Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

I want Front Row Back

I'm sure I'm like a lot of other people here. I want my Front Row back.....


I listen to a lot of Podcasts, watch movies from an SMB share, look at my photos, oh and listen to music. Front Row has done this for year after year, and last night, once I found it was gone, I wanted to go back to SL. How can Apple think they'll ship the new OS without the media center (Front Row) which has been around since what? 2005-8?


Honestly, if this is some sort of push (on their part) to their iCloud crap, they are in for a rude awakening.


Apple should stop taking away our functionality. This one step forward and two steps back is getting really lame.


Plus, there also seem's to be a lot of bugs. new one for me is then I have my two 24" displays connected (3 screens total). Once I plug my iPXXXXX in both 24" displays go back!!! OMG The insanity!!!




Louis

198 replies

Where to send product feedback to Apple:


http://www.apple.com/feedback/

I agree. I use Front Row all the time especially for viewing photographs as I am a professional photographer. This is exceptionally annoying. Would love to hear from Apple about this but I won't get my hopes up....

douglasnelson wrote:


I agree. I use Front Row all the time especially for viewing photographs as I am a professional photographer.

Really?


I much prefer iPhoto or GraphicConverter for that purpose.

Hi Klaus,

Sorry I should have been a bit clearer. I use Front Row on my iMac 27 when friends want to see some of my phootgraphy albums. Never used iPhoto as I'm an Aperture user. Excuse the ignrance but could you let me know how you use graphic converter please ? Thanks

Doug

GraphicConverter is one of the most useful application ever made for the Mac:


http://www.lemkesoft.com/


One of its many features is an excellent slideshow facility.

Many thanks Klaus. I'll check it out now.

Doug

here's how to get it back :


http://osxdaily.com/2011/07/21/front-row-for-mac-os-x-lion/

Many thanks Andy. Much appreciated.

Doug

I'm with Louis here. I use, or rather used, Front Row on a daily basis. Didn't happen to notice anything within the Apple brochureware that indicated I'd lose Front Row if I upgraded to Lion. I'm now seriously considering taking my Mac back to Snow Leopard as it's that much of deal breaker for me. I used to mock my colleagues for having to put up with Windows Media Centre on their PCs when I had this simple and beautiful application. Okay, so maybe I'm going a bit overboard, but I'm that peeved about losing Front Row! Grrrrr to Apple!

I completely agree with the comments made so far. What an incredibly bad move to remove Front Row from Lion! I have a mid 2010 Mac Mini attached to my TV set and run Elgato Eye TV to record TV programs and Elgato Turbo.264 HD to encode videos into iTunes-friendly format. iTunes and Front Row coupled with Candelair and Remote Buddy software give me an excellent media center. I managed to get Front Row back in Lion following:


http://www.mac-hatter.com/blog/frontrowenablerforlion


but since I upgraded to iTunes 10.4, Front Row can no longer access content in iTunes. I'm looking to roll back to iTunes 10.3.1. I've also placed a call to Apple Support to give me possible options - perhaps refund my purchase of Lion so I can roll back to Snow Leopard.

I want Front Row too.! For me it was good easiest way to watch latest Movie trailers.

I also use my Mac Mini in the living room as a media player so I will stick with SL 10.6.8 and iTunes 10.3.1 since I like the Front Row interface for viewing movie trailers etc.

My little Apple remote is useless to me without Front Row.

I bought my 24" display for my 13" Macbook Pro so i could watch movies and browse photos when my friends come round using my remote and Front Row.


Seriously considering rolling back out of Lion because of the missing Front Row functionality.


For the moment i am going to try the "hack", but if the hack works then why couldn't those idiots at Apple have just left it in and said they weren't going to develop it further. I'm not asking for new functionality, but don't take this away.

I found this (Front Row Enabler for Lion) here, But it only will do your movies and Photo's at the moment (if you've upgrade to the lastest iTunes that is.) Also I've been playing with Plex and xbmc, both are good media players (Plex has a Netflix plugin which I like, but.... I don't have easy access to my music, and more important (to me at least) My Podcasts which I listen and watch all the time.

Oh, and I forgot. Both work with both of my remotes (white and silver) 🙂

I'm in the same boat as you guys!!! I love my Front Row, I use it all the time. I love to lounge on the couch, fire up iTunes and stick it on full random and let 'er rip! I have my MBP hooked up to my 40" Samsung HDTV, optical cable to the surround sound stereo for 5.1, with a wireless keyboard and mouse, and of course my trusty white remote, listen to music and just hit next when I don't like a song. I know I can do the same thing in iTunes, but with front row and remote, I can switch playlists, find songs ect. ect. without getting up and grabbing the mouse and keyboard. And it's truly great for showing friends photo's on the TV! I also use the movie trailers as well. I really hope someone figures out a way to get iTunes recognized again.

Does not matter that took Apple, Plex is much better alternative because it is show the weather to!
But I do not understand why need two chat program? IChat+Facetime? Skype is much better becouse works on every platform! also, why is the ugly chess still part of the system? they are much better games in app store for free!!!???

The problem is not to weed out the system, the problem is
why not availeble to download in the App Store? as an extra if someone miss this Front Row app

(Sorry about my English)

Does PLEX work with the Apple Remote I paid for? I like Front Row and use it in my computer room and offic 00004000 e area where I do not have my HDTV. This looks like Apple's blatant move to get everyone to purchase the Apple TV instead of just using their Mac. Or maybe Apple is, in fact, about to introduce an Apple-branded TV and removing Front Row creates an instant market? How does Apple make these decisions? Maybe I can sell my remote on eBay to someone who is still using SL.

Yes, it works, I tried🙂 Plex its free app, feel free to try:DDD download from here: http://www.plexapp.com/

If you dont like it, easy to delate...

The remote control continues to be with iTunes too:)


Other alternative: http://osxdaily.com/2011/07/21/front-row-for-mac-os-x-lion/

An other alternative: http://xbmc.org/

Zoltan, many thanks. This is not the first time you've helped out me and other Apple users. I'll give both a try and get back tho this topic.

Thanks andy for that link.


Nice to have it back again :-)


🙂

Do the install from link above, took couple of minutes and back in business again.


like you best for movie trailers

Hello Zoltan and others, I've read in a few places that reinstalling Front Row works as long as you DON'T download the latest iTunes. The word is that once iTunes .4 is installed, Front Row will not work even if its reinstalled. Is this correct or not? I'd rather have FR on my Mac, but would also like to hear from anyone on the post if you PREFER Plex or XBMC?

I would love to have front row back. PLEASE give it back. I use it on my 27 inch iMac all the time. Since I dont have a tv in my room it was perfect. I don't really have an elgato because I can only afford so much. Frontrow was a great option. I was able to buy all my shows and watch them direct. And the great thing about front row being no silly unreliable wireless connectivity. I have an appletv 2 in my family room but access and connectivity and internet dependability are all factors. Its the main reason I would have prefered the original appletv. so a mac mini with front row may make it to my family room if front row makes a comeback. Even if they just made it and stuck it on app store. I do not want to pay for it though. I already owned it. just make it accessible again. I was sold on the idea of digital hub and not cloud. Oh and ya I bought a stupid remote just for Frontrow. How about including it as an app for the remote???

+1 to get Front Row back... along with a proper support of the Apple Remote (on my systems, the remote will not even wake up the monitor when in sleep (the monitor, not the mac).

My version of front row is still working after install of itunes X.4


so still a happy camper

I'm still on 10.6.8 and have upgraded iTunes to 10.4 and Front Row still can access content in iTunes

I am furious about Front Row dissapearing. I feel ripped off. Frontrow was able to control my entire living room entertainment very easily - no more.


Do apple run an uninstall app 10.7 app?

Not good


But there is an easy work around.


as I said now a couple of times you CAN use front row with lion and latest itunes.

The Front Row it was a frankly useless crap, all the clever Mac user use XMBX or Plex.

Apple remote control still works with ITunes and Plex and XBMC!

Take your the medicine! or reinstall Snow leopard if the other option is not good for you!


The Plex and XBMC free to try, it also plays Windows media files to, beside shows the weather,and perfectly work with the Apple remote control!

Here are the links to download: http://xbmc.org/download/

http://www.plexapp.com/

Not everyone uses front row as a media player.


There are many media players to chose from.



front row is excellent for movie trailers.

Instead of crying for all go to google search and type : Media Center for Mac ...:DDD

Yes the remote still work, but (at least on my systems) will no longer exit the display standby mode.

Yes, there are Plex, XBMC out there.... they work well, that add many features not found in Front Row but they don't replicate the basic ones: installed out of the box, automated iTunes integration...


By the way, if we all agree that dropping Front Row is just fine because there are good replacement for free.... then following that logic: let's drop Quicktime (there is VLC), let's kill Safari (there is Firefox or Chrome or Opera...), let's erase Mail.app (there's Thunderbird).


One strengh of the OSX experience was the integration and (relative) ease of use with an out of the box system.

It is being torn apart...

TomFR,

For most part I agree with you, most people they do not even know that iTunes is not just playing music, but video as well, on the other hand, photos, music, videos can be play from directly from Finder (alt+Space full screen) and the Quick Time and DVD player is built into the system to ... I ask why so many media players if you do not need!

Mac for me means: the simplicity....

Robin, I 've got one Mac running Lion and iTunes 10.4 and another running Snow Leopard and iTunes 10.4. On SL, the iTunes integration with Front Row is still working, but in Lion it isn't. I think the main difference is that on SL iTunes is running as a 32-bit application, while in Lion it's now a 64-bit application.


I'm sure we're all familiar with System Preferences needing to restart in 32-bit mode when accessing settings for some older applications. So I reckon that if you don't update iTunes after installing Lion, you'll be keeping a 32-bit application that's perfectly happy to work alongside a re-instated 32-bit Front Row...


In terms of Front Row versus XBMC, Plex etc I think some folks are missing the point that I and others were making in earlier posts. I lament the passing of Front Row because it is a simple bit of interface that made accessing media files a plain affair and it was only a remote button away...


I've tried XBMC; I've tried Plex; but I want Front Row! Simply because it lacks all the bells and whistles of the other media centre apps that are out there.

"The Front Row it was a frankly useless crap, all the clever Mac user use XMBX or Plex.'


I use Plex for watching internet videos and can easily say that Plex is not, I repeat, is not, a suitable replacement for the simplicity and convenience that Front Row provides. Neither are the other similar peices of software.Not even close.


I use Front Row all the time because with a single click on the Apple remote you have simple and fast access to all your media. Things like Apple TV2 and an iPad, both of which I own, are not replacements for Front Row, on say my iMac, since obviously they are separate devices.


