Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

iPhoto 11 - Problems With Photo Locations

Now that I can finally get back into my iPhoto library, I'm trying to update the locations on some recent photos. With no luck!


1) On the photos that have embedded location information, I can see the location name BUT the map is blank. It makes me worry that the location data is defective. Any ideas on how I can get the map to display. (I actually DO see the correct map for a brief instant before it switches to the blank white box you can see in this screen capture)

User uploaded file


2) On the photos with no embedded location data, I usually use my web browser to search for my location using maps.google.com, then I copy and paste the place name (and address) exactly as maps.google.com shows it. Always worked in the past, will not work now! I just tried it with the location name "Parco Acquedotti Appia Antica, Via Lemonia, Rome, Metropolitan City of Rome, Italy". For kicks, I tried "Detroit, Michigan" instead - also no luck!


Anyone know what causes this in iPhoto 11, and what I could do to correct it? Thanks!

111 replies

Make sure Look up Places is set to Automatically in iPhoto's Advanced preference pane:

User uploaded file

User uploaded file

yes, it was already set to look up places automatically. The problem persists.

I am experiencing the same problem with exactly the same Locations window appearance - the red pin is at bottom left and the map area is blank despite choosing different map types. This started yesterday on my machine. I tried removing the plist to no avail. I switched to a fresh test account on the machine and the same non-location error occurs. Nothing in Console to give me a clue. Perhaps Google changed the way they deliver map data?

Does the map display when you use the Windows ➙ Manage my Places menu option:

User uploaded file

When choosing Window > Manage my places, a non-satellite map flashes on the screen for a moment, then it changes to the pin-in-the-bottom-left view, with no other markings in the map region. Same as with the main window when showing information. I am guessing the flashed data is cached somewhere, then replaced with the fetched data....

As a test launch iPhoto with the Option key held down and create a new, test library. Import some photos and test to see if the same problem persists. Does it?

The problem persists even with a new photo library. You can typer a place name, but since the map does not render properly you cannot tell whether or not Google got it right?

Do the following:


1 - launch iPhoto with the Command+Option keys held down to open the First Aid window. Be sure to follow the circled recommendation in the screenshot.


User uploaded file

2 - apply Option #4, Rebuild Database.

On my version of iPhoto, the option is "Rebuild Database from Automatic Backup". I've done that, and the problem persists?

Try the following:


1 - delete the iPhoto preference file, com.apple.iPhoto.plist, that resides in your

User/Home/Library/ Preferences folder.


2 - delete the contents the following folder: User/Library/Containers/com.apple.iPhoto


User uploaded file


3 - reboot, launch iPhoto and try again.


NOTE: For Mavericks and Yosemite, go to your Home folder and use the View ➙ Show View Options menu to bring the this window:

User uploaded file

where you can check the Show Library Folder checkbox.

User uploaded file

OT-

On 10.6.8, no such folder, "{USER}/Library/Containers"

The reason I tried with a fresh login was to (try to) avoid user space issues.

Thanks for ongoing suggestions, though. I rely on this old OS and app.... I'd love to fix it!

Best,

W

I have exactly the same problem on my iMac running 10.6.8. However, I notice that my wife's MacBook, running 10.10.4, displays the maps in iPhoto using Apple maps, not Google maps. Does this mean that anyone using an older operating system that cannot use Apple Maps has lost the map fuctions from iPhoto and possibly other iLife applications? Perhaps I will have to forsake my favourite operating system after all.

Forgot about the older system. Look for the User/Home/Library/Caches/com.apple.iPhoto folder.

OT:

1. Found and removed the folder for the cache.

2. No improvement (still flashes a map image, then goes blank with pin at bottom-left).

3. As expected, since creating a fresh login then a new iPhoto library yielded the same problematic behavior. Since the iPhoto '11 code base hasn't had an update recently, I am fairly sure it must be a change in the delivery of the map data from Google.

Thanks anyway.

Best,

W

Oh, MY GOD! Just started experiencing the EXACT SAME problem yesterday, then searched Google and your post is the latest I could come across ever, one reporting exactly the same problem, the very fact seems incredible and I'm at least glad I'm not alone. My OS X is Lion, and I'm on the latest iPhoto '11 version (9.4.3). None of the suggestions (some of them originates as far back as from 2012!) helped me, including every one of list of steps mentioned by Old Toad. See my thread Re: Places work erratically. Isn't that a picture you're seeing too? Came to conclusion that it's Google's fault as they are apparently testing smth or tweaking yet again.

Same problem running iPhoto 11 (v9.4.3) on a 2011 Macbook Pro, 8Gb RAM w/10.8.5. This is the first real stumper that I've come across.

However, I've updated Google Earth a couple of times in the last 2 weeks via the Google Update Manager. I thought it would be safe to upgrade as I do not like upgrading -- unless absolutely necessary. I remember someone mentioning in the iPhoto 9 thread that the Map feature of iPhoto was a mini web app so to speak, so I cleared all the caches that I could find in Google Earth but still no go. Repaired my boot volume from the Recover Partition and repaired the permissions but still no map. I even waved a rubber chicken at the computer -- one of my Mac techs carried one in his 00001C1C repair kit for field work. However, this issue is impervious to plastic fowl.

