Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Claims of Rosetta working

A poster on the Macintouch forum writes:


'I accidentally installed Rosetta on Lion again on a different machine, MBP8,2.

It again works OK!

The RosettaNonGrata file is the handler-file that prompts 'Launch of "%@" failed: the PowerPC architecture is no longer supported', when a program tries to use Rosetta in Lion; whereas in SL it used to prompt to download Rosetta if it wasn't installed.

Re-installing Rosetta in Lion by adding the SL "translate" binary to the use/libexec/oah folder changes the default Rosetta handler file back to translate from RosettaNonGrata

My 10.7 systems now respond to the Terminal sudo sysctl kern.exec.archhandler.powerpc challenge with

kern.exec.archhandler.powerpc: /usr/libexec/oah/translate

So Rosetta is installed in Lion and is my default PowerPC architecture handler '


I don't understand a word of it. Is he deluding himself/trolling/a berk? Or has he found a magic solution?

97 replies

Well, that didn't work! I copied the contents of the Snow Leopard oah folder to the Lion one, after first renaming the RosettaNonGrata file to "RosettaNonGrataOld"--attempting to launch Eudora fails. I then renamed the Snowy RosettaNonGrataSL, and removed the "Old" from the Lion. No go. No matter which of the RosettaNonGrata files I use, If I run the Terminal command:


sudo sysctl kern.exec.archhandler.powerpc


I receive the unhappy answer


kern.exec.archhandler.powerpc: /usr/libexec/oah/RosettaNonGrata


Not the "tran 000031EC slate" answer the poster reports getting. So I don't know what the person did, looks like it was something other than copying the stuff from a working Snow Leopard folder!

Francine

I'm glad I'm not the only one who found this didn't work. I just spent several hours trying every possible configuration without success. I even used the Rosetta installer from Snow Leopard. I just want to be able to use Tex-Edit Plus!

It does rather look as if the MacinTouch poster is one of the three types I listed. Another poster there has reported that he was able to install Rosetta, but that it didn't enable PPC programs to run so there was little point. Several other posters have asked 00004000 about this but that OP hasn't come back. I'll keep an eye on those forums and report back n the highly doubtful case of anything postivi arising.

IMHO He's getting all excited over nothing.


AFAIK How /usr/libexec/oah/translate works is it selects to run the PPC code version of both the program you are attempting to run as well as the system libraries need to load that program.


Last time I checked Lion has no system binaries that have any PPC code in them. Intel and 64 bit Intel code makes up a good part of Lion.


He may be able to get rosetta installed.


But that doesn't mean it will make PPC programs magically work on Lion. Launchd and the various system binaries responsible for launching programs would then have to be forced to use Rosetta when encounting PPC code and there's no guarantee that will actually work and no guarantee the system will then allow Intel code in the system binaries to run the PPC code in the program.


In fact I don't see anything about him then opening a PPC only program and it working on Lion. It's like he's gotten an old 2400 baud modem working in his office yet has not shown him being able to jump on the internet with his Tandy 64 because of that.

I've posted your answer (with credit) back into the MacinTouch forum, since several people there had been asking for clarification on how do make it work.

how did you manage to install rosetta onto lion?


step by step instructions would be nice.


since The RosettaNonGrata file is the handler-file that prompts 'Launch of "%@" failed: the PowerPC architecture is no longer supported can you just replace lion's RosettaNonGrata file with snow leopard or even leopard's file?


i have a new mac mini on it's way that has lion and i would like to decide if i should keep lion or replace lion with snow leopard or even leopard.

I don't think you'll be able to install Snow Leopard on the new Mac Mini. It requires Lion, and a custom version of Lion at that. As for installing Rosetta, the RosettaNonGrata file is already there. According to the original poster, copying some additional files from Snow Leopard and pasting some code in to Terminal will get it to work, but it doesn't. I think it was a hoax.

ejonesss wrote:


i have a new mac mini on it's way that has lion and i would like to decide if i should keep lion or replace lion with snow leopard or even leopard.


OS X 10.5 (Leopard) certainly will not run on a 2011 Mac. You migh 00004000 t be able to do a clean install of OS X 10.6 (Snow Leopard) but only if you have a retail disc. Apple generally does not allow installing of previous OSes on their hardware.


Bluspacecow is right, though. Even if you can get Rosetta installed PPC applications still will not run under Lion because the OS simply does not support it. Period.

Interesting thing Michael.


launchd is the program that's primarly responsible for launching any programs on os x.


On lion this process has no PPC code in it.


You can find out if a particular program has PPC code in it by running the file command.


IE


07:51:55-bluspacecow~$ which launchd

/sbin/launchd

07:55:16-bluspacecow~$ file /sbin/launchd

/sbin/launchd: Mach-O universal binary with 2 architectures

/sbin/launchd (for architecture x86_64): Mach-O 64-bit executable x86_64

/sbin/launchd (for architecture i386): Mach-O executable i386


Also System Information will list what parts of the software are still PPC. Can't see anything PPC.

I installed Rosetta from the SL optional installs DVD. I only installed it because I needed to install my Final Cut Studio 2 on my new iMac. Ironically, the Final Cut Studio suite worked in Lion on my old machine, but I couldn't install it on the new machine because the Installer was PPC.


So, install Rosetta from SL, check.

Install FCS 2 in Lion, check.


I still can't run older programs in Lion, but somehow the old installer works.

I still can't run older programs in Lion, but somehow the old installer works.


Exactly.


I tried the same thing: old installer will work (FCE 3 installed ok). PPC app will not (tried it with Appleworks).

It should be noted that RosettaNonGrata is not some special file in Lion. It's in Leopard and Snow Leopard, too.


These are commands you can use in Leopard and Snow Leopard to disable, and then re-enable Rosetta. People used this sometimes to determine if a program was PPC only. You'd disable Rosetta just to see if Leopard or SL would tell you that you needed to install Rosetta. Then you'd know it was a PPC app. Then cancel out of installing Rosetta and just re-enable it.


Disable Rosetta:


sudo /usr/sbin/sysctl -w kern.exec.archhandler.powerpc=/usr/libexec/oah/RosettaNonGrata


Re-enable after it's been installed already:


sudo /usr/sbin/sysctl -w kern.exec.archhandler.powerpc=/usr/libexec/oah/translate


Who knows, maybe the second command would activate Rosetta in Lion. I haven't tried it yet, though I did install Rosetta in Lion.


