Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Smart Albums lost keyword criteria when imported from iPhoto to Photos

I am just now moving from iPhoto to Photos (Photos 2 in Mac OS Sierra), and I must say, the loss of 5-stars and of events is a complete nightmare for me--I had spent some 10 years adding metadata that is now suddenly useless. I honestly want to cry.


Aside from that, however, it seems that Photos vanished even much of the data that IS supported in Photos? Most of my Smart Albums have lost their keyword criterion. Is there some way to repair this, or do I have to recreate everything manually?


For instance, I had a smart album that was "keyword contains Dominica" and "rating is between 1-5 stars." Now the Smart Album just references stars but erased any reference to the keyword Dominica.


Are there other photo management programs that will import iPhoto or Photos metadata from a Library? (without me manually exporting it all)

Thanks!

7 replies

Photos can search for exact keyword matches, but not "keyword contains".

To replace your "Keyword contains Domenica" rule, you have to add the keyword "Domenica" to all photos that have a keyword with "Dominica" as part of the keyword. To find them quickly, use a search "text contains Domenica".

Or prepare your iPhoto Library in iPhoto for the migration to Photos and migrate it again. Add additional keywords for the parts of a keyword you want to find with "Keyword contains". It will be easier to prepare your smart albums in iPhoto where the old smart rules for keywords are still working.

dayia, I never noticed that the keyword rules in Photos are lacking compared to iPhoto, because I had switched from iPhoto to Aperture and have mainly been using Aperture before I migrated to Photos. Aperture used the same rules as Photos is using now. Instead of "Keywords contains ..., keyword starts with..., keyword end with" Aperture had the powerful hierarchical keywords, so there is no need to have iPhoto's more elaborate smart rules in Aperture.


But thank you for pointing out this additional complication. It should have been mentioned in Apple's support document How Photos displays Smart Albums from iPhoto or Aperture https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204487

You may want to use the feedback buttons at the bottom of this support document to tell apple that it needs more detail. And I'll add link to this discussion to the user tip: https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-8461

I did prep my old iPhoto Library to eliminate any Smart Albums based on Event name, but I expected Keyword-based rules to continue to work, since Keywords are still supported. None of the guides I read on switching programs mentioned that "contains" would be a problem (and since all my rules actually used full keywords, Apple could have programmed a fix in). My question was actually if there was a way to repair the data lost caused by the importer, although these answers about the general transition are very helpful. I'm three years late to the party because I knew I wasn't going to like Photos, so why rush to it?


Suggestion: Add this overall link to the more specific guidance you all have written--I found Moments are the New Events and Simulating Star Ratings, and it would have been great to see this page linked from those.

Links to User tips re migrating from iPhoto to Photos

Oh, and multiple Smart Albums just vanished entirely, although they were set up just like the other ones. Huh.

Thanks, feedback sent. (Discussions won't let me mark your reply helpful.)

You're welcome 🙂

Don't worry about the "Helpful". that is fine. You can only mark two posts as helpful for each discussion and one post as the solution.