Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Time Machine not a true backup?

This past weekend, I happened to notice that 3 Events in iPhoto from last summer were missing, about 500 photos worthy. I did extensive system searches, but couldn't come up with anything. So I tried to restore them from Time Machine, assuming that at some point, my toddler must have deleted them from my current iPhoto. But even the oldest backup on my Time Machine, which was from April, didn't have them.


This leads me to a few conclusions. Tell me if I'm thinking correctly:

1. The missing Events must have been deleted before the oldest back-up - meaning they got deleted sometime before April 24.

2. I've had my Mac since December, but in June, I was notified that the external hard drive Time Machine was using was full. I gave Time Machine the go-ahead to start overwriting the oldest files.

3. But it appears that because I was overwriting backups, I also permanently lost my pictures.


If those assumptions are all true, then:

1. The external hard drive Time Machine is using is 150G. Is there a way I can use that space more efficiently so I have more than a four-six month window into the past?

2. Maybe most importantly: It seems like Time Machine isn't really a great back-up system. It doesn't have an archive of every file I've ever had - like the old HP Simple Save drive I used to use with my PC. It only has archives from the last few months. Do savy Mac users use a separate hard drive - or the Cloud - to store file duplicates?


I'm sick over the loss of my pictures, but I've accepted there is nothing I can do at this point. I'm trying to make sure it doesn't happen again. I feel like I trusted Time Machine and it let me down, but that might be because I thought it was doing something that it really wasn't.


Many thanks.


Kelly

47 replies

i had the same problem. No iPhotos. I lost a truly beautiful collection and many of my grandchildren and a late, best friend. It was awful. I just tried to backup on a Kingston thumb drive and it said it was backing up but when i opened the Kingston, just a few, random things were saved. Think i'll pass on the El Capitan beta, although i enjoyed Yosemite beta, since i do not want to lose my photos.

Time Machine has changed the idea of what a backup is. Before Time Machine, anyone who had even a single backup was a power-user. Professional backup systems costing thousands of dollars would give you maybe a week's worth of backups, asssuming you remembered to swap the tapes every night. Now, people don't notice that files have been deleted for 3 months and blame Time Machine.


The biggest issue here is that your Time Machine backup is way too small. For a Time Machine 150GB in size, you should be backing up a hard drive no larger than 50 GB. I suspect your ha 00004000 rd drive is much larger than 50 GB. Get a bigger Time Machine drive if you want it to keep more than 3 months of backups.


I am curious about your question:

Do savy Mac users use a separate hard drive - or the Cloud - to store file duplicates?


You should only use Time Machine with a separate hard drive. It should be 3 times the size of all the data you are backing up.

I am curious about your question:

Do savy Mac users use a separate hard drive - or the Cloud - to store file duplicates?


You should only use Time Machine with a separate hard drive. It should be 3 times the size of all the data you are backing up.

My fault; I didn't ask clearly.


I was trying to ask what savy Mac users do for back-up. Do they have a 1TB external hard drive for Time Machine to use so they can have more room available? Or do they have a SEPARATE hard drive to use as an archive for important files and/or do they back-up important files to the Cloud?

As etresoft says, you want your backup on physically separate media. If you are just using a partition on your boot drive, and that drive dies, you loose your backup and hence everything.


I think ideally you would want an external drive of 2-3 times or even larger for your backup (the larger the drive the further back in time you can go in Time Machine to recover any given file). That drive really should be dedicated to backups only (not used partially as just extra space).


My old MBP only has a 320Gb drive, but I use a 750Gb partition on an external drive for time machine (remaining partition is for a full bootable system clone).


And for truly irreplaceable files, those you just cannot deal with loosing, then redundancy is a must. So that means putting those on something else (another drive is good, small portable hard drives being useful for this - updated maybe weekly but otherwise stored safely away from the primary backup).


I use two portable bus powered drives for my redundant backups, both full system clones. Each gets updated every week, but otherwise one lives in my filing cabinet at work, and the other in my firesafe at home. Being bus powered, they just plug into the data ports, and update (I have both SuperDuper and CarbonCopyCloner for making bootable system clones).