There is now no way to have Lion and and the latest version of iTunes installed and have total and easy access to all your media on a Mac. Apple is stupid for getting rid of such a fantastic and elegantly simple piece of software. And further, Apple is arrogant and inconsiderate to not even let those updating to Lion know about their lousy decision.


I love Apple but that's a lousy way to treat your customers.


Yes, I have left feedback for Apple.

Even opened by clicking one of the Front Row, was full of bugs! incompletely showed the ITunes album covers, not rent movie from ITunes with a single click , not play Windows Media files and Divix and Xvid not

play movie subtitles! and the weather and Netflix does not show!

The only thing I could tell the front row for the benefit, namely thatshe was beautiful interface! no need to set up, but although most of the format is cant played:(


Iam sorry, but i dont need for only waching movie trailers, ITunes is good for that...


I belive most people is upset becouse thay not able to learn to use and configure different Players


Sorry abouth my English is not as good than my Russian and Hungaryan....

Taxes


You can use front row & latest version of itunes with lion.


I am using it.

Robin Bonathan wrote:


Taxes


You can use front row & latest version of itunes with lion.


I am using it.

Robin Bonathan wrote:


Taxes


You can use front row & latest version of itunes with lion.


I am using it.

What kind of hoops did you have to jump through to get Lion/iTunes 10.4/ Front Row to work ?

None


I had a copy of front row from apps folder which I copied into another folder.


Ran the application mentoned top of page. linked here :-


http://www.mac-hatter.com/blog/frontrowenablerforlion


Enabled run in 32bit mode (click on info and tick box) and i run it from the directory i copied it too (but with icon on task bar).


It runs fine, I then installed x.4 of itunes, still runs.


took less than 5 mins.

I disagree Zoltan205,


I find its simplicity a huge plus for me, it provides a nice UI for simple things like Movie trailers, Movies, Photos, Music and Podcasts.


I'm surprised see the lack of people mentioning Podcasts, I watch and listen to them all the time. I have a Mac Mini in my living room, and I use my remote to watch movies off my NAS box, and also to watch and Listen to Podcasts. So far the fix (or work around for Lion and Front Row) only works for movies and Photo's.


Plex and XMBC, will play music, video's and some on-line content, and even the weather, but will not play podcasts.


I think Apple should have left Front-Row in, or at least given US the choice.


just my 2 cents.


Louis

I am sorry you missunderstand my bad English, as i said to: "only plus was in Front Row is the simplicity...and

unfortunately not the skills"


ITunes plays podcast, radio chanels and movies, music, movie trailer too🙂 and you can rent HD movies with one single click:) The Apple remote is works with to....


an other hand XBMC is just is simple than Front Row...

Can you please clarify? I've tried forcing Lion to run Front Row (in /Applications) to run as a 32-bit application (hardly necessary, it seems to me, as it isn't a 64-bit application) and it has no effect on the interworking with iTunes 10.4. I've also tried forcing iTunes 10.4 to run as a 32-bit application (on Lion), but Front Row interoperability continues to be lost. What am I missing?

I am running front row from a folder held in my documents folder.


(thats were I put a copy).


I now have it linked to task bar.


I did as I said above and it works fine.

I've just tried your setup. Sadly, it doesn't seem to work.

Try this: http://osxdaily.com/2011/07/21/front-row-for-mac-os-x-lion/

Thanks. I might have missed something there, but installing Front Row was one of the first things I did after upgrading to Lion. It worked perfectly until I upgraded to iTunes 10.4. Now all connectivity between Front Row and iTunes (10.4) has been lost on Lion. Not so on Snow Leopard. I was intrigued by Robin's explanation that he successfully managed to get Front Row and iTunes 10.4 working together on Lion. I've been unable to do it following his instructions. Can anyone clarify the situation?


PS I know Front Row on Lion still works just fine for movie trailers, etc. Presently, I'm only interested in connectivity with iTunes 10.4. Thanks.

I think the problem here is that iTunes 10.4 for Lion is a native 64-bit application, while on SL it's still a 32-bit application. Front Row is a 00004000 lso a 32-bit application, therefore it can 'drive' iTunes on SL, but not on Lion.


You've now got me wondering what would happen if I copied iTunes 10.4 from my SL install onto the Lion install...

@jstoll -- on what hardware, and did you try to actually play the content? I can browse my Music library, but not actually play any of the content. I'm rebuilding the library now, because my one movie plays correctly...

Edit -- rebuilt my library and SnowLeopard is still happy with Front Row... Don't know when it broke, but I'll be good until I upgrade...

@kquinn -- it's a Mac mini Core 2 Duo with currently only 1GB of RAM - that's why it's still running SL, has Front Row officially available, but already has iTunes 10.4. Might not upgrade RAM and just leave it running SL as a media server in our living room 😟

It seems to me several things have been established:

  1. Front Row 2.2.1 (the version included in Snow Leopard) works just fine on Lion. Its only incompatibility is NOT with Lion itself but with the 64-bit version of iTunes 10.4.
  2. Front Row 2.2.1 is fully compatible with the version of iTunes 10.4 running on Snow Leopard, possibly because it's different from the one installed on Lion (32 bits?).


It would be great if Apple addressed the Front Row and iTunes 10.4-on Lion issue by creating a 64-bit or otherwise revamped version of Front Row, but, if that weren't to happen, perhaps someone can figure out how to restore iTunes 10.4 connectivity for Front Row.


Several options might be available for exploration:

  1. Replacing all Lion iTunes application, libraries, frameworks, etc., with their Snow Leopard counterparts in case they can run on Lion.
  2. Replacing only one or a few iTunes components (Quartz Composer Visualizer.bundle?) with their Snow Leopard counterparts in case the replacement doesn't render the system unstable.
  3. Naturally, a more drastic (and, er, theoretical) approach might involve reverse-engineering one, a few or all Front Row calls to iTunes components so that they will be executed by the Snow Leopard version of such components and not the regular Lion components.


Does anyone have expertise that might shed light on the path to follow?

As the title of this topic stated " I want Front Row back"

Thanks for all the suggestions guys & Gals but none of them are front row.

Apple should just offer it in the App store.

So add my name to the list!!!

I want Front Row back

Hi to All,


We are many people with the same problem on Front Row and also with a Remote Apple control.


I would like give back the Front Row application.


I don't understand which is the apple business in this, if then has too much people angry.


I have also buoght the Remote Apple control with my new IMAC.

What can I do with this?


I would give back the money!!


Or the application or Money back for the unusable control on Itunes also !!


Faber

I wonder if Robin Bonathan be so kind to explain exactly what he did step by step so that everyone in this predicament knows how to get back front row like he has done.

Because as far as I can see Aplle will not offer a 64 bit version of front row even as a purchasable option since they are promoting their GBP101.00 Apple-tv2 which works on the same basic principle of front row interface. To me it is a glorified HDMI cable as it's main use is streaming music and video from your computer wirelessly to your TV or to your DAC which I do not want. So if I had it I would use it for controlling my media files like I did with front row. Expensive way to do it!!

Very cheeky and sly move on Apple's part.

Plex 9.3.5 does not work with OSX Lion either as it loses my playlists after a while. Plus too many unnecessary stuff for my taste. I loved Front row's simplicity.

XBMC ; I just could not get it to work with the Lion

So I WANT MY FRONT ROW BACK!!


p.s. I have Lion installed on 2010Mac Mini with Itunes 10.3.plus mac-hatters front row installed. So it is working fine. But I know he minute I update Itunes to 10.4 (64 bit) Front row will lose my music files and playlists on Itunes.

I thought i had made my expanation fairly clear.


so here goes again.


I copied front row app whilst i still had snow lepord into a seperate folder in my documents folder (purly a copy) original stayed is apps folder.


upgraded to lion


no front row in apss any more, i did try to run front row i think but it did not work.


i then ran the application posted on this page


http://www.mac-hatter.com/blog/frontrowenablerforlion


computer restarts after install.


i enabled 32 bit mode on front row (note I have not moved app, its still in a folder in my documents folder).


it works fine.


i have created link on my task bar as shortcut for application (still stored in my documents)


following day see update for itunes 10.4, perform update.


front row still works.


no magic

on the mac-hatter.com website, there was an update from someone that said if you made an alias iTunes Movies folder and put it in the Home icon to the left where it will open up the different files on your computer and drop it in movies, when Front Row is opened that alias file will be there also. I'm new to the iMac world so forgive me if I don't know the correct terminology. But it works!!

I am sorry, but there remains a lingering doubt. There are several (many?) of us who have successfully installed Front Row on Lion. Before the iTunes 10.4 update, it worked exactly the same as on Snow Leopard. After the iTunes 10.4, however, all connectivity with iTunes 10.4 has been lost, but non-iTunes content (for instance, movie trailers) still works fine. The "trick" to put aliases in your "home" movie folder works as it has always worked: it is even capable of navigating your entire set of volumes and all their folders, in search for movies, etc. The problem is that, even if you access your music files this way, the "coverflow" effects of iTunes and Front Row aren't there any more.


If they are there for you (apparently without an alias or anything else, except for the presence of the Front Row application in a subfolder of your Documents folder and a link in your "task bar" (your Dock?), it would be great if you could some further light into this issue. By the way, telling Front Row, a 32-bit application, to run as a 32-bit application serves no purpose I can see.

how do you enable 32 bit app in front row. I'm trying it your way. I have time machine so I can get Front Row back. I deleted the other with the alias folder.

I want it back too. It was MOST disheartening to find out my little white Apple remote was turned into an impotent piece of crap.

Bring it back....please.

This might already be known, but, since I haven't seen it anywhere, I thought I should post it, in case someone with more knowledge can do something about it:


  1. The basic difference between iTunes 10.3 and 10.4 is in the application itself and in the ~/Music/iTunes/iTunes Library.itl.
  2. As far as I know, Front Row doesn't care which specific version iTunes.app is. iTunes connectivity is effected exclusively through iTunes Library.itl.
  3. As a matter of fact, if you replace your 10.4 iTunes Library.itl with the latest version you had under 10.3.1 (you can locate it under ~/Music/iTunes/Previous iTunes Libraries), Front Row and iTunes connectivity will be automatically restored IN FULL.
  4. The catch is if you open iTunes 10.4, it'll modify your iTunes Library.itl and connectivity with Front Row will be once again eliminated.
  5. So, for those of you who might want the temporary "solution" of downgrading iTunes to version 10.3.1, do the following:
  • Get yourself a valid copy of the 10.3.1 version of iTunes.app.
  • Open ~/Music/iTunes.
  • Rename iTunes Library.itl to iTunes Library.itl.bak.
  • Locate your latest iTunes Library.itl (it'll be named something like iTunes Library 2011-07-30.itl) in ~/Music/iTunes/Previous iTunes Libraries and copy it to ~/Music/iTunes.
  • Rename it iTunes Library.itl
  • Open a terminal window.
  • Enter "cd /Applications" (without the quotation marks).
  • Enter "sudo rm -fdr iTunes.app" (without the quotation marks).
  • It will ask for your administrative password; enter it.
  • With that, iTunes 10.4 has been erased. Quit terminal.
  • Now, copy your iTunes 10.3.1 application to /Applications.
  • If necessary, repair permissions.
  • You are done. You have a fully functional iTunes 10.3.1 and Front Row 2.2.1 running on Lion.
  • In addition, since the system knows you already installed iTunes 10.4, it won't be offered as an update. Hopefully, by the time iTunes 10.5 and iCloud arrive, someone will have discovered how to fix Front Row and iTunes 10.4+ connectivity.

