Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Photos info description has a glitch

This has been happening within the last week. When I select a range of photos to add a description to, the photo that is before or after that range overrides and takes on the description of the selected photos.


Here are some examples:


Shift and select 4 photos. They are highlighted with the blue box around them. I already have the info box to add the same description to these four photos. When I am done, I discovered the next photo after the four also now has the new description, even though I didn't select that photo. It override the description I had in the fifth photo.


When I click on photo one, hold the shift key and click on three photos away, those four photos are selected. I change the description so they can all match. Then I noticed the photo that is after the fourth photo suddenly took on the same description and erased my previous description in the fifth photo that I never selected to be changed.


The same thing happened in reverse also. When I clicked on a photo and held down the shift key to select three photos before it, I then have four total photos selected. I changed the description. Then suddenly the photo that is before the first of the photos is also changed. But I never selected that photo before the four photos.



A further issue, I have a movies smart album set up to show all my videos in one place in my Photos. Whenever a video is imported, it also goes into this album so I can view all videos in one place. I have been adding some videos lately. I know that I didn't select all the videos, but somehow every video now has the very last description I entered for the last video I imported. All my many videos descriptions are now gone, and they all show the same exact description.

15 replies

This is a bug with the latest version of Photos. For some every photo is the window gets the same description.


A workaround is to put just the photos you want to change in an album, open the album and change there. This limits the change to only those photos in the window.


Apple is aware of the problem but it won't hurt to let them know via https://www.apple.com/feedback/photos.html.


User uploaded file

Hello,


Today (august the 10th) the problem still exists with 10.12.6 (in french).

Re: smart albums messing my pictures

A question ? Does that problem exists only with "description" or also with the other ways to create smarts album (keyword, date, text or anyone else) ?


Thanks

There are two problems:

  • one problem that the next photo may also have the description changed. This happens, when viewing photos in the Moments or collections. That is annoying but easily corrected.
  • The other problem is, that when you are viewing photos in an album or after using the search field and then select a few photos to change the title, keywords, or descriptions, they may be changed for all currently displayed photos, not only for the selected photos. I had this happen also in macOS Sierra 10.12.3. Luckily I took head of the warning "Do you really want to change the description for 2500 photos" and hit the "Cancel" button.

You are smarter than the Apple rep I spoke to today before I sent the post. The Apple rep (in the iApps dept.) did not know what I was talking about at all and I could tell didn't really care (all I was told is that it worked on his Photos fine). I thought I was the only one with this glitch.


I then tried to do a Photos library repair (option + cmd while opening Photos) upon the Apple reps recommendation.


I hope Apple fixes this soon.


But I don't know why all of my smart album for video changed all my videos to one description. I know I would never select all the videos. I just selected one video and went to type in the description. Maybe it is tied in with the glitch. I have to be super careful now because a lot of hard work went into descriptions.


Thank you. I am all set for now.

But I don't know why all of my smart album for video changed all my videos to one description.

It's a bug in the Photos app. Try the album workaround until there's a fix provided by Apple, hopefully in the next update to Photos or Sierra.


As a test launch Photos with the Option key held down and create a new, test library. Import some photos and test to see if the same problem persists. Does it?

I just did an extensive test and found out the problem. I created a test library as you suggested and also did the same thing in my other library. This is what causes the issue: must hit enter after typing in the description. If you don't hit enter and just click anywhere else (like a blank space or on another photo), it will erase the next picture/video's description and replace it with the one you were typing in in the previous photo.


I tried it a bunch of times and each time I hit "enter", the description only change to the photos/videos I wanted (selected). If enter wasn't clicked, then it will change the adjoining photo/video also. It was never like this before. A user was able to click anywhere else (including any other photo or video) and it would be an automatic enter to any description that was entered previously.


It appears that some users are having this problem and not all? You probably have the latest OS also.

Then if it is a bug in the Photos app, then I would think it would affect all users with the latest version of Photos. I am not sure if this will be fixed in an update if it doesn't affect all users.


So if you select a group of photos and type a description for those photos only. Then don't click enter but just click anywhere else only (don't hit enter), it won't override the description in the adjoining photo (either in front or after) of the group you selected?

You mentioned: "That is annoying but easily corrected."


I believe you are referring to what I discovered the solution about hitting the enter button after typing a description. Yes, that is annoying as that wasn't apparent previously. Before with earlier Photos and iPhoto, when you type a description, you can click anywhere else and that would be an auto enter. Now, it isn't and I found out the hard way. But this issue doesn't seem to happen to everyone with the latest version of OS, so I don't know why I have that issue.


Could moving an Photos library from one drive to another cause this issue?


With the other problem in my smart album of my videos, I am careful with that also. I wouldn't have selected all my videos to change the description. It was only the one video I was working on. However, I know accidents happen and I believe I noticed that warning box you mentioned come up once for me and I did hit cancel then.

I found out that I do have that problem (just didn't do it properly) and your workaround works like a charm. I did all of my testing in an album as I didn't want to put all of the photos in my library at risk.

This is affects a group of photos selected only. It isn't consistent it seems. I did the test before in many ways and when I clicked on the white space it didn't work before.


I just did the test again at least 00004000 seven times. When I have the group of photos selected, I then clicked on an empty space (not hitting enter) and the description didn't change an adjoining photo. I did not hit enter though, just an empty space and it worked now.


But then I selected the same two photos again. I changed the description to a different one. But now instead of clicking on a white space, I clicked on the adjoining photo. It then proceeded to override that adjoining photo description which wasn't selected to begin with.


About the smart album for my videos:

There seems to be a bigger issue here. I just did a test again with two videos. I selected two videos and added a description. Then I clicked anywhere on the white space. It then changed all my videos in my album to that description. I am 100% sure I didn't select all the videos nor did a pop up message come up about changing all my descriptions. It just changed all of them. I did an undo. I redid the test but now I hit enter (not on a white space), and now only the two videos I selected changed the description. The enter only worked in the album (not the white space).

APPLE! This is a big frustrating problem! as kkkttt mentioned below (Thanks kkkttt) , making sure you press the ENTER key after entering a description does seem to work - but, say you have just finished making 48 unique descriptions on 48 separate photos and then add a description to the 49th --- AND FORGET TO PRESS ENTER!!!! - you have just negated all your work! Also I have corrupted a ton of descriptions before realizing this bug was even happening. Searching by descriptions is my main mode of fast archiving. This needs to be fixed!! PLEASE!


Looking for those wedding photos from a year ago where you used the description field to name everybody, the venue, the caterer?

Search for "wedding" and the results appear - see somebody you forgot to add in the description? You type in "Stacy", click on the next photo and Voila! You have just changed the description of every photo in your search to "Stacy"! You have not just added the word Stacy to all the descriptions, all previous descriptions have been erased and replaced with "Stacy".


APPLE PLEASE FIX THIS!

iMac (27-inch, Mid 2011) 3.4 GHz Intel Core i7 16GB ram MacOS Sierra 10.12.4

Thanks in advance

I have Sierra 10.12.3 and Photos 2.0 and do not have that problem.

Thank you.


I hope Apple fixes this because it caused an issue with 378 descriptions in my smart album for videos.

No, thank you. We'll be distribution your workaround so others can avoid this pitfall until it's fixed by Apple.