We all spend thousands on our computers, more on our camera and video cameras, and more on other gadgets, but so many people bawk at spending a few hundred dollars on some redundant hard drives to safe guard their data and files. Its penny wise and pound foolish as sooner or later you are either going to absolutely need that backup, or highly regret not having it.


P.S. so I guess I have about $350 or less invested in backup media (each of the portables was around $100 for 500Gb drives, and the 1Tb WD MyBook was less than $150 ?? not absolutely sure as I've had them all for awhile, but I think that is about right for prices at the time.

To clarify: I am using a separate 150G external hard drive that is set aside soley for Time Machine. I'm not using my boot drive, nor is my external drive partitioned.


And I already have a second external hard drive that I use for archival purposes. It's a back-up of important files (mostly picturse and videos) that I typically update about 4x a year. It just hadn't gotten updated for a while because 1. my old PC laptop was stolen in December, so 2. it took me a number of months to get everything transitioned over to my new iMac and then 3. I didn't do it immediately because I thought Time Machine would cover me for a while.


And obviously, it did. It's just that my files got deleted a while ago, and I didn't notice, and by the time I did, Time Machine had moved on. I realize it's a perfect storm of events here, not something "wrong" with Time Machine. But that's also why I'm interested in getting advice about the best way to move forward, so this doesn't happen again.

I agree with etresoft that your backup disk seems a bit small -I have found references in the internets that you should at least have 1.5x the disk you are backing up.

If you are looking, though, for an option that deletes no files no matter what you might want to check

www.crashplan.com

as I plan to do (if you use your own disk its free -suggested by Lifehacker).

Kelly @ I Need More Sun wrote:


Do they have a 1TB external hard drive for Time Machine to use so they can have more room available? Or do they have a SEPARATE hard drive to use as an archive for important files and/or do they back-up important files to the Cloud?

Yes to all.

Kelly, look at how far back your Time Machine backups go now with the 150Gb drive - now figure how much further back your saved backups would have gone had you had 6-7 times that much storage space before TM started deleting the oldest backups.

Kelly @ I Need More Sun wrote:


To clarify: I am using a separate 150G external hard drive that is set aside soley for Time Machine. I'm not using my boot drive, nor is my external drive partitioned.


And I already have a second external hard drive that I use for archival purposes. It's a back-up of important files (mostly picturse and videos) that I typically update about 4x a year. It just hadn't gotten updated for a while because 1. my old PC laptop was stolen in December, so 2. it took me a number of months to get everything transitioned over to my new iMac and then 3. I didn't do it immediately because I thought Time Machine would cover me for a while.


And obviously, it did. It's just that my files got deleted a while ago, and I didn't notice, and by the time I did, Time Machine had moved on. I realize it's a perfect storm of events here, not something "wrong" with Time Machine. But that's also why I'm interested in getting advice about the best way to move forward, so this doesn't happen again.

Use a much larger drive for Time Machine, at the very least make it 3 times the size of the internal, more is better here.

Hi Kelly


This thread has been helpful to me as well.


I just got a 3tb seagate drive at costco for $129 which is awfully cheap and well worth the investment. (external space gets cheaper by the day...). My current iMac HD takes up a tad less than 1tb, so my TM backup is roughly three times the size of what it needs. I'm new to TM backup, as in the past I always manually copied my Docs, photos, music, etc over every couple month to a external, but I think I will do both now. TM for hourly/daily/monthly and then move absoultely vital stuff every Quarter for permanent archive.

That's exactly what I'm doing right now, Dennis. Time Machine is efficient. But it didn't work for me, because I wasn't aware that something had gotten deleted.


So now, I use Time Machine as an emergency backup. And every few months, I make a secondary archival backup, using good old copy and paste, of all my important files, which are mostly photos and videos.

Since you asked for opinions: I choose not to use Time Machine at all; however, I have 3 external drives @ 1 TB, each with several partitions and containing 2 bootable clones of each system I have (Snow Leopard, Lion, Mountain Lion). Additionally, I have extra drag 'n drop copies of all my pics, and any/all personal/financial files and, once a year, I make a "year-end" copy of anything important and burn that to DVDs.