ITunes operates in full screen mode and you can use the Apple remote control to. Its works, not exactly like Front Row, but it is enough to turn on ITunes, switch musics, radio channels, stop, froward, play movies...etc...etc.

Instead of patching the system, why not just use ITunes until Apple solves the problem? ICloud is coming, soon, I'm sure that Apple is working on something better!

Yours is no response. Whether Apple is working on something "better" is very much a matter of opinion. Those of us who like Front Row may not want something "better". For instance, some people usually mention Plex or other solutions I personally dislike. If Apple are working on something "better", I might like it, but perhaps I won't. For now, we can retain full functionality of Front Row on Lion with iTunes 10.3.1, and perhaps with future versions if somehow we get Front Row to "understand" the changes introduced in iTunes Library.itl with version 10.4.

In my personal opinion I have told you even if it is accidentally addressed to you:)

if you not need something more better then Front Row why should switched use the lion?

Why you're not the president of Apple?

Anyway,

Maybee Apple put back Front Row later, as he put back into iPhoto the calendar function...





You seem to be confused. Someone may want certain advantages of one product (Lion) while trying to avert certain disadvantages of ANOTHER product (iTunes 10.4 running on Lion). And that has nothing to do with being the president of anything. If Apple release a new versoin of Front Row for Lion (even if we have to pay for it), it'll probably be a welcome addition, but, for now, we've discovered that the SL version of Front Row runs just fine on Lion with iTunes 10.3.1, but loses its iTunes connectivity if we upgrade to iTunes 10.4 and above. So, there are several choices now:

  1. Do nothing about the absence of Front Row on Lion, claiming it's a useless product or that "better" options are available (Plex, etc.).
  2. Do nothing about the absence of Front Row on Lion, hoping Apple will release a new version at an undertermined future date.
  3. Install Front Row 2.2.1 on Lion and have full functionality with iTunes 10.3.1, hoping that Apple or a third party (a hacker?) will achieve full integration with later versions of iTunes.
  4. Install Front Row 2.2.1 on Lion with iTunes 10.4, losing iTunes integration, but retaining all other non-iTunes functions (like movie trailers).

I Think you are the one who is very very confused.

"non-iTunes functions "

ITunes is full with movie trailers as far i know....(ITunes--ITunes Store---Movies--Movie Trailers)


Front Row it was allways full with bugs..please do not force me to list them again....

YES, I do waiting for something much, much better!!! until i use what i have!


System pach is works only until the next update!!! and than what? --ohh pach again?

No, sir. I'm not confused at all. But keep waiting.

"Front Row it was allways full with bugs..please do not force me to list them again...."


Oh really? I've been using Front Row for a couple of years now and I have not experienced one glitch at all, which isn't surprising considering how simple the software, the interface and the concept is, which also explains why it is so popular.


Apple, plain and simple was stupid for killing Front Row, just like they were stupid for removing the DVD drive from the Mac Mini and just like they were stupid for removing many used features from Finat Cut X and just like they were stupid to demand 30% from merchants like Amazon and Barnes and Noble to make purchases within apps, forcing them to remove any references on how to purchase content, which for the novice, a big percentage of iPad users, leaves them lost and confused.


I love Apple and their products but they seem to be starting to lose touch with their customers. The one thing though about Apple is that in the past they would often correct their screwups, like the iPod Shuffle stick version and them going going back to the previous design. Hopefully that Apple, the one that wasn't afraid to admit they screwed up, still exists.


Keep taking care of your customers Apple; that's one of your biggest strengths.

You probably did not notice the bugs, because you only used with the dvd drive:DDD

"which also explains why it is so po 00004000 pular."

-Where was popular??? in the american Senior club???


"stupid for removing the DVD drive from the Mac Mini"

-Wake up! nobody using DVD anymore!!!! time is up like VHS, Apple Cloud is comming!


- "iPod Shuffle stick version and them going going back to the previous design."

-You probably a big huge fat american with hot dog fingers, losing weight is better than buy bricks!



Run for Apple president Man! or just simply go back to school and finish your high school!

Zoltan205 wrote:


"You probably did not notice the bugs, because you only used with the dvd drive:DDD"


No, I used it exclusively with content from iTunes and iPhoto. In other words, music, movies, video and audio podcasts and photos.



"-Where was popular??? in the american Senior club???"


What does "American" have to do with what we are discussing?


Obviously a lot of people used Front Row, like most in this and similar threads.



"-Wake up! nobody using DVD anymore!!!! time is up like VHS, Apple Cloud is "


Then maybe you should tell Apple that so they can stop selling it as a separate add on device and so that they do a recall and remove it from recently updated products, like the MacBook Pro and iMacs.


You don't even know the difference between what iCloud does and is supposed to do and what Front Row does.



"You probably a big huge fat american with hot dog fingers, losing weight is better than buy bricks!"


That's the second anti-American remark you have made, which is funny considering you are using an American product and posting to an American website.



"Run for Apple president Man! or just simply go back to school and finish your high school."


And maybe you can grow up.


Why are you posting to this discussion anyway? Front Row doesn't mean anything to you so you posting here makes no sense. Go do something productive.

I would advise that patently stupid tirades by ignoramuses about how "buggy" Front Row supposedly "was" be summarily ignored. Such individuals are totally incapable of providing one single instance of such "bugs" and they contribute absolutely nothing to this thread other than their own lunacy.


Instead of giving an answer to such absurdity, we should concentrate our efforts in finding a way (in case Apple don't create a revamped version of Front Row after iTunes 10.4) to make Front Row "understand" the new format of iTunes Library.itl.

load of many users to replace the dvd drive to SSD in New IMac and Macbook Pro🙂 since you can rent HD movies from ITunes! you dont need anymore Front Row, cloud is replace all that soon!

Most new TV capable to play movies from a single USB hard drive, and have built in internet! conectivity! so i can play my pictures from ICloud:)


My wife is american, iam europian...

I teach using mac, besides i have a small butik Hotel (Guest House) and i am professional dancer an musician!

Check my profile ashole!

You can be proud of yourself! congratulation!

zoltan205 believe it or not we don't give a **** about you, especially me. You aren't bringing anything positive to these discussion forums about the original post.

What a Buda...PEST.

Being an American, it's a shame your wife hasn't seen it fit to teach you some English. Perhaps she thinks it's not worth it. By the way, has your dancing made you dizzy? That could explain a lot.

Becouse you are a high quality:DDD


Learn use your comuther!

I know ist hard if you dont read in your own language

ITunes Plays movies, works with Apple remote, plays music, all in full screen mode!

You can play pictures from finder using alt+space in full screen mode!

Also XMBC its an other, better alternativ ( Hopfuly new update soon for lion) than haking the system! after every ITunes update!


Its more help than recomend illegaly hacking the system! As i said before , waith, maybee Apple put that Front Row Back, but that power the floppy disk back into vogue, could be




Message was edited by: zoltan205


We are living in Europe, my wife is as many american and not not be able to learn any language:)

I spoke more than 4, sorry 00004000 its not perfect:)

You are a low class...

Look who's talking. I guess your dancing lessons must include creeping routines really close to the dirt. You are a real "expert".

Your reply downgrades only yourself, man!

It is easy to be dirty with outh your face?

What makes you imagine that your "grade" is superior to anyone else's? The degree of sheer idiocy you exhibit so blatantly indicates you must be dizzy indeed. Unfortunately for you, your "replies" manifest much more than your absolute ignorance.


So, your "contribution" to this thread is that you expect something "better" than Front Row. Good for you. When that "better" thing finally does arrive, don't forget to post your relevant "expert" assessment. Until then, sir, you would be wise to get lost. If not, you'll be treated as you deserve.

Elsewhere sharpen your tongue! Not my habit to talk with people such as you.....so i just take your advise!

Well done, sir. You see? Even you can learn.

Zoltan205 wrote:


"load of many users to replace the dvd drive to SSD in New IMac and Macbook Pro since you can rent HD movies from ITunes! you dont need anymore Front Row, cloud is replace all that soon!"


Did you even read what I wrote. Better question, did you understand what I wrote, since obviously English is not your first language.


"Most new TV capable to play movies from a single USB hard drive, and have built in internet! conectivity! so i can play my pictures from ICloud:)"


I already have an Apple TV connected to my TV. That has zero to do with me wanting Front Row *on my iMac!*


"My wife is american, iam europian...

I teach using mac, besides i have a small butik Hotel (Guest House) and i am professional dancer an musician!"


Does she know that you are obviously anti-American? What did you marry her for, to get a green card?


Once again. The fact that you are using an American product that you don't have to and are contributing to Apple's American site while obviously being anti-American is quite amusing, not to mention contributing to a discussion that has absolutely nothing to do with you.


Also, you can't compare your wife's nationality and what you claim since Europe is not a country. That said, I am not surprised you are from a European country.


I am not interested in your profession.


"Check my profile ashole! You can be proud of yourself! congratulation!"


Wonderful language. That really contributes constructively to the discussion.


I am also not interested in your profile.

As a said, this does not alter your quality

I leaving in Hungary, as i said!

Zoltan wrote:


"Learn use your comuther! I know ist hard if you dont read in your own language"


It's the native English speakers here that have a problem understanding English.


"ITunes Plays movies, works with Apple remote, plays music, all in full screen mode!

You can play pictures from finder using alt+space in full screen mode!

Also XMBC its an other, better alternativ ( Hopfuly new update soon for lion) than haking the system! after every ITunes update!"


So if you have an iMac in your bedroom and say you are lying in bed how do you go about seeing the iTunes and Finder window and selecting what you want to watch? Maybe with binoculars?


I'm starting to suspect that you have never even used Front Row if you can not understand how it works relative to your bizarre alternatives.


"Its more help than recomend illegaly hacking the system! As i said before , waith, maybee Apple put that Front Row Back, but that power the floppy disk back into vogue, could be"


It is not illegal to hack, as you call it, your own paid for system.


When Apple removed the floppy drive there was actually an alternative, and a better one. Such is not the case with Front Row since things like Plex, and others, do not give you the ability to very simply access all your media content on your computer with a simple interface and a simple remote.


