Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Duplicates in Photo

I don't know how it came to be but I now find that Photos has all sorts of duplicate pictures often as many as 10. Is there some way to screen for duplicates and get rid of them other than manually which would be a daunting task?

6 replies

as answered three questions below your post


There are three tested, safe duplicate removal programs - many duplicate removal programs damage the Photos library beyond repair - never use one that directly removes photos or modifies them


The safe ones include:

PowerPhotos which also is an outstanding utility for use with photos for much more than duplicate removal

Duplicate Annihilator for Photos

PhotoSweeper for Photos


LN

Deleting your duplicate photos

Photos does not provide a mechanism for PowerPhotos to directly delete the duplicate photos that it has found, so the final step of deletion must be performed manually.

That is why Power Photos is one of the very few apps that are safe to use for detecting duplicates.

It will collect the duplicates in an album, and you can select all photos in this album and delete them all at once. None of the duplicate detectors that will remove photos from the Photos Library directly by modifying the Photos Library are safe. You may be left with a corrupted library. Only use duplicate finders that will collect the duplicates in an album, if you do not want to risk to lose your photos or have to restore your photos library from a backup.

That the reason for apple's warning: Using third-party apps to remove duplicate photos might damage your Photos for macOS library - Apple Support



Where are you seeing duplicates? Photos will only be duplicates, if you are seeing them more than once in the Moments in the Photos View, not if you are seeing them in multiple albums. A photon appear in many albums without being a duplicate.


If you are indeed having duplicates in the library, it will depend on the kind of duplicates how to detect them automatically.

Photos has no tool to detect photos, once they have been imported to the library. It relies on detecting duplicates on import.


If you want to search your library for duplicates use a third-party tool, like Power Photos, Photo Sweeper, or Duplicate Annihilator. These three apps are known to be safe, because they just collect duplicates in an album for you to remove using Photos's Interface. Other duplicate cleaners may manipulate the library directly and damage the library beyond repair (Using third-party apps to remove duplicate photos might damage your Photos for macOS library - Apple Support)


What kind of duplicates do you have? if you imported duplicates in different edited versions or different pixel size, Photo Sweeper will be your 00004000 best option, because it can compare the content of a photo based on bitmaps or histograms, not only the file attributes.

If the photos are exact duplicates, Power Photos is very good, because it is a nice companion for Photos anyway.

Thanks so much for the tips Larry and Leonie. I am seeing the duplicates in Photos (at the very top of the sidebar). Now that I look really closely I see that I was mistaken in my original post about as "many as 10". In fact the duplicates are all sets of 5. Still a mystery to me as to how the originals proliferated from the originals to sets of 5. Thanks for the Power Photos hint. I will certainly get it and trim my library to single photos.

Whoa !! I thought that Power Photos would be the answer to my problem but check out the following snippet from their Help section -

Deleting your duplicate photos

Photos does not provide a mechanism for PowerPhotos to directly delete the duplicate photos that it has found, so the final step of deletion must be performed manually.

So this doesn't do me any good since I can do the manual deletes without Power Photos. Do either of the other 2 apps that you suggested

Duplicate Annihilator for Photos

PhotoSweeper for Photos


do the job automatically?

Oh I see - I had the mistaken notion that with Power Photo it would collect one set of duplicates at a time and I would have to repeat the process for as many photos that have the duplicates. However if ALL the duplicates are collected into a single album and I only have to do one delete for the entire lot - well, that is a very reasonable procedure so I will give that a go. Thanks for elucidating the Power Photo process.