I use a 2TB drive to back up two Macs with Time Machine. This gives me several months of backup per Mac. One of the reasons this works for me is that I have used the Options button in Time Machine to exclude folders I back up separately because they are huge files (like Windows virtual machines) that I back up separately. I don't want Time Machine churning on those huge files and piling up backups of them.


It's important to remember the difference between a backup and an archive. It sounds like you know that because you're already keeping a separate archive drive. The files on the archive drive won't get deleted when Time Machine runs out of space on the backup drive.

Kelly @ I Need More Sun wrote:

I was trying to ask what savy Mac users do for back-up. Do they have a 1TB external hard drive for Time Machine to use so they can have more room available? Or do they have a SEPARATE hard drive to use as an archive for important files and/or do they back-up important files to the Cloud?


I have the Time Machine backup so I can get to versions of files. But I also maintain two bootable clones per Mac that are created with SuperDuper, and one of each Mac's clone drives is rotated off site so that if my home is completely destroyed or burglarized, I still have a complete bootable system that can be attached to a new Mac and used immediately.

I used to use a 4TB drive for my time machine. that is untill my mac died :'(

You should only use Time Machine with a separate hard drive. It should be 3 times the size of all the data you are backing up.


Etresoft: could you briefly say why the separate hard drive needs to be three times the size of the data being backed up? I'm not questioning the veracity of your comment - I'm just curious to know. I could guess that twice the size is important, because of swapping etc, but why three times?

Having it 3x the size is the general recommendation; it has nothing to do with swaps, but with the fact of how far back you want/need your backups to go. The first time TM will create one entire backup; after that, incrementally just the new additions. It will keep doing that until the disk is almost full - it will then delete the oldest backup to make room for the newest update, and so on and so forth. If you don't care about older backups, 2 x the size is fine - but if you do, then 3x is recommended.


I don't need anything but the latest backup, so I just use bootable clones.

As babowa suggested, it is just a rule of thumb. You can get away with less, but you are more likely to experience problems. For example, if you only have used 300 GB of a 1 TB drive, you could get away with a 1 TB Time Machine drive.


Just remember that Time Machine works best the less you mess with it. People who report problems invariably have done some sort of customization to the process.

Thanks for the clarification. I have two external 2TB hard drives, one for TM backups and one for a SuperDuper bootable clone that I make every couple of weeks.


But since I have about 750GB of data, I guess my next external drive will have to be bigger.


Thanks again, and to etresoft.

And remember TM is an incremental backup, not archival. Regardless of the size of the backup drive TM will be deleting older backups.


FromMac Basics: Time Machine

Time Machine keeps hourly backups for the past 24 hours, daily backups for the past month, and weekly backups until your backup drive is full.

So you will not have hour by hour backups except for the current day, and daily's will only go back a month no matter how big the drive you are backing up to.


Weekly backups are the only thing affected by drive size.

Sorry for your loss, but your anger/grief etc. should be directed firmly towards Cupertino HQ because it's their incompetence that has caused your loss.


Apple makes it so easy to use TimeMachine, it's a frigging nagware that works every time a new drive is connected, so people do it and they mistakenly assume everything will remain on the TM drive, but it doesn't.


That's not your fault, it's Apple's for not covering all the bases and alerting you that old data is about to be removed.



Review your backup options and choose a combination of backups that don't include TimeMachine.


Most commonly used backup methods

That is patently ridiculous. Did you even read what the original poster said?


Someone buys a new Mac in December, 2011 and backs up a 500 GB or 1 TB drive to a 150 GB drive. How is that even possible? Did the original poster have to go in and exclude a bunch of stuff to make the backup work? Still, Time Machine ran fine for several months while the original poster deleted files and left them deleted - for months. And somehow, you blame Apple?

This is a really old thread at this point, but to review: I am the original poster. I was backing up about 70 GB from my Mac onto my 150 GB external hard drive using Time Machine, so I didn't have to exlude anything. Time Machine worked flawlessly.


The problem was I didn't realize there's a difference between an incremental back-up system, like Time Machine, and an archival system, like the HP SimpleSave that I used to use before I got my Mac. Once I realized the difference, I went back to physically archiving my important data once a month. I also let Time Machine run as scheduled. That way, I have an extra layer of security if my toddler son deletes events from iPhoto again without me realizing it for months, yet I also have the ease of Time Machine in case of daily hiccups.