"We are living in Europe, my wife is as many american and not not be able to learn any language:)

I spoke more than 4, sorry its not perfect:)"


Once again, Europe is not a country so stop talking as if it is. You live in Hungary.


I feel really sorry for your American wife. I hope one day soon, for her sake, she finds out how anti-American you are.

Of course. What made you think you could alter my "quality"? Thoughtlessness rarely can have such an effect.

Wow! you are incredebile necty person, as your replys reflecting that!

I think is nice i speek your language, even if is not perfect! I try to help in your langauge so it not nice to criticize me if you are not better! Lets forget my family ok? What my family is do with Front Row?

Hungary its an EU Country, just in case , if nobody told you yet!

Why don't you guys/girls exchange your personal email addresses so thatyou can continue your 00004000 disscussion about nothing there.

This thread is for mac users to discuss issues they have with Front Row.

Not.....

"Hungary its an EU Country"

"I think is nice i speek your language"

"I feel really sorry for your American wife"

etc...etc...etc....


I have to quote Taxes here....

"Once again. The fact that you are using an American product that you don't have to and are contributing to Apple's American site while obviously being anti-American is quite amusing, not to mention contributing to a discussion that has absolutely nothing to do with you."


Stop this childish behavior and lets get back to complaining about Front Row being taken from us!😉


This app should be offered in the App store!!!

Here is the reason I will not upgrade to LION. I purchased a MacMini and a remote control earlier THIS YEAR and set it up in my living room and connected a 42 inch monitor through HDMI. Now when I come home at night I have news podcasts from some of the world media waiting for me. All I have to do is to grab the remote and I am getting my news updates. I don't want to use a keyboard and a mouse because I have a todler who won't leave those alone. When I want to play music for my child I use the same remote to access my whole music library. My system works with FRONT ROW. I don't want to mess up my system with 3rd party applications. I am very disappointed that Apple took something that works perfectly for a lot of us and discontinued it. I will not upgrade to Lion until it includes Front Row.

I respect your position, but I don't think installing SL Front Row on Lion qualifies as "messing up" your system with "3rd party applications". It's an Apple product running on an Apple OS and Apple hardware. There's no mess. And it works great. An altogether different issue is its lack of connectivity with the iTunes Library.itl of iTunes 10.4 and above (which, in any case, does NOT affect photos, movies and so on). We are trying to be constructive here.

I was referring to Plex and other 3rd party applications that some are advocating. Installing Front Row on Lion might be a good solution for now (if the remote works) but what happens when other files get updated by Apple but Front Row doesn't? The lack of iTunes connectivity is already an issue. I'm a pro Apple user and I spend a lot of time making things work on my video editing Macs at work. I just don't want to spend my time fiddling with the Mini when I come home. I just want it to work as a media center. Therefore I won't update to Lion. That's all I'm saying.

Fine. That's reasonable.

Yes, I won't be upgrading my mac mini as well. I just wish I didn't upgrade my macbook pro, and I won't be upgrading my other MacBook Pro as well.


At least until they bring Front Row Back. As for the reported "ton's of bugs" I don't see that at all.

I am not happy about the removal of the DVD, I actually use it a lot, since I burn all my DVD's with handbrake and then move then over to my 4TB Buffalo NAS box, and I won't be using apple's iCloud, since I spend a lot of time at the lake, and no there is no adsl or high speed internet out there.


This is just a money grab for Apple, yeah, store everything on the iCloud, and we'll charge you for this and that, and then just a little more for this!

Taxes,


I totally disagree with you. I use both Front Row and my DVD, and will continue to do so for quite some time to come. Not everyone will use the Cloud, for numerous reasons. The Topic of this post is I want Front Row Back. And I've noticed a lot of poeple here use Front Row, and agree. If you don't, that is your opion, and your welcome to it, just as we are with ours.


Regards,

Louis

TEMPORARY SOLUTION (HOWEVER IT WORKS):


1) Front Row Row works with Lion no issues regarding that.

2) The difference between iTunes 10.3 and 10.4 is in the application itself and in the ~/Music/iTunes/iTunes Library.itl.

3) Front Row doesn't care which specific version iTunes.app is. iTunes connectivity is effected exclusively through iTunes Library.itl

4) If you replace your 10.4 iTunes Library.itl with the latest version you had under 10.3.1 (you can locate it under ~/Music/iTunes/Previous iTunes Libraries), Front Row and iTunes connectivity will be automatically restored IN FULL.

5) However this will create instability in iTunes that will not show extra music added in that period, and also will ask for updates of the apps that appeard in iTunes Store in the same period.

6) More to that if you open iTunes 10.4, it'll modify your iTunes Library.itl and also connectivity with Front Row will be once again eliminated.

7) So here is the trick: Make an ALIAS of the latest version of iTunes Library.itl you had under 10.3.1 (again you can locate it under ~/Music/iTunes/Previous iTunes Libraries).

8) Rename the Alias ITunes Library (no extension required).

9) DON'T LAUNCH iTunes.

10) Move the Alias to ~/Music/iTunes.

11) Launch Front Row and it will work again recognising all the Music.

12) When you are finished with Front Row just re-move the Alias back to ~/Music/iTunes/Previous iTunes Libraries before launching iTunes.

13) Done....just remember the above steps and be sure that you move the Alias out of ~/Music/iTunes before launching iTunes, and just remember to move it in before launchinng Front Row.


Cheers for now, hope it works for you guys.

The alias is a good idea for those who don't want to go back to iTunes 10.3.1, but there are two possibly minor catches:

  1. If you forget to move the alias back to ./Previous iTunes Libraries and you launch iTunes (10.4), the latest 10.3.1 library will be messed up by iTunes.
  2. Front Row will never be able to see any new iTunes content added since the 10.4 update.


There might be a convoluted "solution" involving copying the 10.3.1 version of iTunes.app to /Application under a new name (for instance, iTunes 10.3.1.app), which would access an old version of iTunes Library.itl. That way, new content to the iTunes Library could theoretically be added to by the old version. Then the itl file could be copied to ./Previous iTunes Libraries. Finally, the regular (10.4) iTunes.app would convert the old-style itl library to the new format. When we want to launch Front Row, we would only have to copy the latest itl library from ./Previous iTunes Libraries to its parent folder, and so on. All this might be automated via one or two Automator flows.


Another theoretical process might involve altering the Front Row core application so that it wouldn't access iTunes Library.itl but a new file named "iTunes-Library.itl", and altering a copy of version 10.3.1 iTunes.app so that it will access "iTunes-Library.itl" (not "iTunes Library.itl"). That way, we would have two independent copies of iTunes, 10.3.1 and 10.4, running independently from each other, each being able to add new iTunes content without messing up each other's itl library and Front Row being able to work well with all iTunes content despite the presence of iTunes 10.4 on Lion.


What do you guys think?

Yes, your points are valid, however, and as mentioned, this is just a temporary solution/workaround to make the program fully working.


Regarding a permanent fix, I believe option number one is actually not practical, even if it could work, and option number two could be better.


Even better....fixing Front Row core to be able to read and pilot the new iTunes-Library.itl from iTunes 10.4.


Last but not least, keep in mind that iTunes 11 will dramatically change and it will basically integrate back in the program itself what Front Row used to be, plus with a wider integration throughout the OS.

When iTunes 11 does arrive, it will be a great plus if it really integrates the entire Front Row experience. Meanwhile, altering Front Row so that it will accept the new 10.4+ itl library may be very difficult to accomplish if we can't access the source code. Naturally, this is purely theoretical, as reverse engineering is an illegal practice. In addition, decompiling "Front Row.app/Contents/MacOS/Front Row" may be tricky, and, in addition, the actual structure of the itl library may be a well-guarded secret, so it would be hard for a would-be hacker to produce a fully 10.4+ compatible Front Row. On the other hand, in all likelihood, my second "solution" would merely involve hex-editing a few Unix executables (which I suppose might also be illegal). As they say, this is only stated "for educational purposes".

Bring back Frontrow ASAP (for Lion)- I know of another 4 people who use a mac mini as a media centre with SL - Frontrow is stable and the 10 foot UI isGretat as is the small simple apple remote.

Yes, I just realize that Front Row is not included in the OS X Lion. Me too, I want the return of Front Row application, which was a nice nice. HowApple could have thought that?

What a disappointment, I hope Apple will change their minds LATER ...

Apple, Please Give us this wonderful application.

Indeed, it is a great dissapointment to find out that Front Row disapeared after installing Lion.

What is the alternative?

breeaz

My computer skills are too limited to suggest a solution. But frankly that I hope Apple find a way to restore our Front Row. Remove this applicationdoes not make sense.

Advance does not mean delete a working application. Go Apple Treat your customers!

A TEMPORARY SOLUTION


Faced with the dilemma of having an iCloud-ready version of iTunes (10.4 and above) or a Front Row-compatible version of iTunes (10.3.1) running on Lion, and while we await for a definitive solution brought by Apple, there are things we can do to have the best of both worlds running on Lion through some Applescript code. I've quickly put together the code presented below, which can still be greatly improved upon. Although it is offered with no guarantees, it should work well in most situations. For it to work properly, several requirements must be met:

  1. The script is intended to run on Lion. It's unnecessary in Snow Leopard and it won't work in anything below Lion.
  2. iTunes 10.4 must be installed.
  3. A copy of the iTunes 10.3.1 application (i.e., not the framework or any other componentes) must ALSO be in the /Applications folder with the name "iTunes 10.3.1". If you already have iTunes (10.4) in place, simply copy a backup copy of the previous iTunes. Remember to rename it as "iTunes 10.3.1".
  4. A copy of the old-style iTunes Library (iTunes Library.itl) must exist in ~/Music/iTunes with the name "old-style iTunes Library.itl". You can get it from ~/Music/iTunes/Previous iTunes Libraries.
  5. A copy of the new-style iTunes Library (iTunes Library.itl if you have run iTunes 10.4) must exist in ~/Music/iTunes with the name "new-style iTunes Library.itl".
  6. Front Row must have been reinstalled. Ralph Perdomo created a package to achieve this on Lion.


If all six requirements are met, the following script (name it anything you like and place it wherever it suits you) will see to it that your iTunes Library is, at all times, ready to do what you want it to do, effecting EITHER (future) iCloud-compatibility OR Front Row-compatibility. Notice that this doesn't involve any hacks of any kind. When you swap from iCloud-compatibility to Front Row-compatibility, and vice versa, the script makes some noise (it sends temporary files to the trash). A revamped version of the script might avoid this noise in future. The script even allows you to launch Front Row from it if you've just used it to make your iTunes Library Front Row-compatible.