The above commands are one line, they're just wrapping on these forums.


Edit: The translate program of the re-enable Terminal command doesn't exist in Lion. Not even after installing Rosetta, so that must be part of the Leopard and SL install. You may be able to copy them over to Lion in their identical locations and get it to work. But who knows what else may be missing for Rosetta to function.

If you have VMWare Fusion 4.01 then you can load leopard or SL virtual

fred724 wrote:


If you have VMWare Fusion 4.01 then you can load leopard or SL virtual


I thought I read that it's illegal to run SL (don't know about Leopard) unless it's Server version?

As I understand, Fusion announced this feature but then backtracked, all very disappointing as I was hoping to be able to run Rosetta in Lion (via Snow Leopard in Fusion)


http://tinyurl.com/d49hr73


If anyone out there is running SL Server (or SL for that matter) in Fusion with Lion as OS, how fast do programmes work in the virtualization environment?

Kurt there's no need to turn Rosetta on/off to check if a program is PPC only.


All you have to do is to show the Application's Package Contents , navigate to Contents/Mac OS and run the file command on the binaries in that directory.


If it was PPC only there would be only 1 binary in there and the output of the file command would be that were a PPC binary.


You may argue that a non technical person would want a simplier way of checking. Ok then. Run the program in Lion. If it's PPC only and since Rosetta doesn't exist for Lion it will simply not run.


I thought I covered 00001D3F this in my posts from August - logically for Lion to run PPC apps it needs to have some form of linking to PPC code in the system binaries. AFAIK You can't just run machine code compiled for one architecture of processors on some other processor. If you have some detailed information on exactly how Rosetta works and how to install it on Lion please do share tho.


In fact guys why are we necoring a thread from August ?

Kurt there's no need to turn Rosetta on/off to check if a program is PPC only.
All you have to do is to show the Application's Package Contents , navigate to Contents/Mac OS and run the file command on the binaries in that directory.

Yes, I know. That was just one way of finding out. You can also start the System Profiler and click on the Software heading. All software on the drive is listed, and the Kind column will tell you if it's Intel, Universal, or PPC.


Part of the other reason to do that was to force Leopard or SL to reinstall Rosetta via the download method when you try run a PPC only app. Disabling Rosetta makes the OS think it isn't installed.

In fact guys why are we necoring a thread from August ?

Because users would really like to be able to run their PPC software in Lion instead of having to boot to S 00004000 now Leopard to run those few apps. For those with new Macs that won't boot to anything less than Lion, users don't want to have to keep another Mac around just for those few apps, or go through the expense of getting a VM and a server copy of SL for them.


The common argument of course is, "just get a newer version of the software". Well, I'd like to, but the scanner division at Kodak (who bought out Scitex/Creo) never updated the software, and now looks like they never will. I must have a machine capable of running Snow Leopard. A VM doesn't work for me because the scanning software only looks for the scanner on a FireWire connection, and not a single VM supports FW port linking from within the virtual environment.


What is necoring, anyway? The word doesn't exist with any type of explanation on a Google search. Necore, or necoring shows up in a grand total of 31 matches. Like this post by someone on a gaming forum:


Stop necoring this thread! We figured out long ago that i'm a dummy and I rushed to conclusions. This thread is pointless and should not be necro'd.


Which makes no sense whatsoever without knowing what "necoring" means. It's got to be one heck of a limited use slang term.

Interesting fact : If you have showing of invisible files/folders turned on you can actually find a


/usr/libexec/oah/translate on the Snow Leopard install DVD. If you want to go playing around with this and possibly even prove me wrong go right ahead.


Take back up copies of your HD first of course 🙂


Also : The SL DVD would contain a barebones system install with only the system binaries and directories required the run the installer. So on the theory of it being a "mini" OS X install this would tell me what sort of structure your would expect the system binaries to make up and if I ran the file command it would confirm if there was indeed PPC binaries as well as Intel binaries for the system programs & libraries.


Every executable program i found on that DVD in their system folders all had both a PPC binary and an Intel binary. Comparing it against the equlivent folder on the main HD would reveal on lion those same system binaries have a 32 bit Intel binary as well as a 64 bit intel binary but no PPC code.


Checking this your self however merely requires doing a cd command to the root level of the DVD then another cd to say the usr/sbin folder and running a file * command. Neither of which are dangerous so you should be able to check that without having to do a back up 🙂

Part of the other reason to do that was to force Leopard or SL to reinstall Rosetta via the download method when you try run a PPC only app. Disabling Rosetta makes the OS think it isn't installed.


Ok good reason to do so on Leopard / SL. Unforunately we're not talking about either Leopard / SL. We're talking Lion. I think you might of been wanting to provide some background as to the use of the commands.


Because users would really like to be able to run their PPC software in Lion instead of having to boot to Snow Leopard to run those few apps. For those with new Macs that won't boot to anything less than Lion, users don't want to have to keep another Mac around just for those few apps, or go through the expense of getting a VM and a server copy of SL for them.


Then write up a sticky and guide about it then.


See I thought I covered the reasons why Rosetta won't run in Lion. All you're doing is rehashing ground that's already been covered.


What is necoring, anyway? The word doesn't exist with any type of explanation on a Google search. Necore, or necoring shows up in a grand total of 31 matches. Like this post by someone on a gaming forum:



Seriously ?


You just googled the term without fulling knowing what it means ? On a tech support forum no less :lol:


A necro is where someone takes a thread that's several months old and bumps it. Tha 00004000 t's what a necro is in it's most basic form. It's taking something that was covered and answered quite some time ago and adding something to it.


But from the necros I've seen ? The person necroing it adds nothing to the conversation at all. Most of the time the person hasn't read the other replys either. And worse ? There's a very high probablity that the information contained in the thread is no longer relevant to the discussion. It's too old and with the way the IT/tech/computers industry works today what might of worked three months ago has no guarantee it will work now.

/usr/libexec/oah/translate on the Snow Leopard install DVD. If you want to go playing around with this and possibly even prove me wrong go right ahead.

Way ahead of you, there. 🙂 I've already copied the app translate, and the folder Shims to the same location on the Lion partition I have set up for testing. I just haven't had time to boot to Lion to see if it made any difference.