So what is best way to make a "bootable" and an 'archive' version on an external hard drive? Also, i'm a bit confused. If photos are backed up to the Time Machine, could they in essence be overwritten a few months/years later and hence not be backed up? (if the external drive runs out of space or whatever reason?) Or is it just overwriting versions of files , so earlier versions aren't retained but newer ones are?


also, does it make sense to have all photos on a separate drive as well as the backup disk? (i use aperture and have a fair number of big raw files etc...)


I have a 2008 macbook pro which i've boosted to 4 GB memory, and now am going to add 2 GB more to the max 6gb... i need to make sure i have a fully bootable backup in case something doesn't work. what do you suggest?

CremeBrulee1 wrote:


So what is best way to make a "bootable" and an 'archive' version on an external hard drive? Also, i'm a bit confused. If photos are backed up to the Time Machine, could they in essence be overwritten a few months/years later and hence not be backed up? (if the external drive runs out of space or whatever reason?) Or is it just overwriting versions of files , so earlier versions aren't retained but newer ones are?


It is more a question of how soon you want to recover from a hard drive failure. Usually all of the fight for and against Time Machine are just people with some silly personal agenda. Time Machine is, by far, a superior solution for regular backups. However, the more backups you have, the better. If you know you are going to need a backup beforehand, such as before a major operating system update, then that is an excellent time to use a cloning tool. Don't rely on any tool for archives. Just copy and organize them yourself.


I have a 2008 macbook pro which i've boosted to 4 GB memory, and now am going to add 2 GB more to the max 6gb... i need to make sure i have a fully bootable backup in case something doesn't work. what do you suggest?


There is very little risk with a memory upgrade. It won't damange the data on the disk. More backups are always good and this could be a good excuse to make a clone, but it really isn't required.

CremeBrulee1 wrote:


So what is best way to make a "bootable" and an 'archive' version on an external hard drive?

You can make a bootable exact copy of your drive using SuperDuper or Carbon Copy Cloner. These can also update only changed files, so that it only takes a few minutes if you only changed a few files since last time. Some here prefer Carbon Copy Cloner because it also copies the Recovery Partition.


Like a lot of people, I use a cloner utility to have a fully bootable complete backup but also use Time Machine to retain multiple versions back for a reasonable amount of time, and in addition I keep three complete copies of my entire photo library (one working drive plus two exact backup drives, where one backup drive is always rotated off site in case something happens to my house).

CremeBrulee1 wrote:


Also, i'm a bit confused. If photos are backed up to the Time Machine, could they in essence be overwritten a few months/years later and hence not be backed up? (if the external drive runs out of space or whatever reason?) Or is it just overwriting versions of files , so earlier versions aren't retained but newer ones are?

Old versions are deleted to make room to back up the latest versions. The larger the Time Machine drive you have, the longer it takes to reach the point where the drive is full and old ones need to be kicked out.

CremeBrulee1 wrote:


also, does it make sense to have all photos on a separate drive as well as the backup disk? (i use aperture and have a fair number of big raw files etc...)

This can be a performance advantage, because then Aperture and the system aren't waiting for each other to take turns retrieving files from the same disk. I am not an Aperture user but I understand that if you store your photos as "referenced" you can move them to any connected drive.

Hi

Just curious about How you make your two photo library back-up's,

What photo management tool do you use and if you're using one, do you

back-up from within that software?



"Like a lot of people, I use a cloner utility to have a fully bootable complete backup but also use Time Machine to retain multiple versions back for a reasonable amount of time, and in addition I keep three complete copies of my entire photo library (one working drive plus two exact backup drives, where one backup drive is always rotated off site in case something happens to my house)."

Time Machine can back up to multiple drives, so one option is to have two drives in the location of your computer so Time Machine will alternate between them, helping prevent any impact from a backup drive failure. Additionally, if your system is mobile then you can have one backup on the go with you or at your work, and another one at home so you will have them in multiple locations. You can encrypt these backups if needed, to prevent them from being useful to anyone who steals them.

adnx wrote:


Hi

Just curious about How you make your two photo library back-up's,

What photo management tool do you use and if you're using one, do you

back-up from within that software?