Here's the script:


#Make sure any instances of iTunes (10.3.1 or above) is closed

set iTunesVersion to "iTunes"

tell applicationiTunesVersion


quit

end tell


#Establish common dialog title

set dialogTitle to "iTunes integration with Front Row/iCloud on Lion"


#Check that Lion is running

set osVersion to do shell script "sw_vers -productVersion"

if osVersion < "10.7" then

display dialog "This is not intended for versions below OS X 10.7 Lion" buttons {"OK"} with title dialogTitle with icon stop

return

end if


#Check that iTunes 10.4 or above is installed

set iTunesMainVersion to ""

tell applicationiTunesVersion

set iTunesMainVersion to version

end tell

if iTunesMainVersion < "10.4" then

display dialog "This can only run if your regular version of iTunes is 10.4 or above" buttons {"OK"} with title dialogTitle with icon stop

return

end if


#Check that iTunes 10.3.1 is also installed

try

set iTunesFrontRowVersion to (path to applications folder as text) & "iTunes 10.3.1.app" as alias

on error number -43

display dialog "This can only run if, in addition to iTunes 10.4 or above, you have iTunes 10.3.1 in your Applications folder" buttons {"OK"} with title dialogTitle with icon stop

return

end try


#Check that old-style iTunes Library.itl exists

set oldStyle_iTunesLibrary to ""

try

set oldStyle_iTunesLibrary to (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:old-style iTunes Library.itl" as alias

on error number -43

display dialog "old-style iTunes Library.itl does not exist in" & (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:" buttons {"OK"} with title dialogTitle with icon stop

return

end try


#Check that new-style iTunes Library.itl exists

set newStyle_iTunesLibrary to ""

try

set newStyle_iTunesLibrary to (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:new-style iTunes Library.itl" as alias

on error number -43

display dialog "new-style iTunes Library.itl does not exist in" & (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:" buttons {"OK"} with title dialogTitle with icon stop

return

end try


#Make sure iTunes 10.4 or above is closed

tell applicationiTunesVersion


quit

end tell


#Make sure iTunes 10.3.1 is closed

set iTunesVersion to "iTunes 10.3.1"

tell applicationiTunesVersion


quit

end tell


#Check that Front Row is installed

try

set 00004000 iTunesFrontRowVersion to (path to applications folder as text) & "Front Row.app" as alias

on error number -43

display dialog "This can only run if you have installed Front Row" buttons {"OK"} with title dialogTitle with icon stop

return

end try


#Establish version of current iTunes Library.itl

set currentItlLibrary to (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:iTunes Library.itl" as alias

set currentItlLibraryVersion to (read (currentItlLibrary) from 18 to 23 asstring)


#Prompt the user as to their choices

set message to "The current version of iTunes Library.itl is " & currentItlLibraryVersion & ", which is compatible with "

if currentItlLibraryVersion < "10.4" then

set message to message & "Front Row.

Do you want to make it iCloud-compatible instead?"

else

set message to message & "iCloud.

Do you want to make it Front Row-compatible instead?"

end if

set question to display dialogmessagebuttons {"Yes", "No"} default button 2 with titledialogTitlewith icon 2

set answer to button returned of question


#If the user decides not to change the format, quit

if answer = "No" then

return

end if


if currentItlLibraryVersion < "10.4" then


#Copy iTunes Library.itl to old-style iTunes Library.itl

tell application "Finder" to duplicatefilecurrentItlLibrary

tell application "Finder" to deletefileoldStyle_iTunesLibrary

set temporary_iTunesLibrary to (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:iTunes Library copy.itl" as alias

tell application "Finder" to set name of file temporary_iTunesLibrary to "old-style iTunes Library.itl"



#Copy new-style iTunes Library.itl to iTunes Library.itl

tell application "Finder" to duplicatefilenewStyle_iTunesLibrary

tell application "Finder" to delete file currentItlLibrary

set temporary_iTunesLibrary to (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:new-style iTunes Library copy.itl" as alias

tell application "Finder" to set name of file temporary_iTunesLibrary to "iTunes Library.itl"



#Launch newer version of iTunes so that it will update the library, if necessary


# do shell script "/Applications/iTunes.app/Contents/MacOS/iTunes -ProfileManager"

set iTunesVersion to "iTunes"

tell applicationiTunesVersion


launch

end tell




#Advise the user

display dialog "iTunes has been launched so that it will update its library with whatever purchases you may have made while running iTunes 10.3.1. You may quit iTunes whenever you are ready. Front Row integration has been suspended and iCloud integration restored." buttons {"OK"} with title dialogTitle with icon 2

else


#Copy iTunes Library.itl to new-style iTunes Library.itl

tell application "Finder" to duplicatefilecurrentItlLibrary

tell application "Finder" to deletefilenewStyle_iTunesLibrary

set temporary_iTunesLibrary to (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:iTunes Library copy.itl" as alias

tell application "Finder" to set name of file temporary_iTunesLibrary to "new-style iTunes Library.itl"



#Copy old-style iTunes Library.itl to iTunes Library.itl

tell application "Finder" to duplicatefileoldStyle_iTunesLibrary

tell application "Finder" to delete file currentItlLibrary

set temporary_iTunesLibrary to (path to home folder as text) & "Music:iTunes:old-style iTunes Library copy.itl" as alias

tell application "Finder" to set name of file temporary_iTunesLibrary to "iTunes Library.itl"



#Launch older version of iTunes so that it will update the library, if necessary

set iTunesVersion to "iTunes 10.3.1"

tell applicationiTunesVersion


launch

end tell



#Advise the user

set question to display dialog "iTunes 10.3.1 has been launched so that it will update its library with whatever purchases you may have made while running newer versions of iTunes. You may quit iTunes whenever you are ready. iCloud integration has been suspended and Front Row integration restored." buttons {"Close", "Close iTunes", "Launch Front Row"} default button 3 with title dialogTitle with icon 2

set answer to button returned of question



#If the user decides not to do anything, quit

if answer = "Close" then

return

end if

tell applicationiTunesVersion


quit

end tell

if answer = "Launch Front Row" then

tell application "System Events"


key code 53 usingcommand down

end tell

end if

end if

-------------------------------------------------------------

Enjoy!

I can only agree that the scrapping of Front Row without explanation, alternative or apology is an infuriating move by Apple but sadly this kind of inconsideration to its customers and users no longer comes as any surprise.


Plex has its attractions but it is cumbersome, doesn't have effective itunes integration and requires me to rename and relocate my entire collection of movies, home movies and other videos. I'd prefer it to do no data scraping (it makes very many mistakes [probably because my files aren't named to its liking] but unless I am missing something the function cannot be turned off.


I've never had Boxee work effectively. XBMC did well with my old 1st generation Apple TV and ATV Flash but I thought I had left all that behind.


Combined with the imminent loss (without the option) of useful MobileMe functionality, the arrogant axing of Front Row is hugely annoying. The developments have led me to no longer recommend Apple to others.

question is.. who do we start sending emails to to get it back? homebrew is not good enough. They basically said to themselves "F it! they won't even notice its gone."


I noticed and I want it back. There is no real alternative.

It is true, as you say, that "homebrew is not good enough". And although I did provide some sort of a "homebrew" script that allows iTunes 10.3.1, 10.4 and Front Row to peacefully coexist on Lion, I also indicated that this recipe of mine was intended as a hack-free, temporary solution "while we [wait] for a definitive solution 00004000 brought by Apple".

I know that I can get Front Row from diferent places back, but I refuse to downgrade ITunes to sync with the app! This is not suppose to work LIKE THIS!

I want Apple to fix it!! I paid for my MAC! and OS X LION! I WANT IT BACK! UP AND RUNNING!


Follow us on twitter @saramapeche hash #IWantFrontRowBack and make of this the next problem to solve for Apple.😠

CANT LIVE WITHOUT FRONT ROW


I have MacBook Pro 2011, iMac 2011, iPhone 4, AppleTV 2, Mac Mini 2011, TimeCapsule, Airport expresses, iPad 2, trackpads, MobileMe family account.... totally apple fanatic.

Have bought almost all the apple apps....


Used MacMini as MediaCenter using FrontRow.... it was brilliant.....


Now its gone???? without any other solution...


I simply cant believe it!


We all have to live without flash support, java, HDMI etc. But this ... this was one really big advantage in Apple...


So sad...

Hi,


I agree with you, I bought a remote control especially for Front Row and now i cant use it... I hope it will go back to the Mac else, i hope a new MediaCenter will replace it QUICKLY!!!

It's not in the Lion update that has just been released!

http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4764

Here's one more person who want's Front Row.


I watch a lot of DVDs, almost all of the TV shows I watch I get from iTunes, I move around a lot (ever year or two) so rather than have another TV to lug around I decided for years to use my iMac as a TV. Front Row was one of the selling points that made me switch to Mac in the first place.


For me, the Mac is 1/3rd computer, 1/3rd TV, and 1/3rd stereo. Lion just downgraded 2/3rds of my Mac.

Could not agree more...


I also could show an apple to many people, who was simply amazed and incrediably impressed as soon as you took out the little remote and pressed MENU to enter Front Row.


I no longer recommend apple computers, because I cant show 1/3 computer ... 1/3 TV ... 1/3 music ... 1/3 picture booth etc....



So sad so sad ... please apple let Front Row back ...

so the question is where do we start making enough noise to force the change? Facebook page? Twitter? I was praying this would re appear in 10.7.1 but it was suspiciously absent. APPLE people bought your product based on what it can do and then you take that functionality away from something they paid for. Thats almost as bad as the 3g ipad unlimited data bait and switch you pulled with At&t. You want us to buy apple tv's I get that but you have these beatiful 27 inch screens that I loved using for movies and tv. I bought a 27 inch iMac specifically because of that. thats 2000 dollars I could have saved. Thanks. The least you can do with your 78 billion in cash is spend a few thousand putting front row back on the app store as a free app. I want what I paid for. I wonder what a class action lawsuit would accomplish in this case?

What's the mailing address to the people who decided to ditch 'Front Row'? I want to mail them my useless Apple remote so they can take turns 'sticking it' where the Cupertino sun don't shine.

Yep still ******.

I have called written and complained on this forum....

For some reaseon I feel as if it is only falling on deaf ears!!!

Come on Applke!!

Do the right thing offer it in the app store!!!

please bring front row back to OS X.

bring it back and improve it.

add airplay to itunes music playlist.

Why remove something that many liked very much

We should all write our frustrations here ... http://www.apple.com/feedback/macosx.html

We should all write our frustrations here ... http://www.apple.com/feedback/macosx.html

I have tried the trial version of Remote Buddy and it is crashing on my MBP.


http://www.iospirit.com/products/remotebuddy/software/

"Starting with OS X® Lion, Front Row is no longer part of the OS. It is therefore no longer supported by Remote Buddy under OS X® Lion 10.7 and later..."