Then write up a sticky and guide about it then.

About what? A guide of how PPC apps don't work in Lion? I think everyone knows that already.

All you're doing is rehashing ground that's already been covered.

Are you truly missing the point of this thread? People want to know if it IS possible to get Rosetta working in Lion. Or do you think there's something wrong with a discussion of curiosity?

Seriously ?

You just googled the term without fulling knowing what it means ?

Seriously? You chide people for not knowing what an extremely little used slang term means? If I made up a word and used it sentence, would you automatically know what it means? It would also have helped greatly if you had spelled it correctly the first time. You wrote necoring instead of necro.


Yes, I know what necro means. But would it have killed you to use a term everyone recognizes, instead of trying to show us how "cool" you are? This is an international community. The less slang you use, the better it is for those for whom English is NOT their first language to understand a user's post.

Seriously ?


You just googled the term without fulling knowing what it means ? On a tech support forum no less :lol:



I didn't google; I was just going to ignore it; however, I became curious. This is what I got using the dictionary:


User uploaded file


I would not expect any of these terms in a tech forum; I would, however, expect someone to use proper language considering the many different other-than-English-native speakers we have here. A bit much to expect others to be familiar with some American slang term or street language.

Having a Necro-experience here. Can someone remind me again what Rosetta was again? Seems like something from an aincient era like G5 or Powerbook that were too outdated to even run Snow Leopard and Intel programs. But here we are, what seems just a few short years later, arguing over something a one post Troll put up about magically einstalling Rosetta in Lion. Even homes for the Intellectually impaired have access to the internet! lol


Carry on Lions

I maintain a fully updated Snow Leopard partition to be able to work with an app that requires Rosetta.

Yes, as do I, but seriously, to date, I have had no reason to boot SL as I have somehow slowly updated everything I use to non PPC. Appleworks is the only thing I might miss a bit, but had a fair idea that it had seen it's day a while back so been using Pages and even Text Edit which is a bit more powerful than it first appears. I still use my SL partition for booting into to repair permissions on the Lion partition if necessary and also have DiskWarrior on it just in case, but I am surprised at how many programs have been slowly updated and are now compatable with Lion.


Cheers

Well, there is no acceptable replacement for the painting function of Appleworks and I create all my own graphics from scratch - until I find a replacement that does the same thing, I will need Appleworks. But, the point is: it is irrelevant why someone wants/needs to use a PPC app, deriding them is neither helpful nor does it add anything useful to the thread.

babowa wrote:


Well, there is no acceptable replacement for the painting function of Appleworks and I create all my own graphics from scratch - until I find a replacement that does the same thing, I will need Appleworks. But, the point is: it is irrelevant why someone wants/needs to use a PPC app, deriding them is neither helpful nor does it add anything useful to the thread.

Couldn't agree more. Personally some threads do out live their usefullness and become vessels for rants and insults, never to resolve anything more within the thread. The dropping of Rosetta has been seen as a radical, yet eventual one, by many. If I had of had a say early on, I would have loved to have seen Apple continue advancing Appleworks as their flagship W/P. But the writing was on the wall a long time back and users are very lucky that it can still be used even in the most recent version of the previous OS. Imagine if it never even made it to Intel machines? Anyhow, duel booting is a pretty simple for all but brand new Macs, so in a lot of cases, given enough space, we are in a win/win situaion here in many cases, until all future programing is aimed solely at Lion.


Thanks

Installing Rosetta off the Snow Leopard CD worked fine, and it allowed me it install Final Cut Suite 2. It worked fine. Thanks!

EljefeWappo wrote:


Installing Rosetta off the Snow Leopard CD worked fine, and it allowed me it install Final Cut Suite 2. It worked fine. Thanks!

That is great. Can you open FCP, go to Get Info and post a screen shot so I can see that it is actually using Rosetta before I install it?


Thanks in advance

That didn't have anything to do with it. FCS2 is a Universal app. It would have installed anyway. Rosetta does not work in Lion.

Kurt Lang wrote:


That didn't have anything to do with it. FCS2 is a Universal app. It would have installed anyway. Rosetta does not work in Lion.


Actually, my FCE3.5 would not install in Lion on mine even though it is a universal app - its installer is not universal, it is PPC. I tested several methods:


one was an attempt to install from the disks (failed with warning about PPC apps not working)

one was to manually drag every file over (worked); and the last

one was to start over with a clean Lion install, use the SL disk to extract/install Rosetta (worked), followed by installing from the install disks (worked).

its installer is not universal, it is PPC.

Ah, that's different. 😉 Why would a company do that? Like the handful of Office 2008 disks out there also with a PPC only installer. How dumb is that?

Why would a company do that?


Can't answer that since we're not allowed to speculate....... 😀


P.S. After that successful Rosetta install, I tried to drag over Appleworks - that refused to work (maybe since there was no installer as such).

I tried to drag over Appleworks - that refused to work

Probably not. I have the last version of AppleWorks on my backup drive as an installed copy. It was on a bundled software package which I installed and then backed that up. If I just drag the installed app onto a drive which can run it, it starts right up.


Getting back to FCS, I had 1.5, which was the first Universal version, skipped 2 and upgraded to 3. It's entirely possible that all three had a PPC only installer and you just don't realize it.


Which brings us back to EljefeWappo's statement. I've tried Rosetta both ways in Lion; installing Lion over a clean Snow Leopard install and then reinstalling Rosetta from the SL disk, and installing Lion on an erased drive followed by Rosetta from the SL disk. Neither way will run any PPC software.

Which brings us back to EljefeWappo's statement. I've tried Rosetta both ways in Lion; installing Lion over a clean Snow Leopard install and then reinstalling Rosetta from the SL disk, and installing Lion on an erased drive followed by Rosetta from the SL disk. Neither way will run any PPC software.


Agreed.


Ditto for Appleworks - it works on my SL partition, but will not on the Lion partition.

babowa wrote:


one was to start over with a clean Lion install, use the SL disk to extract/install Rosetta (worked), followed by installing from the install disks (worked).


When you put the disk in Lion, is there a check box option to choose to just install Rosetta? I have the install disk for Leopard but I don't see any option to just install a program called "Rosetta".