So, I won't look at the problem for 2 weeks and see if it goes away. Plus I'll keep an eye on this thread. Silly computers! Have a great day ladies and gents!

Mark

After experiencing the same Google Maps issue with iPhoto '11, and, knowing that Apple has been moving everything away from Google Maps to Apple Maps, in some cases to avoid having to pay Google for the use of Google Maps in Apple applications (like iPhoto '11), I did the following experiment. My iMac has both a Mountain Lion (10.8.5) partition and a Yosemite (10.10.4) partition. I copied one of my iPhoto '11 libraries from the Mountain Lion partition to the Yosemite partition, and rebooted in Yosemite. When I open iPhoto 9.6.1, the iPhoto library is "upgraded" to work with iPhoto 9.6.1, and all of the map and geotag data are visible, unlike when the library was opened in iPhoto'11.


Since this first appeared on 1 July 2015, the most logical explanation is that, with 10.10.5 now in beta with the next version of Photos, Google Maps support for iPhoto '11 has ended effective the end of the day, 30 June 2015. So, I g 00004000 uess, it's time to embrace upgrading your operating system if you ever want to see your Places information again.


It will be interesting to see if Apple makes any official statement about the loss of Places information in iPhoto '11.

Yes. I have experienced the exact same thing. It started sometime around July 1. It's very frustrating, but I also plan to ignore it until Apple and Google resolve it or I upgrade OS. It's good to know that everyone with my version has the same issue, at least it's not me.

I wonder if it works in iPhoto 9.5 on Mavericks? If yes then I will make a bootable external HDD, as I don't want to abandon Lion and its apps completely.

After finding this discussion, I am glad that at least, I am not the only one who is having the same issue on iPhoto 9.4.3. I hope that it can be easily solved because I would not like to update my OS (I have mountain lion) neither my iPhoto. I am/was pretty happy with the combination iPhoto/Aperture and Google Maps. If they do not solve it I will consider to move my photos to Lightroom instead of upgrading to Yosemite.


Anyway I do not see Apple motivated about solving any issue on iPhoto furthermore when it is an old version. I bet for an answer like "update...."


Let's see!

Alvaro_MBP wrote:


I hope that it can be easily solved because I would not like to update my OS (I have mountain lion) neither my iPhoto. I am/was pretty happy with the combination iPhoto/Aperture and Google Maps.


Exactly. So am I. Just do not understand: Apple doesn't support iPhoto/Aperture (any version, let alone iPhoto'11 [in fact iPhoto'09]) anymore, so for Apple these two is kind of extinct software, why not keep things as they had been doing by the moment it abandoned them? Why not let old iPhoto and Aperture use Google Maps





data, while keeping existing course of development up?




Anyway I do not see Apple motivated about solving any issue on iPhoto furthermore when it is an old version. I bet for an answer like "update...."


Let's see!

I'm afraid my intuition tells me that any wait is hopeless.

It seems to be a general issue for every version of iPhoto using Google maps for this geolocalisation feature.


The service is broken for iPhoto 9.2.x under SnowLeopard and iPhoto 9.4.x under Lion, but it works for iPhoto 9.6.x (Mavericks) and newer


Use the feedback page to send a bug report to Apple as they don't read these forums

Apple doesn't have a clear option for providing feedback on iPhoto for OSX. Seems like they're only interested in the Photos app at this time?

I've about had it with Apple unilaterally pulling the plug on software features we've paid for! They've done it to me with their Airport utility losing support for early models of the Airport. Then they moved from mobile me to iCloud, killing my ability to easily sync contacts and calendars across the MANY Apple devices I purchased. Now it seems they're happily leaving those of us who purchased & use iPhoto in the dirt re: geo-tagging photos and who knows what other features.


You know what - i BOUGHT iLife, many many times, and for more than one computer. And I bought it with the expectation that I would be able to use it for as long as I cared to, and maybe have the OPTION of upgrading at a later date IF I CHOSE TO ! But Apple's policies don't align with that expectation. It is a HUGE disappointment, and I feel like I'm being forced to buy new hardware software in order to regain features I've already paid for.

I feel exactely like you. I am a big apple fan but i really do not like their policy and how their are releasing one OS per year leaving many old software without support. My opinion is that they should solve this issue because 3-4 years-old software is not old enough... but it is just my opinion.

If I have to move my photos to any other app i will choose lightroom. For sure I will not use an apple app anymore for this task.

Apple doesn't have a clear option for providing feedback on iPhoto for OSX.

Yes there is: either use http://www.apple.com/feedback/iphoto.html or create a Developer's account and send a formal bug report

Thanks!

what could be clearer and easier than clicking on the iPhoto menu and selecting "provide iPhoto feedback"?


LN

YYeah, wouldn't it be great if a web search on "Apple Feedback" provided such a straightforward option?


https://www.apple.com/feedback/

Don't take this the wrong way but have you looked at all of the menu option in iPhoto or the system or the apps you use regularly? So many users questions are answered there but many don't take the time to peruse the various menus to see what features are accessable thru them. I include myself in that group also.

It seems that the contract with google to use the API on iphoto ended this month.