I have looked at the possibility of Applescripts but it does not look hopeful. Looks like I will have to be satisifed with keyboard control of Front Row for now.


Some sites I have looked at:

http://www.iospirit.com/developers/hidremote/releasenotes/

http://www.iospirit.com/developers/hidremote/

http://cocoadev.com/wiki/UsingTheAppleRemoteControl

I can't figure out why Remote Buddy should crash on your MBP. It has always worked flawlessly on my Mac Pro, back in SL days, with Lion and with Mountain Lion now (version 1.21.1). I suggest that you write to the developer, who will probably be able to figure out what's wrong.

I wonder if any of you used, successfully on Mountain Lion, Front Row with DVDpedia and the DVDpedia.frappliance plugin ?

No optical drive with the new iMac so an even stronger case to bring back Front Row (to play MP4 video). The new Mac Mini has also lost the optical drive. Apple TV is not a viable substitute for Front Row on a Mac.


I suppose that during the next OS update DVD Player will disappear - like Front Row did with Lion.


Grrr

How does one voice this to Apple through the support network?


I want Front Row back, too.

Where to send product feedback to Apple:


http://www.apple.com/feedback/


But Front Row will not work with either Lion or Mountain Lion and we will not see it again.

And to really rub salt into the wound, the Mac Mini has 1 Thunderbolt and 1 HDMI port. The obvious use for the HDMI port is to connect to a HD TV. But then what - use it as a big monitor? As I understand it the Mac Mini lacks the interactive menu of Apple TV and, of course, it won't run Front Row.


Grrr

Snow Leopard is back in the app store:

http://www.macrumors.com/2012/11/21/os-x-10-6-snow-leopard-again-available-on-th e-apple-online-store/

If anyone buys it please report if Front Row is there, or works better than ML

Just installed iTunes 11 on my Macbook Pro running Mountain Lion 10.8.2. Not surprisingly I still cannot access music, TV or movies from the iTunes library (I have not tried to set up any of the tricks detailed by other users above).


It seems that Apple is supporting Snow Leopard and iTunes for "legacy" machines that won't run Mountain Lion.


Should I try iTunes 11 with my Snow Leopard iMac (where Front Row is running perfectly)? I am not in a hurry to do this.


Please post on this discussion if you have found iTunes 11 breaks (or does not break ) Front Row functionality.

Hi Michael,


well of course you can try that, but I really doubt that it will work.

Front Row itself runs on Snow Leopard and Mountain Lion. The Problem is, that it is not able to read the iTunes Library anymore since iTunes 11.7. So that has nothing to do with the OS.


If you really want to make it run, you have to downgrade your iTunes to iTunes 10.4



But I have an alternative for you. I use XMBC now. It is free and not as beautiful or elegant as Front Row, but works fine with the remote.


Greetings,

Thomas

Edit:

It did run ;-)


Seems like something went wrong after upgrading to iTunes 11. Since this, the remote does not work anymore in XMBC.....


And if you want to make sure that Front Row runs, don't choose iTunes 10.4. Try the previous Version.

I have now installed iTunes 11 on my iMac running Snow Leopard (after making a back-up so I could revert to iTunes 10). Surprisingly all Front Row functionality is retained. Music works. Movies work, including DRM movies, Top Movies and Trailers and DRM TV shows work... Phew


Whether it is worth "upgrading" to iTunes 11 is another matter.

It boggles my mind why Apple killed this program, when the Mac Mini is a perfect living room computer (aching to be a game console as well). They are sitting in a pile of cash and don't even know it.

I couldn't agree more, postnocomments. I have the 2011 mini. It sits in my living room plugged into my TV. In our home it is the "only" way we have to watch Netflix. Our children play games there, where we can watch them. It's our hub for watching TV Shows and Movies from our collection. It replaced a large desktop tower that was (not so well) hidden behind our TV, drastically cutting down on power, noise, and space. So I just can't fathom why Apple would remove the media centre power of this mini power house! In fact, just last night we watched a great movie. So with such a great market just sitting around the living room, why is Apple making me stand up and walk across my living room to select/start/pause movies? And don't say get a remote... my mini came with the Apple Remote right in the box. I have to use it for Plex. So why is Apple making me use Plex?

Now I figure I'll be upgrading my 2nd gen iPod and getting a iPad Mini soon, so maybe I'll couple that with a third party Air Server app and then stream from the iPad to the Mini. But that feel's backwards to me. Why house my movies on my mini, stream it to my iPad, then bounce it back to my mini to display it on my TV? (sigh) Isn't there a better sollution?

Just confirming my previous post that Front Row running under Snow Leopard can still play music from ITunes 11. It is Mountain Lion that breaks the Front Row/Music link.

I am the creator of the AppleScript you used in your so-called discovery. As for the claim that Mountain Lion breaks Front Row, that is not so. The same thing happened under Lion. The culprit is the structure that iTunes 10.4+ enforces on its own "iTunes Library.itl" when running on a 64-bit operating system. That is why Front Row continues to work flaswlessly with iTunes 10.4.x or iTunes 11 under Snow Leopard (a 32-bit operating system), whereas iTunes integration is broken in both Lion and Mountain Lion if iTunes 10.4.x or iTunes 11 is run. Front Row will still play iTunes music and videos in Lion/Mountain Lion if "iTunes Library.itl" has 10.3.1 structure.

Just to be sure I properly understand : any iTunes library created under a 32 bit system (Snow Leopard or below) can run in Front Row "read only" as long as the library has never been modified after been copied to the Lion / Mountain Lion disk : right ?

No, the issue is not the operating system as such. It's the version of "iTunes Library.itl". It 00004000 the version of "iTunes Library.itl" is 10.3.1 or below (even in a 64-bit operating system, such as Lion or Mountain Lion), Front Row will read that library correctly (even in Lion and Mountain Lion). The problem is that iTunes 10.4+ will modify the structure of "iTunes Library.itl" under 64-bit operating systems in such a way that it's no longer compatible with Front Row. Back in the days of Lion, I created a relatively complex AppleScript that was able to run BOTH iTunes 10.3.1 AND iTunes 10.4+ in Lion and allowed one to use Front Row with an old version of one's library, or revert to the new version of the same library, thereby restoring iCloud compatibility. That original AppleScript can be slightly modified for it to run with Mountain Lion and launch Front Row, etc., but I haven't had the time or the inclination to effect the modification myself. I just created a much shorter version that simply launches Front Row itself, leaving the issue of iTunes library compatibility to the user.


I haven't checked the effect of making "iTunes Library.itl" read-only, but that would hardly be useful, as far as updating your iTunes library is concerned.

Sorry, I was not clear enough : from your posts, I understand that running iTunes 10.3.1 under Snow Leopard will keep iTunes Library.itl Front Row compatible, even when later running under Lion or Mountain Lion AS LONG AS it is not modified from the original 10.3.1 version (what I called "read only Front Row").

And I was wondering if running even iTunes 11 under the same Snow Leopard (not 64 bits) would still keep iTunes Library.itl Front Row compatible, when migrated AND NOT MODIFIED under Lion or Mountain Lion.


I have 2 Macs, and my "Master Mac" still runs Leopard with Front Row, although my HTMini runs Lion, with videos and music libraries slaved to my Master Mac.

Under Snow Leopard, all versions of "iTunes Library.itl" (including versions 10.4+, 10.5+, 10.7+ and 11) are Front Row-compatible. The problem comes when iTunes 10.4+, etc. are run in 64-bit mode (i.e., in Lion/Mountain Lion). The moment you do that, the structure of "iTunes Library.itl" changes, and Front Row compatibility is broken. Even if you were to backup your iTunes 11 folders under Snow Leopard and restore them to Mountain Lion, the "iTunes Library.itl" structure would be compatible for as long as you DIDN'T run iTunes 10.4+. Once you run it, Front Row compatibility will be lost.


Naturally, you can resort to my first AppleScript and install iTunes 10.3.1 AND iTunes 11 on your Mountain Lion machine. That way, you decide if, at one given moment, you have an iCloud-compatible "iTunes Library.itl" OR a Front Row-compatible "iTunes Library.itl", but you have to do the swapping yourself and see to it that you don't inadvertently run iTunes 11 when the current version of "iTunes Library.itl" is 10.3.1.

Thank you Edumara for that explanation. All the more reason to retain Snow Leopard on old Macs so they can be "retired" as media centres capable of running Front Row in all its glory.


As I reported on 25th Nov, Apple is still selling (and presumably supporting ) Snow Leopard, which will run iTunes 11 and remains compatible with Front Row. There are many Macs in use that cannot run Mountain Lion so this situation should continue for some time.

Does anyone see the correlation with unsatisfied loyal customers and Apple stock price. Satisfaction has erroded and so has apple stock price. Boy I miss Steve! The Apple company does to as quiet as it is kept.

This discussion started in July 2011 when dismayed Lion users found that Front Row had vanished. Evidently the decision was made many months before that, when Steve was still at the helm.


Since then we have waited to see what brilliant corporate strategy would justify dropping Front Row - an AppleTV app for the Mac, iTV or whatever - but nothing has turned up. It seems so simple to update Front Row to run on Lion or Mountain Lion and keep many Mac users happy.


So if you are new to this discussion please send feedback to Apple:

http://www.apple.com/feedback/macosx.html

Of course I'd like to find Front Row back on OS X.

At present, it must be put in evidence, nothing replaces Front Row on my computer screen.

Apple TV is a different strategy ...

Thank you for giving attention to this message

Thank you for the suggestion feedback

happy Holidays

I'm stil running Snow Leopard on an older iMac (just haven't bit the bullet yet on a new one), and lately I've had a problem with the video and audio being out of sync in Front Row.


What happens is that when I watch Movies & TV Shows in Front Row, the video and audio fall out of sync after approximately 10 minutes. It's like watching a poorly dubbed Martial Arts flick. If I hit the menu button on my remote to back to the movie or episode list, then select the program I was watching and resume play, the video and audio are in sync again, but only for about 10 minutes and then I have to back out and resume play again.


As a result, I've been watching everything in iTunes, which is kind of annoying. I can't be certain, but I'm pretty sure the problem started when I installed iTunes 11. I had hoped the recent iTunes 11 update would solve the problem, but it hasn't.


Anyone have any thoughts?

Please start a new discussion on your topic. This one is about Apple dropping Front Row. You are more likely to get an answer with a separate discussion topic.

That hasn't been my experience so far, which is why I posted the question in a thread that's actually seen some activity lately. But thanks anyway.

My apologies - the audio-syncing problem is relevant to this discussion. When I reported that Front Row worked with iTunes 11 running under Snow Leopard I had only watched the start of a couple of movies to check there were no authorisation problems. With my system (Snow Leopard and iTunes 11) I had the audio-sync problem start after about 10 minutes but only for movies purchased through iTunes. The copy-protection system seems to have changed.