I use various photo software, so I don't rely on any one for backup. The main one I use is Lightroom, but its backup facility is only for the catalog (the edits) and not the photos themselves, so I simply make the photos part of the overall Mac backup plan.


On my Mac Pro, the system, apps, and regular docs (but not photos) are on the main system drive. All photos and videos are stored on their own separate internal drive for maximum storage space.


I use Time Machine for versioned backups of the system disk. I then use SuperDuper to make a bootable clone of the system disk, and also to make backup clones of all other disks in the Mac (the Mac Pro has four internal drive bays and I use them all).


After I import new photos or videos, I connect my external backup drive and run SuperDuper to immediately add the new files to the backup. Like any good cloner, it will scan both drives and go "Hmmm, you added 296 new files and edited 17 files, I will update those on the clone." After a few minutes my backup matches the working drive.


When I'm going by the bank I take my external drive and swap it with a second copy in the safe deposit box. When I get home I run SuperDuper and update that second copy. That gives me the two backup drives with one off site.


Note that some in the forum are recommending Carbon Copy Cloner over SuperDuper because it apparently will also back up the recovery partition. While Carbon Copy Cloner is indeed excellent, I'm sticking with SuperDuper for now because I assume the recovery partition is easily reconstituted by Apple, and also because I don't want to spend another $40 right now.

Th 00004000 anks for detailed info, this solved and sorted things out

Network 23 wrote:

CremeBrulee1 wrote:


Also, i'm a bit confused. If photos are backed up to the Time Machine, could they in essence be overwritten a few months/years later and hence not be backed up? (if the external drive runs out of space or whatever reason?) Or is it just overwriting versions of files , so earlier versions aren't retained but newer ones are?

Old versions are deleted to make room to back up the latest versions. The larger the Time Machine drive you have, the longer it takes to reach the point where the drive is full and old ones need to be kicked out.


You are dangerously misreading how an incremental backup like Time Machine works. Please reread my post above and the Apple TM basics.

So you will not have hour by hour backups except for the current day, and daily's will only go back a month no matter how big the drive you are backing up to.


Weekly backups are the only thing affected by drive size.

If a file is removed from the active disk drive an incremental backup system WILL remove that file from the backups at some point in time. As TM works when that file is dropped from the backup will depend a great deal on just when in the hourly, daily, weekly bakup cycle the file was deleted from the active drive.


Worst case is if I create a file today and delete it some time later today that file won;t even make it into the daily backup for today.


If you need archival backups (like for photos and such) you need to have more then TM in place.


regards

Frank Caggiano wrote:


You are dangerously misreading how an incremental backup like Time Machine works. Please reread my post above and the Apple TM basics.

I'm not sure what is is that I'm misunderstanding. Please point it out to me, because I'd sure like to know!


My understanding seems to match everything you said. Time Machine keeps backups at the intervals Apple has specified, consolidating them into daily, weekly, monthly as specified in the referenced documents. At some point the drive becomes full. That's when old stuff starts getting dropped.


Right?

Network 23 wrote:


Frank Caggiano wrote:


You are dangerously misreading how an incremental backup like Time Machine works. Please reread my post above and the Apple TM basics.

I'm not sure what is is that I'm misunderstanding. Please point it out to me, because I'd sure like to know!


My understanding seems to match everything you said. Time Machine keeps backups at the intervals Apple has specified, consolidating them into daily, weekly, monthly as specified in the referenced documents. At some point the drive becomes full. That's when old stuff starts getting dropped.


Right?


I think you both are correct, but are arguing nuance details. Time Machine will make a new backup instance every time it runs, and create a duplicate of the last backup via hard links, which does not duplicate the data but only the drive's directory so the new backup "instance" points to the same data as the last. The only difference is that directory entries for changed files point to new "backed up" data for them as opposed to that from the prior backup instance. This paradigm is repeated until the drive is full, or until by Time Machine's default behavior hourly backup instance 00004000 s are removed.


Once the drive is full, then older instances of backups will be removed, and when the data on the drive is no longer pointed to by multiple hard links from the various backups remaining on the drive, then that data will be freed and allowed to be overwritten.