As an example I rescued an article from gizmodo about maps on ios.

http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2012/09/apple-still-had-a-year-left-on-its-google-maps -contract/


As I wrote before, somewhere, I will not upgrade for the moment. I will see after they release El Capitan. Anyway, the old locations will always be there if i move my data to photos. Does any of you have experience?


Thanks for your help, I never though this forum worked so well.

It seems that the contract with google to use the API on iphoto ended this month.

But it still works on v9.6.1 on 10.10.4

Terence Devlin wrote:


It seems that the contract with google to use the API on iphoto ended this month.

But it still works on v9.6.1 on 10.10.4

But is it Google Maps on v9.6.1 or Apple Maps?

Good point, it sure looks like Apple Maps.

If you display The Places'map and do a right-click on it, you'll see that with the iPhoto versions compatible with Mavericks and higher, this location feature relies on Apple Maps instead of Google's

I'd like to dig out this contract to read what were the terms.

In that case, one solution could be upgrade to Mavericks (not to Yosemite), and upgrade to on v9.6.1??? That's possible?

Upgrading to Mavericks and iPhoto 9.5.1 could be a solution if Mavericks could still be downloaded from the Mac appStore.... but you can't find it anymore!

It might be possible to set up a proxy locally to fix the requests for Google maps, but based on a quick look with wireshark it's not 100% obvious which of the requests to Google is failing. In the short term, I am using Lightroom to show the mapping information for my pictures. Exporting from older iPhoto to versions to Lightroom works well, but new versions of iPhoto preclude that.

Exporting from older iPhoto to versions to Lightroom works well, but new versions of iPhoto preclude that.


There has never been a way to export from iPhoto to Lightroom. On the other hand, there is the possibility of exporting to the Finder and that's the same as it ever was, so I'm not clear on what you mean.

Older versions of iPhoto (up to 8.1.2 ('09)) stored most of the data, including tags or comments, in Finder-accessible formats that can be processed with 3rd party apps to achieve a compete export. I use Phoshare 1.5.1 myself which allows me to use iPhoto and Adobe Lightroom back-and-forth, by regularly organizing and exporting material from iPhoto and still retain the ability to modify the files later on with Lightroom (see http://code.google.com/p/phoshare/ ).

iPhoto 9 (that's v8.1.2) and iPhoto 11 store the files in precisely the same way. The developer of Phoshare - which is simply a way to export your photos to the Finder and nothing to do with Lightroom at all, ceased development of it as the feature it offered is included in the export panel of iPhoto11.

Don't forget this is about photo mapping. By the tool I mentioned, I found a way to move my iPhoto library to another tool that lets me do the geomapping and, better yet, I have a way to go back and forth. If this is helpful to somebody else, great. Why quibble about pedantic issues? Use my tip of discard it. That said, here are some further comments in response to your statements.


I have not attempted to compare how recent versions of iPhoto store image files: note that the issue is metadata, not (just) the photos themselves, so I am not sure you have made the comparison correctly. The Phoshare developer (Tilman) has explicitly stated that more "recent" iPhoto versions made it infeasible for his tool to extract metatdata and that's why he stopped development. A short quote is "With iPhoto 9.4, the amount of data shared with other applications has been greatly reduced, and some features have already been lost." You can read his posts here and there and specifically the blog post here: https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups=#!topic/phoshare-users/moWsMcD5SdQ

There is no point debating this.


Your comment about Phoshare being "nothing to do with Lightroom at all" is wrong. The topic I was addressing is the ability to export data (including full metadata, keywords, faces, etc) from iPhoto for use with other applications, and in my case Lightroom. Phoshare provides specific hooks that make sharing with Lightroom possible in a manner more flexible than just an "export". This is achieved using linked files (i.e. inode links) rather than copied files.


You seem to be right about Apple-Google deal expiration. It's up this year and if it expired in late June it explains the issue with no seeing locations in iPhoto and Aperture for Snow Leopard, Lion and Mountain Lion.


http://searchengineland.com/apple-google-deal-expires-will-win-safari-default-se arch-business-214277

I would happily pay for an upgrade to Mavericks (or to ANY Apple OS) ... isn't possible on my hardware. And I don't appreciate being "forced" to replace my hardware in order to retain software features I've already paid for.

I won't enter your quarrel as I don't think these forums should lead to such behaviors...


I only wanted to thank you for the tip about PhoShare, an application I didn't know before that will help me migrate my photo library to another software than the one provided by Apple (I don't want to rely anymore on Apple's software. Along the time I already had to migrate from Appleworks to Office, from /homepage to iWeb then from iWeb to Sandvox, from iDisk to OVH... just because oneday Apple decided they would abandon such feature or piece of software)

Sounds like the bottom line is that Apple and Google had a contract to co-support iPhoto (iLife?) for a specific timeframe, (which appears to have ended about (6/2015) that expired and now the feature is no longer available. Apple may or may not legally be permitted to rewrite support into the older apps that connects iPhoto to Maps. Or Google could perhaps offer to extend the terms. My system is complex and I don't have time to rebuild all the connected parts into a newer OS so that isn't currently an option. I'm a little annoyed that this goose egg was nesting and hidden in the system all this time.