I have restored a Time Machine back-up of my system to return to iTunes 10.7 and the same movies run without problems.


I did try to just replace the iTunes app and Music library to older versions, using Time Machine, but ran into Store authorisation difficulties so had to do a full system restore.


So the lesson is: if you want to run Front Row do not "upgrade" to iTunes 11.

I'm late to the party; just upgraded our family system to Mountain Lion, and found Front Row is gone. I've missed all the lessons above. I regret the upgrade, and paying for it; we used it regularly. Very disappointing. Apple, would love for you to bring this back.


...sigh

XBMC does not require that you rename files; it even has some advantages over FR: point it at a folder full of .rar files for an mkv movie - which for QuickTime would have to be uncompressed and then loaded into the player - and XBMC just plays the movie instantly.

It's still no substitute for FR. All the alternatives seem to me both over- and underdesigned: too many features and an impenetrable interface. And XBMC can't play iTunes playlists (as far as I can tell).

It's hard to believe that Apple keeps ignoring this when the Mac is such an ideal media centre.

I want to have wifi in the basement.

I have given up and bought an Apple TV. I use an iPad and the Remote app to control ATV and access the itunes library of the iMac - audio, movies, TV. The HDMI video and digital sound are very good.


I can still send video to my projector from the iMac via wifi to the ATV (eg EyeTV live & recordings). Airparrot (mac app) is very useful for this as it mirrors video and audio to ATV. I can even use Front Row via Airparrot. However the digital sound is way out of sync when going through the ATV and so I have to use other speakers directly attached to the iMac (I have some old Lacie Firewire speakers that are OK for this).


I will keep running Snow Leopard on the iMac so 00004000 that I will always have Front Row available. It would have been so much simpler to have had Front Row running under Mountain Lion!

Have you noticed that AppleTV successfully presents your (10.4+) iTunes library much in the way Front Row used to do in the iTunes 10.3 days? If it were possible to get the AppleTV Finder from the AppleTV software, we could probably get at least a Front-Row-like iTunes framework that can be used to replace the outdated framework in the CoreServices Front Row application.

Nigh impossible I suspect.


If only Apple would release an "Apple TV" app for OS X...


Grrr!

It needn't be. AppleTV software is downloadable. I downloaded it myself from an Apple server. The "only" problem is that Finder.app is included in a nested password-protected dmg. Previous iterations of AppleTV are known to have been protected by one particular password ("alpine"), but that no longer works. If hackers of ATV3 find the new password, extracting the Finder should be straightforward.

I should add that, in effect, the iMac is just a server for the ATV. I play content from iTunes on the iMac directly from the ATV menu or using the Remote app on an iPad. A Mac Mini would be suitable for this purpose as the display is redundant.


The main nuisance is watching digital TV (EyeTV on the iMac). As I mentioned, the digital sound sync is poor when using Airplay between the iMac and ATV. With the current version of EyeTV this has to be done via Airparrot (a great Mac app) as EyeTV does not support Airplay. An alternative is to stream the TV show to an iPad using the EyeTV app and then send this to the ATV via Airplay. This works and the digital sound is in sync but the video quality is poor.


Another nuisance with the ATV arrangement is that all movies and TV shows must be "registered" in iTunes on the iMac in order for the ATV to find them. With Front Row I could (can) access any video in my home/movies folder including aliases to folders on external hard disks. Now when I add a movie to an external hard disk I have to drag its icon to iTunes and then set the type (movie, TV show etc), show name and/or genre before it appears in ATV.


I would still much prefer an updated Front Row so I can use the iMac as the media centre (and there would be fewer remote control devices!).

Please Apple, bring back front row. Please Mister Apple Sir, please bring back my favourite media player.

Front Row was simple, user friendly and played all your itunes media. It was brilliant. I don't see why Apple axed it. It doesn't do any harm being there. For the people who don't like it, they didn't have to use it. But all of us who love it are suffering. Infact it was so good, Sony copied Apples design.


Plex is good but it has too much going on. Other media players either aren't user friendly, have way too much stuff or not enough stuff.


I just want Front Row, so when I am in my bed, I can easly scroll through my media.


I have an apple tv, but that is in my lounge and my imac is in my room facing my bed.

I am impressed: 21 pages about a discussion that people like Front Row. And it is still going on. Yes - it was nice & simple. But it is not available anymore. And it will not be in the future...


Even more interesting: "usefull" tips like

1.) how to get it back (which will not work satisfying as far as I know and read)

2.) alternatives which (as far as I have read) does not seem to make people happy?


At MacWorld there was a similar discussion (http://www.macworld.com/article/2034670/the-computer-in-the-living-room-setting- up-a-mac-mini-media-center.html) and the users posted the major point (in my opinion):

1.) a Front Row style menu and a simple look & feel

2.) direct access to folders (like picture / movie folder / volumes) instead of administrating another structure / library

3.) access to Aperture, iPhoto and iTunes media (including DRM to play rented / bought movies)

4.) access to EyeTV movies to play the recorded motion pictures


For some users it seems that they need some more features:

5.) streaming movies from Mac to iOS

6.) AirPlay support to stream movies from iOS to Mac (with fullscreen support)


Did I forget anything? Yes: the metadata! That is a nice feature which Front Row did not offer but some media center do. And I like that!


But there are some major points which might be a problem:

a.) the file names have to be renamed to find the correct metadata (or at least to give it a try)

b.) some media centers even display other titles for your movies (because of wrong metadata) - you will be impressed about the movies you suddenly have (but you do not)


So - what is the conclusion? I have spend a lot of time since many years to find a suitable media center. Front Row did its work as expected, but is not available anymore for Mac OS X 10.7 or newer. After a lot of research I found a suitable media application with all the features I expect - you can read more about my experiences at http://www.mac-media-center.com.


And if these solutions does not fit your needs - why not to take part of it?

Thank you for that advice. nessMediaCenter has a lot of nice features and you have published a great review.


However, only Front Row gave us access to iTunes music playlists, movies including DRM movies and movies in local alias folders, online stuff such as Top Movies and Trailers, DRM TV shows and iPhoto albums. Plus it also integrated with EyeTV.


Grrr! (the sound of an unhappy Mountain Lion customer)

Thank you for your post, Michael. However, nessMediaCenter gives you access to all the things you mentioned:


1.) iTunes music playlists, TV shows and movies can be accessed at "iTunes" including DRM movies.

2.) Local folders and their media (DVDs, EyeTV movies, pictures, PDFs, videos) can be directly accessed at "Folder Pictures", "Folder Movies" or "Volumes" including alias files to other folders / volumes.

3.) Online stuff like movie trailers in several languages can be found at "Internet", and other internet content like DailyMotion or YouTube can be selected by categories and criteria (newest, most viewed etc.).

4.) iPhoto albums (pictures and videos) can be accessed at "iPhoto".

5.) Miro video podcasts (RSS) and their videos can be accessed, too.


In my opinion, this is similar to the features of Front Row. Even if DRM movies will be started in iTunes and EyeTV movies in EyeTV (or VLC if installed). This might be a disadvantage, but iTunes and EyeTV can be controlled by the remote control after being activated.


If you have an iPhone, iPad or iPod touch and you want to stream movies between Mac and iOS, then the media server of nessViewer might be interesting.


I hope that these little hints will move you from an unhappy to a happy Mountain Lion customer, Michael. If you have further questions or need some help, then you could use the forum at my web side.

Thank you - I will give it a try

I bought nessMediaCenter but although it works, it's incompatible with my own methods. It does not, in fact, handle aliases, ony symbolic links to folders – I like to quickly move aliases of current things into a single folder, then discard them when I've watched the file. I really don't need to see every file I have. It also fails to do XBMC's great trick of simply playing a movie in a folder full of .rar files, instantly, without the need to expand the file first. I still miss FrontRow, and I don't want to buy an Apple TV because I don't own a television!

It does not, in fact, handle aliases, only symbolic links to folders…

nessMediaCenter handles aliases to files, but not aliases to folders - symbolic links must be used instead.


The download image of nessMediaCenter contains an (AppleScript) application named "Create Symbolic Links": drag & drop files or folders on this application and select the target folder to quickly create symbolic links.

I like to quickly move aliases of current things into a single folder…

If the target folder is always the same folder, then this AppleScript application could be modified to simply create the symbolic links always at the same folder. After this little modification, creating symbolic links is as easy as creating aliases by the Finder. Please contact us if you need further help.

I really don't need to see every file I have.

We would suggest to use two folders: one folder for all files you have watched (or do not want to see), and one folder for the other files. After watching files, you simply move these files to the first folder. Different way, same effect.

It also fails to do XBMC's great trick of simply playing a movie in a folder full of .rar files, instantly, without the need to expand the file first.

RAR files must always be expanded before accessing its content. If you select a RAR file in XBMC then you must wait until the RAR file is expanded, too. Depending on the size of the RAR file, this might take a longer time.

In our opinion, the goal of a media center is to watch media instantly and not to wait - this is the reason why we prefer the solution to expand RAR files at any time (outside the media center with a tool like "UnRarX") and then to watch its media instantly.

Hello (Salut !)


I'm from France and I'm try my best in english T__T'


I want SIMPLY -> Front Row <- in news OSX (I mean also Mavericks).


Because this is simply safe to do use that application FR in the property OSX with all things I knew in OSX SW.


Hey Apple, you may listen all reclamations of yours loyal customers !


Yours.

Yes, count me in. Apple, please bring front row back for 10.7, 10.8 and 10.9. This is a very important app. Plex *****. Itunes managed on a big screen with a remote ***** too. Need a media server interface for my Mac Mini Server. That's one of the reasons why I am still running 10.6.8 server on my Mac Mini. (besides the fact that OS X 10.7 + servers suck - period). Anyway, please bring Front Row back!

If Apple would bring back "Front Row", then it would be based on "AV Foundation" (64 bit) and not QuickTime (32 bit). But "AV Foundation" can only read very few movie fomats (like MPEG4, H264) - so even if Apple would bring it back, we guess the people would not be satisfied.


You can read more about the problem with the movie formats at https://discussions.apple.com/thread/5473287?answerId=23584275022#23584275022.

I have "upgraded" to Mavericks on my Macbook Pro. Front Row will still display its home page (after pressing ESC) but is now completely broken - even the arrow keys dont work to step through menu items.


I have kept Snow Leopard on an old iMac for media center purposes. It is useful that it talks to an Apple TV for music output. I now have a choice of Apple TV by itself (for video, music etc) or Front Row and EyeTV video on the iMac. I have played with Airparrot to try and send FR and EyeTV video/audio to the Apple TV but the lip-sync is hopeless.


A Mavericks FR with an Apple TV Airplay output option would have been a dream...