I'm trying to install my old FCP Studio 2 on a brand new Lion computer. Can you please describe the steps you used to install Rosetta from the install disk. I'll find an install disk for Snow Leopard if I have too. Thanks.

Unfortunately, I did this last August or so, so memory is a bit hazy on the individual steps (I can barely remember what I had for dinner yesterday 😉 ;


the easiest (but requiring the most "manual labor") was dragging every file over from a successfully installed copy on my SL partition. For that, I followed the "uninstall FCE" in reverse, found the files, copied and parked them in the very same spots on Lion; uninstall steps here:


http://support.apple.com/kb/TA38198?viewlocale=en_US


that worked like a charm.


As for the Rosetta aided Installer: no, there was no option to install Rosetta dialogue - simply something that it won't run because it's PPC. I know there was a thread here about extracting Rosetta from an SL disk (where to find it), but I don't have a link for it; you should also be able to use Pacifist. I followed the instructions in the thread and I'm sorry I didn't keep the link, but searching for Rosetta here should get you there. In any case, it installed successfully and then I used the FCE installer.


I would try my first method above - that would appear to be the safest route.

Roger, seems to be the only way to have Rosetta (within Snow Leopard) running concurrently with Lion and not having to Dual Boot - Snow Leopard in Parallels 7 in Lion.


This allows me 24/7/365 access to Quicken Deluxe 2002 and other PPC applications, as needed:

User uploaded file

Hi MIchael,


Could you please let us know how you installed Snow Leopard in Parallels 7 running on Lion? AFAIK, Parallels 7 only supports the Server version of Snow Leopard (which costs several hundred dollars; no comment on that).


The various proposed solutions (found searching the net) to install SL in Parallels 7 running on Lion all seem a bit unstable, though I have not yet implemented any of them. I am hoping your solution was straight forward.


Cheers,

Sasha

Initial support of some virtualization software in OS X Lion allowed for Snow Leopard virtualization, but this breaks Apple's EULA and the software was quickly updated to prevent such virtualization. While one could probably hack the software to get it to run, it will not be available for the average user to simply try.

asmystiq wrote:


Hi MIchael,


Could you please let us know how you installed Snow Leopard in Parallels 7 running on Lion? AFAIK, Parallels 7 only supports the Server version of Snow Leopard (which costs several hundred dollars; no comment on that).


The various proposed solutions (found searching the net) to install SL in Parallels 7 running on Lion all seem a bit unstable, though I have not yet implemented any of them. I am hoping your solution was straight forward.


Cheers,

Sasha

Sasha:


It works and it's stable! Try this:


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3209335?answerId=16247806022#16247806022


If you run into any problems let me know. My nickname at America Online.


Topher: Are you just trying to be "helpful" to someone in need, or can you be more definitive with your "road blocks." See:


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18039235022#18039235022


and


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18039443022#18039443022

Thank you Topher, that helps clarify the issue for me.

Thank you MIchael, I appreciate the answer and the links. I will try your suggestions and will let you know if there are any issues! 🙂

Be sure to print out all the information so that it will remain available to you in the future from here and the links...

asmystiq wrote:


Thank you MIchael, I appreciate the answer and the links. I will try your suggestions and will let you know if there are any issues! 🙂

Did your Mac ship with Lion? If not then the easiest way is just to run Snow Leopard on a seperate partition. I have a 60GB SL Partition which I used for programs which required Rosetta, until I updated or replaced the old, out of date PPC programs and now have not used it for about four months, as Lion is running great. But this was by far the easiest way to go about it if your Mac will do thi 000029B3 s.


Good Luck


Pete

As is true in many ways in life, these two solutions require a choice to be made:


Either more work up front and easier to implement on a day to day basis (setting up SL in Parallels once and then running Snow Leopard concurrently with Lion); or


Less work up front, but more work every day (partioning the hard disk and installing SL but then having to do the "Boot Camp" reboot EVERY time you want to change from Lion to SL and back...


My solution has the first virtue and your solution has the second...

Thank you for the suggestion, Pete. I already have SL installed on a separate partition, though, as MIchael's, my preference is to run it from a virtual environment, even if it takes more work upfront to set it up. I'm going to give that a try and if all runs smoothly, will release the current SL partition to utilize as available space for Lion.


As a side note: Nothing fresher, aside from cool water on a hot day, than competent advice and working links. Thank you both. 🙂

asmystiq wrote:


Thank you for the suggestion, Pete. I already have SL installed on a separate partition, though, as MIchael's, my preference is to run it from a virtual environment, even if it takes more work upfront to set it up. I'm going to give that a try and if all runs smoothly, will release the current SL partition to utilize as available space for Lion.


As a side note: Nothing fresher, aside from cool water on a hot day, than competent advice and working links. Thank you both. 🙂

Yes, both choices would be good. I personally went with the two partitions as I had very few PPC programs and now have none, given that the Virtual Environment may not be possible in the upcoming Mountain Lion and beyond. If Virtualisation of SL has been a loophole in the short lived Lion OSX then it may very well be closed in all future OSXs which is why I chose to go with upgrading the programs rather than trying to get them to work in an unstable way.


Good Luck


Pete


petermac87 wrote:


Yes, both choices would be good. I personally went with the two partitions as I had very few PPC programs and now have none, given that the Virtual Environment may not be possible in the upcoming Mountain Lion and beyond. If Virtualisation of SL has been a loophole in the short lived Lion OSX then it may very well be closed in all future OSXs which is why I chose to go with upgrading the programs rather than trying to get them to work in an unstable way...

I would think it goes without saying that upgrading programs to their Intel versions is the first preference of every Mac user using Lion.


Some, for various reasons, are obviously unable to upgrade some of their software at this time... I suspect that asmys 00004000 tiq falls into this latter category.


Pete, I am glad that you were able to get rid of those Rosetta-requiring games that your kids played...


Now you can turn your attention to those who need your advice in a non-Rosetta related way. I'll miss your helpful advice in this area. Don't forget to turn in your badge...


Regards, Michael

MlchaelLAX wrote:



Pete, I am glad that you were able to get rid of those Rosetta-requiring games that your kids played...


Now you can turn your attention to those who need your advice in a non-Rosetta related way. I'll miss your helpful advice in this area.


Regards, Michael

No, I have an iMac set up with Snow Leopard for the kids now.........but thanks for taking such an interest in my private life, but that's creepy and I would prefer you kept out of it. Thank you.