I hope iPhoto is at least holding onto the location data, I'll be very annoyed if that is lost. A lot of work in making sure that was done correctly.It would be great to see the maps re-appear for me. Apple? Google? Don't you both have BILLIONS in cash? How easy might this be? Just agree to something and have a dev assign to vetting it for a day or a few to make sure an update won't interfere with anything. Do it for the digital faithful who've invested time into the tools.


Thanks all for the blog and info, good to know what happened to the Maps.

Just to let you know, I've discovered yersterday that the feature is back with the version of iPhoto running with OS X Mountain Lion (eventhough it's still relying on Google Maps datas.


It's still not working with iPhoto on MacOs X SnowLeopard...


(I don't know with Lion, as I don't have any Mac running Lion)

I've discovered yersterday that the feature is back with the version of iPhoto running with OS X Mountain Lion (eventhough it's still relying on Google Maps datas.

That is good news. Which iPhoto version is that exactly?

Remy Leroy wrote:


Just to let you know, I've discovered yersterday that the feature is back with the version of iPhoto running with OS X Mountain Lion (eventhough it's still relying on Google Maps datas.


It's still not working with iPhoto on MacOs X SnowLeopard...


It's not in Lion either, just checked it up, v.9.4.3

iPhoto 9.4.3 on OS X Mountain Lion but.... it worked yesterday, it doesn't work anymore today 😕

The joy was short-lived. Are you sure the feature was back as Google Maps view?

User uploaded file


Definitely! It was GoogleMaps.


As you can see, when you search for a location, you still get Google results

On Sunday I obtained the location I was searching for and the map was displayed (either the standard or the satellite one) with the Google copyright on the lower left corner of the map.


Yersterday when I tried to make a screenshot, it didn't work anymore.


Maybe on sunday, I reached a proxy somewhere on the net, that still had the Google datas in a cache of some sort...

Terence, I read some of your posts and they are always useful.

I have OSX 10.9.5 and iPhoto '11 9.4.3.

I can not get places to work.

Is there any software version that would solve the issue without upgrading to Yosemite and using Photos?

With kind regards

I'll try to answer for Terence. if you can't see locations on 9.4.3, then chances are you can on iPhotos 9.5 via Apple (not Google) Maps. Both versions are compatible with Mavericks.

iPhoto 9.4.3 and earlier use Google maps for the locations feature. Apple has not renewed it's agreement with Google regarding Google maps so that feature is broken in iPhoto 9.4.1 and earlier.


For iPhoto 9.5.1 and later, including Photos, the locations feature uses Apple's Maps.


Since you have 9.4.3 you should be able to upgrade to Yosemite and get iPhoto 9.6.1 by following he directions posted by Tererence Devlin in this post:

Terence Devlin

Apr 14, 2015 11:21 AM

Re: Is Iphoto gone ? i want it back!

in response to Johannes666

Recommended


Go to the App Store and check out the Purchases List. If iPhoto is there then it will be v9.6.1


If iPhoto 9.6.1 is there, close the App Store, drag your existing iPhoto app (not the library, just the app) to the trash and then go back to the App Store.


Install the App from the App Store.


Sometimes iPhoto is not visible on the Purchases List. it may be hidden. See this article for details on how to unhide it.


http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4928


One question often asked: Will I lose my Photos if I reinstall?


iPhoto the application and the iPhoto Library are two different parts of the iPhoto programme. So, reinstalling the app should not affect the Library. BUT you should always have a back up before doing this kind of work. Always.

User uploaded file

Thanks Old Toad.

I can see iPhoto on my purchase list but the grey button on the right says "INSTALLED" hence is not hidden but it does not allow me to upgrade from 9.4.3 to 9.5.1. or later (I might miss some simple step but it just does not allow me to do anything with iPhoto on the App Store).

Do I understand correctly that you are suggesting that since I have iPhoto 9.4.3 even if I upgrade to Yosemite I should be able to get iPhoto 9.6.1. and not Photos? Will this solve the issue i.e. keep iPhoto with locations?

You must be running Yosemite before you'll be able to download 9.6.1.

I am now running Yosemite. I go to app store and to list of purchased apps and it shows iPhoto with the "open" tag but when I click nothing happens...

The issue is solved. i had some iPhoto version running on the background. Many thanks LarryHN and Old Toad for help!!!

You are welcome


LN

Agree! So tired.. but it's a society problem..


I'm a hardware guy.. so programming is only basic level... I do believe I found the basic level of the problem and found a way to verify that it is not a BUG or other kind of malfunction... simply an expired account..


file:///Applications/iPhoto.app/Contents/Resources/googleMap.html


this is what I believe to be the file that actually displays the map in iPhoto 11. It's inside the iPhoto App itself.


Put the HTML file in a browser and it gives you the error message as to why it will not display the map..


https://developers.google.com/maps/documentation/javascript/error-messages?hl=en


don't suppose anyone could modify this file to use a correct userID from Google.??



as soon as a majority of users refuse to grab their ankles and buy what ever big companies tell them to buy, (in order to more and more easily FORCE them to upgrade and let go of what they deem obsolete) we will have this problem. In reality it should be illegal and considered fraud.. I own have owned and support litterally hundreds of devices thru the years (it's my job!) I've quit! I will QUIT using things when I fail at making them work the way they did when I purchaced them. I havn't the energy to bang my head against a wall, but I will not contribute to this insane problem.. I suppose this belongs in a thread of it's own but again.. no desire to put endless hours into combatting this issue.

