them.


User uploaded file

Hi Léonie! I´ve left only the "Open" shortcut defined...for some reason having a second shortcut stops the "Return" key from working. To close the preview I flick my middle finger down (towards me) on my wireless Magic Mouse, as if I had a scroll wheel...not ideal but it´s fast and easier than reaching up for the "Return" key! I imagine the majority of us use Photos for just that...photos...so I think Apple ought to give us back the Space Bar functionality for opening photos. I've sent them feedback. Regards, Ian.

Thank you, Ian.

That is what I finally did. I changed the "close" shortcut back to "return", and now I am mostly using a double tap on my trackpad to open and close photos. And use the spacebar to open the photos only on my old iMac, where I do not have a trackpad in the keyboard.



Hi Eric in Boca! Before updating to Mojave 10.14.2 your shortcut workaround worked great on my iMac, but now it´s only possible to have a shortcut to open or to close, not both! **** nuisance!

😠 You're right, Ian. Now only the "Open" shortcut is working for me. "Close" is still defined, but it does no longer work. And the "Return" key is no disabled as well.



Uhhg. I completely agree. MacOS has conditioned me to slap the spacebar to view objects, and this was an obvious, intuitive and consistent way to open/close photos.


My quantity of photos outnumbers my quantity of videos 30:1, so this change has made the spacebar 30x less useful (not to mention that the spacebar could previously be used to open/close videos as well).


Changing this behavior (without providing an option to restore the previous behavior) is offensive. I will not update to Mojave on my primary machine until an option is available.

Eric: This is fantastic. Your tip--I love it and it (mostly) work. Thank you for taking the time to post it.


I say "mostly" because I have one issue I can't figure out. When I first open Photos, this shortcut doesn't work. I see "image" in the menu bar light up like it's trying to do something but it won't work. However, if I click on the "image" menu bar one time, from then on the space bar will work as I want it to with this short cut. It won't work if I click on other menus, it has to be the "image" menu, and then the space bar works going forward.


Are you experiencing the same behavior? Any way to avoid having to click in the menu bar first?


Thank you!

Hey, Eric in Boca.. Thanks!!!

FYI.. to others: I don't have the option for "Photos" in 'app shortcuts' (see images below).. but fortunately, I was still able to add the two shortcuts per his post and it works in Photos. 🙂

User uploaded fileUser uploaded file

Works perfectly, thanks.


Apple is supposed to avoid us having to do workarounds like this.

If Jobs were alive, someone would get the sack over this.


I've left feedback

www.apple.com/feedback/photos

everyone else who's annoyed should too.

The "solved" icon should NOT be on your post. You merely explained the problem better. The person who posted the (almost) perfectly functioning workaround, Eric in Boca, is the one who helped us. We came here for help so we could go on with our work in an efficient manner, not commentary, so please give the "Solved" designation to him.

As the original poster, please understand that I accidentally hit the "solved" button next to the wrong post, and I realized it immediately, but to my knowledge this forum has no way to undo that or to mark another post as having solved the problem.

Sometimes the forum software marking another post as the correct answer, if there is a race condition in the network transfer. Probably you marked the correct post, Kenneth, but on the server my post got marked. I could ask the hosts to remove my reply completely, and then your question would probably have the solved mark, which would not help much. There is something else very strange - Eric in Boca's solution has already 11 well deserved Helpful marks. This alone should have kicked it automatically to the top of the discussion, but that is not happening for some reason.

Also, once I'm signed in, I'm not able to mark any posts as Helpful. I thought maybe because I'd already marked too MANY as helpful, and that I was being limited as to how often I could "vote" on a given thread.

There are limits on the number of "Helpful" and "solved" per discussion.

  • The original poster can award one "Solved" and two "Helpful" marks per discussion.
  • Any other forum member can award twice a "Helpful" per discussion.

Thats great except there seems to be something preventing me from using the same shortcut to open and close. The open with spacebar works fine then gives me an error chime when pressing spacebar to close. Sure would be great if Apple would ruin functionality with new releases ....

Same here, Bell86! Before updating to Mojave 10.14.2 the shortcut workaround posted by Eric in Boca worked fine on my iMac, but now it´s only possible to have a shortcut to open or to close, not both! **** nuisance!

what idiots.... why do they always change stuff that works! fix the sh... that doesn't! I makes me so angry that after every update I have to change my workflow because they keep chang 00004000 ing things. One of the reasons I stopped using Windows a decade ago, but it seems to be just as bad here these days. Please bring back the space bar preview !!!

Am I the only one here who grew up using space bar to start and stop videos? When did this expectation change? (Maybe with the move from iPhoto to Photos..?)


Funny, I came here to find out why space bar wouldn't play videos in MacOS (Sierra) Photos and found that people were complaining of the opposite, as if space bar ALWAYS meant "preview/close" (it didn't - it used to mean "open/play/stop" and 'Esc' meant "close"). Weird ...

OMG Apple I am really starting to get annoyed with how bad you are. Your developers used to be the best in the world and now, literally everything... and I mean EVERYTHING you do has major bugs. Now add to the list that it' not just bugs, but intentional acts of stupidity.


So your developers think that spacebar should preview every file, including videos within the photos app and photos stored anywhere else on the Mac... and return should rename every file. Apart from when you want to preview a photo in the photos app - then suddenly, the shortcuts change. Why? It's not like it has another function, it just gives an error dong sound.


I don't care which key you settle on, whether it be spacebar or return but for gods sake make it consistent. This is one tiny issue in a list of maybe 100 other issues i have with your products, hence my frustrations.


If you want to charge several thousand pounds for your devices, in a market where everyone else is charging several hundred, you need to be perfect - no excuse. Or drop the prices, one or the other.

I tried this and it worked only for opening the photos with the Space Bar. For closing the same it does not work the same way. Shame on Apple for messing up years of intuitive interaction with the keyboard.

WHAT WAS THE NEED TO DO THIS??

I like your comment about the spacebar being made 30 times less useful. It's true!!

Makes sense. Done.

Thanks for the help!!

It works now. I had Open Viewer and Close Viewer in all lowercase.

Thanks

works thx

Thank you Sir!!


It was "hold Fn whilst pressing the spacebar" that did the trick :-)
That allowed me to put a spacebar in the shortcut field.

Thank you all for your kind remarks. I have been pretty quiet, but I see all the postings.

What a useless explanation of a UX Bug.

Sorry Leonie and thank you for your update.


i just read that. Didnt know Apple updated their description and manifesting this UX Fail.
[Edited by Host]

Thank you, Eric. It worked for me with Photos! Since it's now December and you posted this in October, I'm guessing Apple heard the cry for help :-)

Just wanted to echo you. I came here specifically to see what was up. My space bar will only work for one or the other. More annoying that before. Ha. Any work around found? Thanks.

how do I delete this comment?

You're most welcome, Léonie! Using my Magic Mouse on my new iMac to close is an acceptable workaround for me, but I do hope Apple react to this problem! Ian.

This works to open the photo, but it will not close it. Am I missing a step? Thank you for the help.

Wish they had just gone back to the iPhoto scheme: The spacebar opens still pictures. And opens and starts video. Another tap on the spacebar stops the video. Couldn't be simpler.

The spacebar won't close the pic! I've tried all of the options in this list. :-(

This works to open the photo, but it will not close it. Am I missing a step? Thank you for the help.

The update to macOS 10.14.2 killed the fix. It worked in the previous version of Photos, but no longer.