As for helping people with Rosetta problems, I have been using Macs all my life, so I fail to see how you are the only one allowed to give expert advice on this subject, given you have a zero score on your helpful answers, despite your many, many posts on this virtualisation set up.


Again thanks for the unhealthy interest in my children's habits, but no thanks


Pete

You either think I am clairvoyant or forget that you posted this information to me in another thread...

Michael, you are correct in your suspicion that I cannot upgrade all of my PPC apps to Lion at this time, which is why I am implementing the SL virtualization solution.


Pete, I am hoping by the time I am ready to upgrade to Mountain Lion, I won't have the need for the legacy support of PPC apps. If I do, then I'll probably keep a Lion partition (with Parallels running SL) next to ML.


Thanks again,

Sasha

I know I posted it Michael, but being irrelevant to the reply to this poster I do not see what possessed you to have to drag it out and repost it. Please avoid contact with me in these threads. Too creepy.


Pete

petermac87 wrote:


Yes, both choices would be good. I personally went with the two partitions as I had very few PPC programs and now have none...


petermac87 wrote:


I know I posted it Michael, but being irrelevant to the reply to this poster I do not see what possessed you to have to drag it out and repost it. Please avoid contact with me in these threads. Too creepy.



Pete


Feel free to look up the definiti 00008000 on of "irrelevant."


If you review our so-called "contact" with each other you will see it always follows this pattern:


1. A poster will indicate a problem with not being able to run a non-Intel application in Lion (usually because of the absence of Rosetta);


2. I suggest the Snow Leopard in Parallels 7 within Lion solution (the "Virtualization method"), usually linking back to my September 28, 2011 post, where I first pointed out how to implement this solution; and


3. Your followup comments to either me or the poster, attempting to disparage this method in one way or another.


You repeat this pattern over, and over, and over again; there is no point in my posting the links to them here!


In THIS very thread, you went out of your way to post an additional message, suggesting that the Virtualization method was "trying to get them to work in an unstable way" when you: (a) have NO experience with the Virtualization method, (b) have consistently criticized the Virtualization method and (c) have no evidence that substantiates your claim that the Virtualization method is unstable.


There are users of non-Intel applications that need to run them with Rosetta in Lion. You now admit that YOU are no longer one of them, yet you consistently go out of your way to criticize the suggestion of the Virtualization method as a solution.


Why must you continue to interfere with a working solution to someone else's problems? I find it mind-boggling! The answer has some connection to your insistence on calling me "names."

According to para 2.2 of the ToU:


Be polite. Everyone should feel comfortable reading Submissions and participating in discussions. Apple will not tolerate flames or other inappropriate statements, material, or links. Most often, a "flame" is simply a statement that is taunting and thus arbitrarily inflammatory. However, this also includes those which are libelous, defamatory, indecent, harmful, harassing, intimidating, threatening, hateful, objectionable, discriminatory, abusive, vulgar, obscene, pornographic, sexually explicit, or offensive in a sexual, racial, cultural, or ethnic context.


and para 2.3:


Post constructive comments and questions. Unless otherwise noted, your Submission should either be a technical support question or a technical support answer.


Because of your posts, I no longer feel comfortable with this thread. Your post from approx. 6:30 pm was removed promptly; unfortunately I read it before reporting it.


Kindly stop now unless you have a constructive comment.

MlchaelLAX wrote:


petermac87 wrote:


Yes, both choices would be good. I personally went with the two partitions as I had very few PPC programs and now have none...


petermac87 wrote:


I know I posted it Michael, but being irrelevant to the reply to this poster I do not see what possessed you to have to drag it out and repost it. Please avoid contact with me in these threads. Too creepy.



Pete


Feel free to look up the definition of "irrelevant."


If you review our so-called "contact" with each other you will see it always follows this pattern:


I will find no such thing. You are trolling, I have seen your other posts. You are ignorant towards legalities and the changes within and now you chime in on a personal level, without yet helping anybody out. You believe in your method and that you can drag up any thread to attempt to insert relevance to your claims.


I repeat, stay in your Rosetta world and stay out of attempts to bring up previous posts on my children in to attempt to disparage me. I have seen your kind here over the years and you will be gone as technology from Apple outgrows your ability to use it.


Rosetta has gone, but you are like the lone fool on the hill calling for the final challange. "We want Our My Rosetta back!"


Happy Computing


Bye

My post is both contructive and informative and quite honestly, I will not allow being called creepy to sit unanswered.


I am sorry you chose the wrong participant to report...

asmystiq wrote:


...my preference is to run it from a virtual environment, even if it takes more work upfront to set it up. I'm going to give that a try and if all runs smoothly, will release the current SL partition to utilize as available space for Lion..

Let me know if you need any assistance in your installation!


It seems I cannot link you to Apple to purchase Snow Leopard, as that post was deleted as "advertising!"

fred724 wrote:


If you have VMWare Fusion 4.01 then you can load leopard or SL virtual

How, Fusion will not install Snow Leopard (client) only the server edition, so how did you do this, or did you do this?

http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13727_7-57329027-263/vmware-4.1-lifts-block-on-snow -leopard-client-virtualization-updated/



NOTE: The update to the article indicates that VMware removed this feature in version 4.1.1

MlchaelLAX wrote:


http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13727_7-57329027-263/vmware-4.1-lifts-block-on-snow -leopard-client-virtualization-updated/



NOTE: The update to the article indicates that VMware removed this feature in version 4.1.1

What is the current version of VMWare Fusion? and why did they correct their error?

Don't know: I use Parallels...


Maybe you should ask VMware!

My understanding is that VMware made a mistake and corrected in the next upgrade. Under the terms of Apples licensing agreements only the server edition of SL can be used.

Under the terms of Apples licensing agreements only the server edition of SL can be used.


Which agreements? Between Apple and VMware or ??

Antony D\'Emanuele wrote:


My understanding is that VMware made a mistake and corrected in the next upgrade. Under the terms of Apples licensing agreements only the server edition of SL can be used.