Paul Fisher wrote:




as soon as a majority of users refuse to grab their ankles and buy what ever big companies tell them to buy, (in order to more and more easily FORCE them to upgrade and let go of what they deem obsolete) we will have this problem. In reality it should be illegal and considered fraud..

Thanks for your insightful observation and this important note. It confirmed what we've come to conclusion of.

Just would like to specify what exactly do you consider "fraud" and "illegal"? The fact that in your own words "a majority of users refuse to grab their ankles and buy what ever big companies tell them to buy" or big companies policy?


Thanks.

I.S.

OK you asked for it.. 🙂


When I choose to buy product, I weigh the advantages, disadvantages, price etc. When the manufacturer decides to change what I decided to buy into something completely different and take away features/functions or the ability to use it what so ever, I consider this fraudulent. If they leased it to me another story. As users have stated, they paid for iLife, was promised Faces, Places, etc. suddenly (without prior warning) the faces feature is unusable, not because of a bug, but by a deliberate action. They could at least acknowledge the issue and release a patch to put a static map, but NO they just give you a white screen and silence.


I bought a TV from Sony that had the feature to watch YouTube videos. 2 years later the icon has a note next to it, "after the 15 April 2015 this device can no longer play videos from YouTube". This is a firmware upgradable TV.. did they attempt to patch? did they apologize and offer any solution or compensation? NO.. silence and blame YouTube.. They are sure that people will realize they just have to go buy a whole new TV to get the function they already paid for.


I feel that I should not be required to upgrade my OS to retain features that I paid for. I should absolutely not lose functions by upgrading my software, When the hardware (supposedly, but often not factually) no longer can run the latest OS you end up with a brick. (example Core Duo machines that can't be updated yet are fully capable). Windows will run on almost any hardware and vice versa. XP from many years ago can be run on a modern PC (here I am NOT an expert). I'm not asking them to support old hardware, just not to purposely make it obsolete by PULLING functions completely, or disabling things that could easily be patched when a contract runs out. A large influential company such as Apple or Sony has both the power and the resources to do these things, but choose not to in order to boost sales of newer devices. Unethical, environmentally unsound and downright WRONG to force hardware upgrades. On the flipside, on iOS devices one may NEVE even downgrade to make the device as it was when when it was purchased (bug free and fast usually) .. (iPhone 3G on iOS 6, iPhone 4 on iOS 7) for example. what about forcing IOS7 upgrade in order to CONTINUE using FaceTime? iPhone 4 became slow as molasses on iOS7... .


I'm not good at writing these things off the top of my head, but rest assured I am an expert and been in contact with thousands of Apple users whom I have had to give bad news to in one way or another.


Besides all this.... Why should users be forced to keep re-educating themselves every time there is some change. Wasn't the original idea of an Apple product that you could forget all the tech stuff and just get down to business using it. The machine shouldn't interfere with your creativity and concentration. And shouldn't be a burden on you to constantly solve problems.. Seriously I wish they would just slow down, fix some bugs and optimise without adding every feature that some tech nerd thinks of.

Completely with you on this one. Just my thoughts, only wrapped better.

When the manufacturer decides to change what I decided to buy into something completely different and take away features/functions or the ability to use it what so ever, I consider this fraudulent. If they leased it to me another story.


All software is leased on every OS and every system. You never own the software, just a licence to use it as is. In other words, they did lease it to you. Also, the license you agree to covers all of this. These are large multi-national corporations with thousands of employees, some of whom are lawyers. I don't think you can bandy legal terms like "fraudulent" around when you previously agreed to the license - which you did when you installed the application. You can't have it both ways. You don't own iPhoto or it's capability. You leased the opportunity to use it.


Can you explain to me how not renewing the licence from Google and instead replacing with the Apple version of the service, for free, forces you to buy new hardware?


I feel that I should not be required to upgrade my OS to retain features that I paid for.


As the OS is free, it's hard to agree. The features are still available to you, just in a slightly different format. The reality is that software evolves very rapidly. It's not a slow semi-moribund technology like television or washing machines.

Example of having to buy new hardware. I have a Macbook Core Duo that runs iLife, but can not upgrade beyond 10.6.8, another Macbook Pro that is Core2Duo that can not upgrade beyond 10.7.5. Both machines can run PAID FOR OS and iLife, but the feature of Places is gone. Only solution is to buy new hardware. I would be happy with a Static Map of the world so I could just click on a country to see photos from that country, no need for satellite or topographical information.


from Wikipedia iLife page

iLife '11: PowerPC Macs are not compatible with iLife '11. Although iLife '11 originally supported Snow Leopard, the latest updates to iPhoto and iMovie require Yosemite whilst Garageband requires Mavericks.



Guess I got too close to the truth. My post was promptly deleted for being off topic or not technical.. It was very much on topic and technical. If only other issues were dealt with as quickly as deleting uncomfortable posts here.

So, you run much older hardware? Eventually it loses capability. The software evolves and the hardware can't keep up. Web services are not offered in perpetuity, no one could. Apple offer a free upgrade path for both of those Oses, and for that version of iPhoto. Indeed it now offers a free alternative. But if you choose to run old hardware it is inevitable that you get left behind one day. As you said yourself:


If they leased it to me another story.