As a result, over time and with changes that fill the drive, older backups of changed files will eventually be turned over and eliminated from the drive. Their longevity on the drive depends on how you use your system and how many megabytes are regularly backed up. If you only back up a few MB per day (for whatever reason) then the TM backups will remain for a long time (especially if the TM drive is large). However, if you regularly edit a large 5-10GB movie file then regular backups of this will demand more from the TM drive and push other files off the drive, reducing backup instances that include them.

Lets say I have a 10tb drive for TM and I create a file on Monday and delete it on Thursday, how long will that file be in the backups?

Topher Kessler wrote:


This paradigm is repeated until the drive is full, or until by Time Machine's default behavior hourly backup instances are removed.


From Mac Basics: Time Machine

Time Machine keeps hourly backups for the past 24 hours, daily backups for the past month, and weekly backups until your backup drive is full.

Again it is only weekly's that are affected by drive size. Hourly's are gone after the day they were written and daily's only go back a month regardless of drive size.

Frank Caggiano wrote:


Lets say I have a 10tb drive for TM and I create a file on Monday and delete it on Thursday, how long will that file be in the backups?

Trick question I guess, in that the drive size is irrelevant; as I understand it the delete file will not make it into the next weekly backup. But that depends on when Time Machine makes that weekly backup.


And I guess I was wrong earlier when I mentioned monthly backups since there aren't monthly backups.

Again, its just these nuance details you're outlining. I never said anything to the opposite of these details, and there's nothing "dangerous" about how either Network 23 or I described it. Also keep in mind the backups are also revolving, so its not as if at 12:00am all of the previous day's backups are cleared out. Ultimately I think everyone here is adequately describing how it functions and has a good grasp on Time Machine's functions.

I too use Lightroom and migrating from a PC to MacBook Pro. I like the idea of my photos 00004000 being set up on a separate internal drive. How do you do this? I am a new Mac user. Would appreciate your help.


I plan to use your backup method.

jtrippy wrote:


I too use Lightroom and migrating from a PC to MacBook Pro. I like the idea of my photos being set up on a separate internal drive. How do you do this? I am a new Mac user. Would appreciate your help.

It's not a big deal, really. Because Lightroom doesn't care where the photos are stored. Lightroom can catalog them on any drive. My LR references photos on like 4 different internal/external/network drives. When I import into Lightroom, I tell it where I want the photos to go (on my other disk) using the automatic date folder format I set up in the Import dialog.


If you are moving Lightroom from a PC, I haven't done it but I think the steps are:

  • Download the Mac version of Lightroom, install it, plug in your serial number to make it go (the serial is cross-platform)
  • Copy the LR folder/catalog from wherever it is on your PC to whereever you want it to be on your Mac (maybe in the Pictures folder? Which is analogous to My Pictures in Windows). The catalog can live on your boot drive and track photos stored on other drives like your external.
  • If your photos are stored apart from your LR folder, drag your photo folder over to wherever you want it to live on your Mac (your second drive?)


After that, when you first start Lightroom, it might not see the catalog that was on the PC. Navigate to where the catalog is now on your Mac, open it, make it the default. However, that catalog might not see your photos since it last saw them in a PC drive letter location that no longer applies. What you want to do is in the Folders panel go to the top level folder that is listed under the old drive letter. Right-click on that and choose Update Folder Location and tell it where that folder is now stored on your Mac. It should automatically find and relink to all folders under it in the hierarchy.


You can boil all that down to "Move your LR files to the Mac and then relink 'em."

My question is: how does Time Machine interact with iPhoto in the sense that my library seems to be a huge file. If I add some photos to it, does it back up the whole huge file again thinking that this huge file has changed, or is Time Machine smart enough to know that its really just an unnessarily complicated Apple created directory system of photos, and just back up the recent photos added to the Library file. The first obviously will chew through a back-up drive quickly (as my iPhoto library is about 75 GBs and growing). If it just adds the recently added/edited photos, then I don't care.

It's not really a file. You can right/command click and "Show package contents".

Yes - but does Time Machine know that . . .