It is an Urban Myth. I have yet to see anyone actually quote the terms of the Snow Leopard EULA that would prohibit virtualization of Snow Leopard in Lion. This guy has articulated the issues very well:


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18039235022#18039235022


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18039444022#18039444022


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18040262022#18040262022


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18042986022#18042986022

MlchaelLAX wrote:


Antony D\'Emanuele wrote:


My understanding is that VMware made a mistake and corrected in the next upgrade. Under the terms of Apples licensing agreements only the server edition of SL can be used.


It is an Urban Myth. I have yet to see anyone actually quote the terms of the Snow Leopard EULA that would prohibit virtualization of Snow Leopard in Lion. This guy has articulated the issues very well:


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18039235022#18039235022


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18039444022#18039444022


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18040262022#18040262022


https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3193258?answerId=18042986022#18042986022

And yet VMWare did change their software to prohibit installation of Snow leopard client.

As Col. Nathan R. Jessup in "A Few Good Men" might have responded to your post:


"I'm an educated man, but I'm afraid I can't speak intelligently about the operating practices of VMware."


Maybe Lt. Daniel Kaffee, like me, uses Parallels...

MlchaelLAX wrote:


As Col. Nathan R. Jessup in "A Few Good Men" might have responded to your post:


"I'm an educated man, but I'm afraid I can't speak intelligently about the operating practices of VMware."


Maybe Lt. Daniel Kaffee, like me, uses Parallels...

Just so we are clear though. There is NO currently available VM software will install Snow Leopard client, although you can try to find an obsolete version of VMWare that will?


Correct? or will you answer with another one of your movie missives.

User uploaded file


"YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE TRUTH!"


"CLEAR?"


"CRYSTAL!"

Just as I thought, you won't address the question, so to all our readers please remember that Mr Lax's advice is missing one crucial piece of information.


You can not install Smow Leopard Client in any current VM as supplied by VBox, VMWare or Parallels. So don't waste your time.


Mr Lax, we're done, you are a miscreant.


Bye

Csound1 wrote:


Mr Lax, we're done...

I'm going to hold you to your word!

While I do understand the arguments as to why it is not possible to install Snow Leopard Client in a virtual machine, because it was really important for me not to loose access to certain research files, in one of my "Oh heck, what have I got to loose moments", I followed instructions found on various sites and managed to install Snow Leopard onto the latest version of VirtualBox. Although the instructions to create a diskimage of the Snow Leopard installation disk which Vbox could read, failed (Vbox would not boot from disk image I created), just as I was about to give up, VirtualBox booted directly and unexpectedly from the Snow Leopard installation CD and proceeded to install Snow Leopard. While use of VirtualBox is a bit kludgy to say the least (I would much prefer to be using Parallels), it came up, was able to connect to the internet (after some screwing around), and installed all the required updates. Since file sharing between VirtualBox and Mac OS X is rather weak, I set my entire hard disk to be shared, added a second ethernet virtual adapter (this must be done to access the shared volume), and moved over my critical application files. Photoshop CS, Prism, Office V.x, and Office 2004 all ran, which made me a very happy camper indeed.


While the entire process eventually worked, it did require a lot of fiddling and trying different things out. Figuring out how to change the screen size took a bit of Internet slewthing, but the information was there. However, I never had to modify disk images to make VirtualBox think I was installing Snow Leopard Server or do anything really arcane. Whether or not I could repeat the process easily, I really don't know. But indeed running Snow Leopard in a VirtualBox is possible and at no time did I encounter any indication that only Snow Leopard Server could be installed.


I am posting this to suggest that hope is possible, not to engage in a flame war. Below is a picture of my virtual system

User uploaded file

Peace

It may work in some instances, and through some instructions, but isn't something that folks who need to do it should rely on. It's definitely not a simple three-step process.

Jim Downward wrote:


While I do understand the arguments as to why it is not possible to install Snow Leopard Client in a virtual machine, because it was really important for me not to loose access to certain research files, in one of my "Oh heck, what have I got to loose moments", I followed instructions found on various sites and managed to install Snow Leopard onto the latest version of VirtualBox. Although the instructions to create a diskimage of the Snow Leopard installation disk which Vbox could read, failed (Vbox would not boot from disk image I created), just as I was about to give up, VirtualBox booted directly and unexpectedly from the Snow Leopard installation CD and proceeded to install Snow Leopard. While use of VirtualBox is a bit kludgy to say the least (I would much prefer to be using Parallels), it came up, was able to connect to the internet (after some screwing around), and installed all the required updates. Since file sharing between VirtualBox and Mac OS X is rather weak, I set my entire hard disk to be shared, added a second ethernet virtual adapter (this must be done to access the shared volume), and moved over my critical application files. Photoshop CS, Prism, Office V.x, and Office 2004 all ran, which made me a very happy camper indeed.


While the entire process eventually worked, it did require a lot of fiddling and trying different things out. Figuring out how to change the screen size took a bit of Internet slewthing, but the information was there. However, I never had to modify disk images to make VirtualBox think I was installing Snow Leopard Server or do anything really arcane. Whether or not I could repeat the process easily, I really don't know. But indeed running Snow Leopard in a VirtualBox is possible and at no time did I encounter any indication that only Snow Leopard Server could be installed.


I am posting this to suggest that hope is possible, not to engage in a flame war. Below is a picture of my virtual system

User uploaded file

Peace

Still seems a lot more sensible to upgrade your programs. I had two PPC programs remaining when I updated. Now all my software is compatable with Lion, which was pretty much the idea when Apple began phasing out PPC well over 6 years ago. PPC Macs themselves could not even run Snow Leopard. Seems like a complicated way to go about holding on to the last renants of an outdated program (Rosetta) which was only ever included as one last chance for users to get somewhere near modern software.


Good Luck, but it's not for most of us.


Pete

There are no equivelents for many PPC Apps as far as I'm concerned, & I don't understand why if it's possible for a Virtual machine to run Rosetta... why it's not permitted, & why Lion or ML can't!???

BDAqua wrote:


There are no equivelents for many PPC Apps as far as I'm concerned,

What in particular?


Pete

I have one in particular: the gradient options in the painting portion of Appleworks can be used to create very stunning backgrounds and I use them extensively while creating art/cards/movie backgrounds from scratch. There is no replacement available unless I were to spend thousands, so I maintain an SL partition I can boot into.

Which is fine. I just got over AppleWorks. Would have actually have liked Apple to continue developing it, but so long since I've used it I am more familiar with Adobe, Corel and Creator these days. Holding onto a SL partition makes sense. Continuing Rosetta support does not.