They do, and continue to do so. You just run hardware that can't do that.

Do you think we could find the new URL pointing to Apple Maps Web service in a more recent version of iPhoto and patch this file in iPhoto 9.2.3?

What disappoint me the most is that Apple didn't send any notice to iPhoto users when the GoogleMap Web Service has been stopped...

(I know many friends who spent hours trying to restore a "normal" behavior of iPhoto, by reinstalling the software, creating new user session to compare with their current session, reparing permissions, restoring their hard drive from a previous backup, reinstalling MacOS X...)

I understand that we only "rent" a software license, but what would you think if, after renting a car, the company you rent the car from decided to remove the spare wheel or the back seat?

I look at a way to replace the GoogleMap.html and GoogleSearch.html files found in the package of iPhoto 9.2 to 9.4 by the equivalent from iPhoto 9.5.... to no avail!

GoogleMap. html and googleSearch.html are JavaScripts written to access the Google Web Services.


There's no equivalent in iPhoto 9.5 to access the Apple Map services :-(



Doing this, I noticed that the maps from Apple Maps are provided by TomTom... I'm afraid that the day Apple will decide not to prorogate the contract with TomTom, we will face the same kind of difficulties with "old" Macs (but also "old" iPhones or iPads), with softwares such as iPhotos, Photos, Aperture but Maps too, that will stop working if you cannot upgrade to the brand new version of OS X or iOS to use the freshly updated versions of these softwares

YES!

I have just made it work.


I'm on a white macbook running 10.7.5 with iPhoto 9.4.3


Thanks to Paul I had an idea. What if we just ignored Apple's expired API and used our own, private and free from Google. Turns out it works.


Here's what you have to do:

0- Close iPhoto

1- Create a google account or use your own

2- Access Google's developers console HERE

3- Create a project (any name)

4- Activate a Google Maps Javascript API

5- Generate your own API key

6- Go to folder /Applications/iPhoto.app/Contents/Resources/googleMap.html

7- Edit the googleMap.html (I've used an application called TextWrangler)

8- Change this src="http://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/js?v=3&client=gme-appleinc&sensor=false"> to this src="https://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/js?key=YOUR_KEY_HERE&signed_in=true&sensor=false">

9- Save your freshly edited googleMap.html

10- Open iPhoto and enjoy.


Take that Apple.

User uploaded file

That is just marvelous! 🙂

I could not get iPhoto 9.4.3 to work again on El Capitan, it keeps crashing in MacOS X 10.11.2, but your fix is working well with Aperture 3.4.5 as well. I am so glad!

Thanks to your work-around I could bring back the terrain data to the Aperture maps in Aperture 3.4.5. Apple's new maps are horribly plain and lacking in detail, so it is nearly impossible to assign locations to photos taken outside the cities.


User uploaded file

I saw this and was hoping so much that it would work for me. Sadly, I can't get it to work. I am running iPhoto '09 version 8.1.2 on OS 10.6.8.


I created a project and enabled the JavaScript API but did not know what "credentials" I was supposed to use. I thought a server request was the most logical. This is what the file looks like in TextWrangler:

<script type="text/javascript" src="http://www.google.com/jsapi?key=[LON 00004000 G_CHARACTER_STRING]"></script>

<script language="Javascript" type="text/javascript">

//<![CDATA[

google.load("maps", "2", {"other_params" : "client=appleinc"});

I copied and pasted the API character string in and changed the client name to the API I created (I didn't know which I needed to use, the project name or the specific API name, and tried both).


IT DID NOT WORK. Worse, it created a huge error upon trying to quit iPhoto: The main panel went blank, but the rest of the application window remained open. I had to force quit every time. The only way iPhoto quit properly was by restoring "appleinc" to the client name. So I'm back to status quo ante.


If I knew beyond the shadow of a doubt that this worked for iPhoto '11, I would reluctantly install it (from iLife '11 CD, and then hopefully though Software Update) and make the code change. (I had a bad experience trying to upgrade last time I tried.) But I really really want to get it to work in what I have if I can.

I would reluctantly install it (from iLife '11 CD, and then hopefully though Software Update) and make the code change.


I would not try this. iPhoto is no longer developed and folks doing what you're thinking of find themselves unable to update.

Could you be more specific as to what king of API key should be generated - browser, server etc, what?

Hi jeffdm,

It seems from your snapshot of the code you didn't copy all that needed to be copied properly.

Your generated API key should be pasted into that googleMap.html file along with &signed_in=true&sensor=false portion of the new string so what you should've had looks like

src="https://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/js?key=YOUR_KEY_HERE&signed_in=true&sensor=false

make sure you're not missing that green part. I edited the file in Terminal using nano editor.


Also speaking of the type of the API key I selected ''Browser" not "Server". Skip that part where they offer to set up credential for you (by just clicking "Skip"). The key will be automatically generated on the go.

User uploaded fileUser uploaded file

I am trying CottonX's workaround, but I do not have this folder:

6- Go to folder /Applications/iPhoto.app/Contents/Resources/googleMap.html


In my applications folder, I have an iPhoto.app file, but no subfolders. I'm using OSC 10.9.5 and iPhoto 11.


Any ideas?