Actually, after I posted the above I remembered that I exclude my music and photo directories from Time Machine and back them up separately using Dropsync to duplicate the folders, because I wanted to be able to easily access these files directly in directory structures from multiple machines/operating systems etc - so its kind of a moot question for me (but it sounds like a valid question for many others who include their iPhoto libraries in their Time Machine backups).

I'm not sure if I am responding to this this thread properly or not. I am having an issue with time machine. I have an external seagate drive attached which i thought time machine was backing up to. After checking it it is not bacing up any new changes i make. i'm not sure what it is backing up. It seems to back up every hour but I'm not sure what it is backing up. Do I need to erase everything and start over? Any help would be appreciated!

The philosophy of data BACKUP (morphing and revolving, i.e. TM,...important point people dont understand in general)........... and a true ARCHIVE (cloned HD, multiple copies in safe places, secure places) ........is something EVERYONE should learn and differentiate. 😍



Very important topic in this thread.


Never consider any computer a data storage device, rather a data creation ,sending, and manipulation device. Anyone who thinks data is safe on any computer, even copied upon multiple partitions is making a mistake.

Never backup your data exclusively upon magnetic hard drives or flash storage, nor consider same since magnetic storage degrades over time even under ideal conditions.

Store important data on multiple servers on multiple continents.

Burn important data onto multiple copies of archival DVDs (Taiyo Yuden 100year rated DVD blanks) and store same in cool dark fireproof safes, multiple places.

Don’t burn data onto junk DVD’s purchased from consumer level electronics stores. These are not archival long life DVD’s nor reliable, nor trustworthy

Most importantly know that 2 copies of your data is 1, and 1 is none, and 1000 copies stored in one place or building, is also the same as none.

Always consider and expect your computer’s hard drive to completely crash anytime, at all times, and you should keep a cloned and updated hard drive handy at all times to return to immediate productivity and utterly avoid programs and parameter reinstallation and tweaking.


Nothing is quicker than taking out a dead HD and tossing in a new updated cloned HD for getting back to 100% in under 20 mins!

When your data is decentralized, it becomes both everywhere and nowhere, destructible by none.



Everyone should remember the rule 2 copies is 1, and 1 is NONE


And the computer itself never counts as one of those copies.

Ok .. Ive been using time machine for a year to backup system info and important data from a 2 TB Internal HD to a 2 TB External HD. I really only need the latest few backups ( I back up monthly ) as want to retain space on the external. Can anyone confirm the following points


1) will dat a be safe If i enter TM and delete oldest backups from the gear symbol so that i only have the last few months backup stored on HD.


2) Can TM drive also be used as a backup to another computer / to access fies occasionally or to drag - copy folders onto that system.


3)Can i store separate data on TM drive or does it need to be partitioned.


Any help with these points appreciated

I know this is not strictly related to the question..but i thought i'd add it ..although it is a bit late.



I have started using NAS4Free...as the name suggests ..it is a Free NAS server system. but it has Apple File Sharing protocol./ service built in.


It is also capable in teh AFP service of instanly making any internal HDD, shared uder AFP, fully Time machine compatibel, with he simple action of a drop down box and selecting Time Machine Compatibility.



So all you do is find any old scrap Intel based Windows PC, d/load NAS4Free burn to a CD and install on to the target computer..overwriting the Windows OS. ..stick in a big HDD or two. I used a 4TB single HDD...£100 on Dabs in the UK at the moment. So i have a 4TB NAS for the cost of 1HDD and about 2 hours work.


I also fitted a gigabit network card and connected it directly to my Mac via the second ethernet port.


Advantage with this is that I can expand by adding extra HDD's with little or no hassle.

Hi Sorry lost these, I feel your pain! There are a few photos I still can't find and grieve.


Yes this is what I do, I have a 1TB and a small older drive that I put the photo folder on periodically in case of failure. ALL hard drive eventually fail and it is smart to have multiple backup of irreplaceable files. You can also do a second TM on another hard drive and keep it at work, which I do in case of fire or theft. TM will ask, Do you want to use this one or both and just say both. I have to bring it home (maybe the first of every month) or after a big trip or event and loads of pictures are added at home.


BW, Denise