Good luck


Pete

I still use Eudora and I presently have no upgrade path if I go to Lion. I also use Mail and Outlook at work, however, Eudora is still my prefered email client...

Eudora is REALLY dark ages stuff!! Lol


Pete

It is indeed, but so much more powerful (and faster) than Mail and Outlook....

Jim: Good for you!


Jim, Antony & BDÅqua:

User uploaded file


This is the screenshot of my mid-2011 Mac Mini running Lion (then 10.7.1; now 10.7.3) and concurrently in the Parallels 7 windows is Snow Leopard (10.6.8) with Quicken 2002 and Microsoft Excel 2004 running within it.


It works, it's stable, it CAN be relied upon and I use it 24/7/365. It takes less effort than the "backup your HD, partition your HD, restore your backup into one partion and install Snow Leopard into the other partition" so-called solution proposed by others (that actually will NOT work on the newer machines, such as my mid-2011 Mac Mini) and you do not have to purchase an external HD.


You need help with getting Parallels 7 to run Snow Leopard? Let me know. Those that have are very happy campers!

I did try to update/upgrade everything to Intel native, but there is no replacement for two apps I must have.


1) oXYgen Scan for Scitex/Creo/Kodak flat bed scanners. The closest they came to making these Intel native is they made the kernel driver Intel 32 bit (that's right, you can't boot 64 bit and use the scanner), and a secondary app that controls communication between the scanner and the actual scanning software interface. Everything else is PPC code. So I can use the scanner up through Snow Leopard and no further. But even then, not in a VM. The software will only look for the scanner on a FireWire port, and not a single VM supports FW port linking; USB only. So in order to use the scanner at all, I have to boot directly into SL.


The software was written specifically for these X-Y auto stitching scanners. There is nothing else that will drive them. Not Silverfast, VueScan, etc. Kodak shut down the scanning division entirely and even bulldozed the Israeli plant where they were made (Scitex was originally an Israeli company). So the only way this software will ever become full Intel native is if Kodak sells the rights to the software to someone willing to port it.


And nope, there are no other flat bed scanners that even come close to the image quality of these things. Only high end PMT (Photo Multiplier Tube) drum scanners can produce a better image. So as far as I'm concerned, they can't be replaced.


2) Monaco Profiler. X-Rite now owns (and discontinued) both Profiler and Gretag-Macbeth's Profile Maker. They took the best features of each and released i1 Profiler as an Intel only replacement. Great! It produces more accurate profiles than even the previously best software, Monaco Profiler.


Bad news. There is no scanner profiling module in i1 Profiler. Nor is there a profile editor. Mandatory for anyone in printing/prepress. It made an awful lot of people scratch their heads when they saw i1 Profiler couldn't do that. So there we are, stuck with the PPC code only Monaco Profiler to able to do these two functions.

Kurt:


Pick up the cheapest Mac Mini you can find in Craigslist, eBay, Amazon, Apple store refurbished; that will run Snow Leopard and work with your proprietary software.


Connect one of your external displays to the Mac Mini or borrow one if you have to. Connect it through FireWire to your scanner and connect it to your intra-network either through Ethernet or Airport.


Install your proprietary software (oXYgen Scan and Monaco Profiler).


In System Preferences: Sharing - turn on Screen Sharing.


In System Preferences: Network: Advanced... - Select DHCP with Manual Address and give it a Fixed IP.


Shut it down, remove the Display and Restart it (older Mac Minis may require the Display Adapter to be connected to make it think that a Display is connected; newer ones do not).


On your main computer, in the Finder: Use the GO menu to Connect to Server and enter "vnc://192.168.0.100" but do not enter the quotation marks and substitute the Fixed IP from the older Mac Mini, click the + symbol to "remember" this entry and then click CONNECT. Click the Green Button in the upper left hand of the window or otherwise resize it to full screen.


On your Mac Mini connect to your main computer for File Sharing as needed, and mount the folders where you keep your important data.


I use my Lion Mac Mini as my "server" and it stores all of my data files, serves them out to all of my computers and uses Time Machine for backup. Before I perfected the "Rosetta in Parallels 7 solution" I was able to use my Lion Mac Mini to remotely control another Mac Mini that was running my Rosetta software in Snow Leopard that in turn was using my data files and saving them back to my Lion Mac Mini. At the same time I was able to use my Lion Mac Mini to run all of my non-Rosetta software, too.


Then you can upgrade your main computer to Lion and iCloud.


In this way you can control your Lion and Snow Leopard environments on one screen via screen sharing and can run your proprietary software.

Pick up the cheapest Mac Mini you can find in Craigslist, eBay, Amazon, Apple store refurbished; that will run Snow Leopard and work with your proprietary software.

Thanks, but no need to. I bought a Mac Pro with the Westmere CPUs and shipped with Snow Leopard (practically one of the last ones B&H Photo and Video had that didn't come with Lion) to cover myself with as new a Mac as I could get that would boot to SL.


We repurposed an older Core Duo 2 iMac as a Lion Server. We were running Snow Leopard Server on it, but ran into the very well known problem of the server refusing to save files. You constantly get .afpdeleted errors or not having permission. In both cases, SL Server VERY stupidly deletes the file you were saving!!! It's not a total disaster, but you have to remember to save the file again immediately before closing it on your client computer.


We had heard and read the Lion Server solved this issue. So I installed it and whadayaknow? We haven't seen an .afpdeleted message once, and only one instance of a person suddenly not having permission to save a file they've already saved a couple of times with no error message. Just super that Apple found the problem but force users to upgrade to Lion Server for such a critical OS error instead of issuing a patch for Snow Leopard Server.

Any port in a Rosetta storm!

I am quite willing to upgrade programs. Sadly, it was not always possible either for economic reasons or because the vendor never upgraded their software to run on Intel Macs.


For example, I owned a small R&D company. From 1990 until when it closed,we created somewhere between 15,000 to 20,000 Microsoft Word, Excell, and Powerpoint documents. Critical Word documents were created in 4, Word 5.1, Word 6, and Word V.x, and Word 2004. Similarly, we had Excel, and Powerpoint documents created (and still readable) using ancient versions of Excel and Powerpoint. Office 2008 only reads some of the old document formats, and Office 2011 reads even fewer. So over the course of several months, before installing Lion, I tracked down (across multiple computers) and converted each of these documents so as to be readable using Office 2008. What pain!