Right-click iPhoto.app, then select Get Contents - >Contents--> Resources, there you'll find that file.

In my applications folder, I have an iPhoto.app file, but no subfolders. I'm using OSC 10.9.5 and iPhoto 11.

Your iPhoto.app is a bundled package, that looks like a single file. Select iPhoto.app, then ctrl-click or right-click it.

Select "Show Package Contents" from the menu that will pop up. Be very careful, when you modify or remove files. It would be safer to create a copy of iPhoto.app before you try the fix.

Thanks, that works! Pins are a little flaky, and I can't search for new Google places using the find function, but I'm happy to have my places pins back 🙂

Thanks to CottonX for figuring this out! 🙂

Yeah, the only downside of this method is its failure to search for and pin new places. Don't get why, shouldn't we have that ability as Google API users?


Any ideas about a workaround to make that work? Further manipulations with the file structure or smth?

Thanks for the additional guidance.


I found a slightly different workaround via the MacRumors website and right now, while I do not have an API key in the code string, I do have map viewability. However, every time I try to drop a new pin, iPhoto locks up and I have to force quit. Do you have the ability to create new pins, or are you just salvaging what was already created?


I was having better success just a few weeks ago when the entire Places system was working (and I was overjoyed), but apparently if I leave iPhoto open too long it "loses" the Internet connection and making new places doesn't work. Seeing a map with existing pins is better than where I would be without any workaround at all, but I wish I could place new pins.

Hi! I'm on Snow Leopard and my Aperture version is 3.2.4. I tried to change the string as you recommended but it doesn't work... Any suggestion? Thank You!!

Have you performed all the necessary steps to get Google's API for its Maps?

I hope! I've enabled the Google Maps Javascript APIs, then I've created a new key (for browser), then i changed the code inside Aperture -> resources -> googleMap.html following cotton-x's instructions. The code that I've found in googleMap.html differs slightly from the one posted by cotton-x:

my file reports that string

<script type="text/javascript" src="http://www.google.com/jsapi?key=ABQIAAAAUf_qajf1-p8SUXIhbPrkJRSdqNO9DHQ3Pe7dmEbj ibfx65pwcBRkf2BLR1Z-ToHuZvgRRBJksKA-WQ"></script>


so I changed it in src="https://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/js?key=and then pasting my key followed by &signed_in=true&sensor=false">.


Before patching googleMap.html, when selecting Places from Aperture's inspector, the app showed me that message:

User uploaded file

And after the patch, Places is blank and no message is showed.

Maybe that patch doesn't work for Aperture 3.2.4?

Please could someone send me a googleMap.html not pached from a newer Aperture version? Thanks!!

Thank you léonie I started my search from the discussion you just linked but it didn't worked 😟

THANK YOU LEONIE!

Finally, that solved my problem 🙂

I placed my google api key in your file and now it works like a charm

In fact the code inside the two googleMap.html has some big differences, and the one coming within my googleMap.html version was really obsolete. I have too much hardware that is no longer supported by OS newer than the good old 10.6.8, so I'm forced to stay with it...

Thank you again léonie!!



User uploaded file

You're welcome 🙂

Althought it seems you've manage to resolve your issue I put into my 2 cents. You said you pasted the portion &signed_in=true&sensor=false">. Did you pasted the closing tag </script> at the end of the line as well? You have to be extremely careful when dealing with code. That could be a reason of your initial failure to properly modify the googleMaps.html file.


Also could you, please report if adding new pins DOESN'T work?

Of course, I didn't changed code that was unnecessary to change, including the closing tag. It wasn't an issue due to syntax as much as the html code itself.

Here my original html, notice that it differs from léonie's one.

... And adding new pins DOESN'T work. Maybe the same patch need to be applied to /Contents/Resources/GoogleSearch.html.

I can't help you because I'm sure my GoogleSearch.html is outdated like the other file. If you could send me a GoogleSearch.html from Aperture 9.4.3 I'll try to patch it and see if assign locations will work again.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/w0iogbvt3d0opj1/googleMap-original.html?dl=0

P.S.

I don't like to assign location from Aperture because data isn't stored in the image exif, so when exporting the pictures they come out without geolocalization...

Hi Topolinux,


Here's a link to download a copy of the file GoogleSearch.html of iPhoto.app 9.4.3 package: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0Bwsy7q2Qc3TCb1lkRjdNNWRqU1k/view?usp=sharing


Please update if you come up with some results that would satisfy you.


Oops, I misremembered what you asked:


Here's another for Aperture's 3.4.5 GoogleSearch.html:

https://drive.google.com/open?id=0Bwsy7q2Qc3TCb1lkRjdNNWRqU1k

I suspect it's identical to iPhoto's one.

Hi scrutinizer82, the GoogleSearch.html files are all identical in Aperture 3.2.4, 3.4.5 and iPhoto versions. Unfortunately the search engine works bad: I can search and find only cities, but is not possible resize areas around pins or search for addresses and streets, patching or not patching the GoogleSearch.html code...

Finally, it is not a such bad deal because now we can see our pictures locations again INSIDE Aperture/iPhoto... 🙂


For geotagging images I'm currently using Photolinker that works like a charm.

Topolinux wrote:


I can search and find only cities, but is not possible resize areas around pins or search for addresses and streets, patching or not patching the GoogleSearch.html code...


Then you're lucky because when I copy pasted that same already modified API code from googleMaps.html (of iPhoto.app) into GoogleSearch.html it made no difference in that I still didn't regained option to search for and tag new locations be it cities or areas except those that are showing up in Manage my Places.

scrutinizer82 wrote:

Then you're lucky because when I copy pasted that same already modified API code from googleMaps.html (of iPhoto.app) into GoogleSearch.html it made no difference in that I still didn't regained option to search for and tag new locations be it cities or areas except those that are showing up in Manage my Places.



Hmm... That sound strange... I show you what happens when I search a place from the Places window (Aperture): here the search engine found some results, and when I have selected Phuket it placed a blue pin on the map. Pressing "assign location" effectively assigns that pin to a previously selected image.


User uploaded file


The same happens when I search a place from the Inspector -> metadata tab. Again, if I press the "V" button the new location is stored. I can move the pin from that tab but no way to adjust the size of the circle around the pin (in fact, there is NO circle area). Moving the pin and saving the new location makes effective change of the location name and of the pin location.

User uploaded file


If I try to assign a location from the Project view -> information popup window of a project, I'm only able to find a place. No way to move the pin and rename it.


User uploaded file

Thank you léonie! Apparently my attempt at creating the API + credentials didn't work but your file did. This worked for iPhoto 8.1.2 and Snow Leopard.

Hello,

it seems that I am using exactly the same configuration as yours :

iPhoto 8.1.2 and Snow Leopard, creating the API + credentials, changing the code of googlemap.html from

src="http://www.google.com/jsapi?key=ABQIAAAAUf_qajf1-p8SUXIhbPrkJRSdqNO9DHQ3Pe7dmEbj ibfx65pwcBRkf2BLR1Z-ToHuZvgRRBJksKA-WQ"

to

src="http://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/js?key=my_key&signed_in=true&sensor=false"


but I am unable to find the file from Léonie which works for you. Could you send a link toward it or correct the wrong code ?

Thanks by advance

Many thanks to you Léonie for that link towards a working googlemap.html file.

It works as a charm for me, but when I try to replace your key by my personnal one, it does not work !!!??

I am in the same configuration ( iPhoto 8.0.2 and SnowLeopard ) than Greg Kolar (page8).

Can I continue to use it with your key (it is really occasionnally) or should I try to ask google a new API key with other choices (Server instead of browser ? other ?).

Thanks anyway to have permitted to recover this great feature of locating a picture from iPhoto.

I also bought Houda Geo which fullfills my need by locating a picture (and changing its tag) from a GPS track log of the same time period.

Can I continue to use it with your key (it is really occasionnally) or should I try to ask google a new API key with other choices (Server instead of browser ? other ?).

Don't ask, just use it as long as you need it.

But try to get your own API key to work, to be on the safe side. It is disconcerting, that your own key is not working.


I also bought Houda Geo which fullfills my need by locating a picture (and changing its tag) from a GPS track log of the same time period.

Houdah Geo is great. I am using JetPhoto Studio for geocoding. I like to assign the GPS before I import the photos to my Photo Libraries. This way the GPS is embedded in the master files.Jetphoto can also do reverse geocoding and write the address to the descriptions. And create GoogleMaps with pins for the photo locations. That is why I applied for the API key originally.

Thank you for answer and permission ; I will try again with a new key.

Houda Geo do include latitude and longitude to the photos from a GPS's recorded track, but the process to add these metadatas to the existing pictures in "Photos" library is a little bit complicated :

- export the picture from "Photos"

- Geocode the picture with Houda Geo and GPS recorded track.

- import the geocoded picture into "Photos"

- Suppress the original picture not geocoded.


Of course I could upgrade the Mac Os to Sierra which is said to allow modifications of "Photos" database ... but some softwares I own would need upgrade too

Houda Geo do include latitude and longitude to the photos from a GPS's recorded track, but the process to add these metadatas to the existing pictures in "Photos" library is a little bit complicated :

That is why I add the GPS to the photos before importing to Photos, if possible.


If you can extract the latitude and and longitude from a track or from a photo taken at the same time, you can type the latitude and longitude directly into the Info panel for a photo, where it says "Add a location". enter first the latitude in degrees, then a space character and the longitude. Photos in El Capitan will look up the place and add it.


If the track is in .gpx format, you can read it in Textedit, if all fails. My .gpx track looks like this - just a simple list of latitude, longitude , and elevation, followed by the date and time in UTC.

<trk>

<name>ACTIVE LOG082903</name>

<trkseg>

<trkpt lat="64.212469" lon="-20.740140">

<ele>119.362</ele>

<time>2015-08-19T08:29:03Z</time>

</trkpt>

<trkpt lat="64.212531" lon="-20.740141">

<ele>104.237</ 00004000 ele>

<time>2015-08-19T08:30:27Z</time>

</trkpt>

<trkpt lat="64.212561" lon="-20.740029">

<ele>107.718</ele>

<time>2015-08-19T08:37:54Z</time>

</trkpt>. .....


It is easy to scroll down to the time I want (minus time zone offset to UTC) and to copy the latitude and longitude directly from the track.

WOnderfull it worked