However, some of the scientific data analysis software we used was rather expensive, and the upgrade fees would have been huge. In addition, we use TurboTax. In the event of an audit, we need to be able to access our tax information going back at least 7 years. Unfortunately, current versions of Turbotax just do not open Turbotax files created by previous versions.


All in all, I am quite envious of those who have been easily able to upgrade to Lion without having to deal with losing the ability to run programs which depended on Rosetta.

MIchael


As I only own the client version of Snow Leopard, I am certainly interested in learning what one does to install Snow Leopard in Parallels 7.


Jim

Jim,

Officially Apple did not support allowing virtualization until Lion.

Jim Downward wrote:


I am quite willing to upgrade programs. Sadly, it was not always possible either for economic reasons or because the vendor never upgraded their software to run on Intel Macs.


For example, I owned a small R&D company. From 1990 until when it closed,we created somewhere between 15,000 to 20,000 Microsoft Word, Excell, and Powerpoint documents. Critical Word documents were created in 4, Word 5.1, Word 6, and Word V.x, and Word 2004. Similarly, we had Excel, and Powerpoint documents created (and still readable) using ancient versions of Excel and Powerpoint. Office 2008 only reads some of the ol 000015AE d document formats, and Office 2011 reads even fewer. So over the course of several months, before installing Lion, I tracked down (across multiple computers) and converted each of these documents so as to be readable using Office 2008. What pain!


However, some of the scientific data analysis software we used was rather expensive, and the upgrade fees would have been huge. In addition, we use TurboTax. In the event of an audit, we need to be able to access our tax information going back at least 7 years. Unfortunately, current versions of Turbotax just do not open Turbotax files created by previous versions.


All in all, I am quite envious of those who have been easily able to upgrade to Lion without having to deal with losing the ability to run programs which depended on Rosetta.

JIM:


WOW! If there ever was a reason to be concerned, THIS IS IT!


I have JUST one Excel spreadsheet that will not open properly in 2011 and so I continue to use 2004 as I update it, just because I do not want to take the time to figure out the problem.


Probably best to continue this conversation offsite: Take a look at: AIM iChat Yahoo America OnLine...


Do you already have Parallels 7? Just curious, what is its version number. I am mostly up to date, but I noticed just yesterday that it told me there is another update.

Kurt, unfortunately nobody could have predicted the demise of Kodak. Scanners and other peripherals of choice will obviously require outdated system coding to run their outdated software. Unfortunatly we live in a disposable world, so it is up to the user to cater for their own needs. Whereas Lion does everything I require, you obviously wish to stay in a ppc friendly world, which is fine but certainly not Apple's responsibility to support the few who need it. Some people here seem to believe that everybody in the world requires Rosetta support while others quietly go about setting up the best combination of computing factors that suit their workflow.


Cheers


Pete

Must be a slow day, eh Pete?

Last count you had followed me directly into eleven threads. I am starting to consider that stalking and will report it as such. Your comments in those posts speak for themselves. As did your comment here that was in answer to Kurt's post, not yours.


Good luck


Pete

Not exactly factually true, but nice try!


Two people in two days posts specific reasons why they need to run PPC programs in a post-Lion world: yesterday you reply to Jim and today you reply to Kurt.


You offer NOTHING OF VALUE to either one of them. You continue to use these posts as a sounding board for your position that Rosetta is dead, upgrade your software and if you cannot upgrade your software, too bad for you! What value did you add to either discussion? Certainly no sympathy for their situations.


Let's look at your reply to Kurt: the first sentence about no one being able to predict the demise of Kodak... it was well-known that Kodak, whose principal business was the manufacturing of film stock, was in trouble in a digital world. I guess it was a surprise to you.


I am not sure what the next two sentences even mean, let alone add to the discussion.


Then you tell us your oft quoted view of the post-Rosetta world:


1. You have no need for it, as you have upgraded all of your software.


2. Apple has no obligation to continue Rosetta support indefinitely into the future -- a point made neither by Jim or Kurt.


3. And lastly you opine that some people would require everybody to support Rosetta -- again a point made neither by Jim or Kurt.


So, I will repeat what I often say when you post your comments in opposition to my Rosetta in Lion posts: some people need to have access to Rosetta in a Lion environment. Maybe because of iCloud, maybe because their new hardware requires Lion, or for other reasons.


Most of us add positive suggestions to the mix. I offered a detailed suggestion to Kurt and it turns out that he has already implemented a similar solution.


You berate my posts, my screenshots and call me names...


My mother taught me: "If you do not have anything positive to add to the discussion, listen and learn!"

No, you were the one who dragged up an old post making reference to my children, then spent the rest of the day stalking me through posts that had nothing to do with Rosetta. Your attempts at justifying your comments are almost, well........softwaterish.


Bye


Pete

OK, then let's look at your reply to Jim.


Jim tells us of his successes with getting Snow Leopard to run in Virtual Box and concludes with the statement that: "I am posting this to suggest that hope is possible..." and gives us a screenshot to show how it functions. You reply:

petermac87 wrote:


Still seems a lot more sensible to upgrade your programs. I had two PPC programs remaining when I updated. Now all my software is compatable with Lion, which was pretty much the idea when Apple began phasing out PPC well over 6 years ago. PPC Macs themselves could not even run Snow Leopard. Seems like a complicated way to go about holding on to the last renants of an outdated program (Rosetta) which was only ever included as one last chance for users to get somewhere near modern software.


Good Luck, but it's not for most of us.


Pete


Jim has 15,000 to 20,000 documents created for his small R&D company back in the 90s in older versions of MS Word, Excel and Powerpoint many of which are unreadable in Office 2011.


Jim also tells us that some of the scientific data analysis software was expensive to begin with and upgrade fees would be hugh. And in the case of tax audits which can go back 7 years, current versions of TurboTax will not read the earlier data.


Your suggestion? "Still seems a lot more sensible to upgrade your programs."


Then the oft-repeated refrain of your post-Lion position regarding Rosetta:


1. You have updated ALL of YOUR software.


2. Time for everyone to get modern software.


3. It (Rosetta) is not for "most of us."


You offered nothing of value to Jim either...