I have thousands of dollars worth of Apple hardware in my house because of iTunes. My $7,000 home theater is based on this platform. I am about to sell every single piece of Apple hardware in my house on eBay and switch to Windows 8 and Android (instead of the iPhone I bought for the remote app) because Apple abandoned the digital hub visioon of Steve Jobs and dumped Front-Row. I'm done!


I've posted this elsewhere on these forums but my posts keep getting deleted because Apple doesn't consider this feedback "constructive." Pay attention Apple, I was about to go out and buy a new Mac Mini for my new home theater because of this one app. You killed the app and you lost me as a customer. I'm dumping your stock, and I will never buy another Apple product again because you cannot be trusted.


Thousands of dollars down the drain - thanks!

The topic of this discussion is "I Want Front Row Back". Here a summary of how to Get Front Row Back as of December 2013:


Front Row works fine on Mavericks but you have to be somewhat technical to set it up. There are previous posts in this topic (and on the net) that describe how to install FR on Lion/ML, by copying over fi 00004000 les from a Snow Leopard installation; that same process works fine for Mavericks. The Apple Remote does not control FR natively the way it did in Snow Leopard, but shareware like Mira can be set up to get that working. FR will not play music in the iTunes library as installed, but there are tricks to get that working as well, by creating an iTunes Library.itl file using an older version of iTunes. There are posts that describe this in more detail.


Apple doesn't listen to complaints posted here, and won't bring FR back no matter how heavy-handed you sound. Ditching Apple products for Windows just because Apple discontinued FR is absurd. If you don't want to install FR on Mavericks by following instructions in this thread, there are other home-theater options for the Mac such as Plex or XBMC.


We will never know why Apple chose to discontinue FR but I have my opinions.. probably a business decision.. Apple may have felt it was too easy to access media files that were purchased outside the iTunes Store. Whatever the reason, only the most technical people are unhappy about losing FR. Most people aren't technical and don't know how to form opinions about software. It doesn't make business sense for Apple to care about our small demographic. One day, if Linux catches up and becomes more competetive with Apple, they might start caring more.

I can understand that you are displeased and I do not like some changes Apple made the last time, too. But I do not see any other operation system which is so user friendly and easy to use. Even if Apple is working hard on it to remove user friendly solutions like removing iTunes sync to iOS devices. Times are changing...


Trying to get Front Row back seems to be to technical in my opinion and I guess this will increase with every new Mac OS X and updates of iPhoto and iTunes.


There are alternatives to Front Row - Plex and XBMC were already mentioned. For me these solutions do not fit but many people like it.

There is a third alternative called MediaCentral, but it was not updated for some time.

And there is a fourth alternative called nessMediaCenter which is based on system technology like Front Row and which offers direct access to your media in the picture and movie folders. And it is the only media center I know which allows to start iTunes DRM media as well.


With this four alternatives in mind, it might be an idea to accept that Front Row is or will be dead and that we have to switch to another solution. As dr321 said: Apple will not listen and they will not bring Front Row back.

Honestly I need a platform with staying power. My company (a fortune 10 competitor of Apple's) manufactures a media server that's pretty compelling, but needs third party software to have a snazzy interface. I started building my Apple media network before I joined this company so I never previously thought switching was an option. Apple products command a premium on eBay so I think I'll eb able to recoup a chunk of my investment when I make the switch. Also the new Samsung TVs are pretty smart and I have a neighbor who got his to talk directly to his Windows 8 tablet, so that's promising.


Dumping FR was just plain stupid. One of Apple's most strategic business decisions was building a self-contained ecosystem of devices around iTunes that caused a "halo effect" whereby users bought more and more Apple hardware because it fit nicely with their iTunes systems. I'm a perfect example - one iPod caused me to drop thousands on Apple hardware over the years because I was so hooked on the digital hub vision of Steve Jobs. Killing FR is a much deeper issue than simply discontinuing a single piece of software - it's Apple giving up on the vision of a unified ecosystem of products that work in harmony with one another and unify your media experience on a single brand. They're basically conceeding that Apple isn't and never could be more than a simlpe computer company that dabbles in consumer products.


There are home automation companies headquartered a few miles from my home that excel at creating the unified infrastructure I need. Apple was simply my elegant way to get all the functionality they offer for a fraction of the price and without a bunch of fancy and proprietary hardware. All the hacks you guys men 00004000 tion in this thread sound great for now, but none of them sounds as if it will last more than a few years, and I'm not interested in re-creating my entire media center every 36 months because one of the platform providers I chose got lazy.


Right now Windows with a big-brand media server seems like option #1, a proprietary system developed by a local systems integrator is #2, and hacking a Mac Mini is #4...I'm still looking for my #3 option.


I will say this, and I actually have some evidence via engineers at Apple to back this up - none of this would be happening if Steve Jobs was still alive. Steve was as much a media nut as I am and he used Apple products in the same way (almost the same configuration) that I do to control his home media experience. Before he died he told the Apple TV guys they needed to do better and he was obsessed with a media center experience built natively into an HDTV screen. I guess the folks left over there at 1 Infinite Loop decided it wasn't worth spending the time to fulfill Steve's vision, which leaves me to find another company that will.

Between info on this thread an also simple input from this other one https://discussions.apple.com/thread/4598396?tstart=0 I suggest people don't give up on Front Row. I'm on Mountain Lion and it's working for me just great. I run iTunes server from my MyBook Live NAS, so things run pretty smooth. Maybe not 100%, but for me it's 95%+, and that's better than the alternatives I've used.

Don't give up. My family and I have been using Front Row for half the day today, watching movies, listening to music, and cruzing through this years Christmas photos (it's Christmas time after all). Oh, and I should mention, Theatre Trailers is working perfect too.

Best of luck and Merry Christmas to all!

I posted a 'Request', Plea for Apple to restore Front Row a year or so ago ago, and have been both delighted that so many feel like me, and staggered that Apple have completely ignored this demand. If though Bansche is correct (and I have absolutely no reason to believe that he isn't) that Apple is deleting his comments, then this brings another whole new dimension to the issue, and suggests such arrogance from Apple that is hard to understand from an organistaion like Apple, that purports to reflect in its products the needs of its customers, and centres around Music (re-affirmed by Tim Cook at both recent Presentations). Apple, if you are so intent on not bringing Front Row back as a part of youtr offering, why don't you provide the code to another software house to develop. I personally would be happy to pay even a modest amount for Front Row that will work with Mavericks. I still have not upgraded from Snow Leopard as I do not want to lose this interface.

I've spoken to two senior reps at Apple now and the best solution I've heard (which we're going to settle for until we fiind a new media center solution) is to buy a Mac Mini, partition the drive, and install Snow Leopard on the partition. They shipped me a free retail copy of Snow Leopard (with Front Row) which arrives tomorrow. Both tier-2 support reps I spoke to expressed the same frustration with the removal of Front Row and had no explanation for Apple's new 'non-strategy.' Steve Jobs must be rolling over in his grave right now and if he were alive, he'd be firing people!


As a Senior Manager of Digital Strategy Analytics for one of Apple's largest competitors, I feel quite comfortable criticizing this latest folly on behalf of Apple's product management team. If my company had a media platform to compete with Apple's, trust me I'd already be sending memos to our software people to fill this void and exploit Apple's myopia.

Just out of interest, what would functionality would you lose by buying an Apple TV, hooking that up to your home theatre system and streaming the content from iTunes on your Mac?

The ATV2 lacks an internal hard drive, is limited in it's port options, and the new interface is crap. Here's how that all impacts me:

  • The 2nd generation lacks the ability to browse my hosted family photos, which bugs my wife.
  • My biggest complaint with the interface of the 2nd generation Apple TV is the fact that MY content is hidden in a back corner. There are dozens of icons with movies I don't want, music album covers I don't want my kids to see, channels I'm not interested in, etc. Meanwhile all the content I own which I spent thousands of dollars on is burried under the "computers" icon.
  • The ATV2 lacks component video out, which is an important option if between your DVR, HDDVD, and Blue-Ray, you're out of HDMI ports. The component video on the ATV1 is exceptional.
  • I have no control over what is seen on the AppleTV 2 screen. Since the Apple TV 1 has an actual hard drive, if I don't want my kids to see LMFAO with their smiling mugs in front of some chicks CROTCH, I can simply unplug the device from the internet and let them watch the content stored on te local hard drive. With ATV2, my kids are always staring at whatever is a big seller on iTunes, including Lady Gaga and other garbage I don't want them to see.
  • A large chunk of the content on my ATV1 is content I legally digitized and did not purchase directly from iTunes, therefore this whole push towards "streaming" is annoying to me. I keep my content on a Terabyte RAID drive for safety. I don't like being at the mercy of Apple and my cable internet service provider. I paid for my content for a reason! If I can't own it, control it, and store it as I please, then what's the point of paying full price for it? If Apple wants me to only be able to access my content over the internet, then they should drop their prices! Nothing is more annoying than getting a "content not available" or "content cannot be viewed at this time" message (which we get often on netflix) while trying to view "streamed" content. If I'm going to pay the same price for a movie as if I bought the DVD, then I require the same level of access and control...period!


Frankly if Apple would get rid of every tab on the ATV2 except the "computers" tab, restore the hard drive, put the component video port back, and and restore the ability for me to browse my photos directly from the device, I think we'd be perfectly happy with the ATV2...that said, they're clearly going in another direction.


It's very simple really - ATV1 (and Front Row) put my content front-and-center. ATV2 puts whoever is paying Apple the most money front-and-center and sends my owned content (which I paid Apple good money for) to the back of the bus or leaves it standing on the curb. Apple also decreased the amount of control I have over my content and dumbed down the device to make it intentionally less usable for people who really get-it.

Hi John,


I posted the full text of the email from Apple deleting my post complaining about them killing Front Row in response to your last post here, but Apple deleted that post too. They said they deleted the first post because it contained feedback and they don't want feedback on these forums. They said they deleted the post where I posted their message deleting the feedback post because they don't allow "rants" on these forums. Funny, all I did was post the exact text of their email to me without any comment.


Oh well - learning the rules.

Bansche


Many thanks for your response, I wasn't expecting one and posted my reply out of anger at the cavalier attitude of Apple, who until now I confess I have always admired. I honestly feel that such arrogance can only tarnish a reputation that they (well at least in SJ's day) worked so hard to earn. I personally would have had no real objection to Apple commenting it was in the wrong Forum/area if they felt this to be the case, but to delete it shows in my view thst it 'hit a nerve'.


Included in this string are many comments that Apple will never bring back Front Row (and to those who comment that it doesn't really add to a simple iTunes interface suggests they haven't used it). I may be either naive and/or missing something very important, BUT why won't they. Is it technically too difficult even for Apple.


Incidentally, for Apple to suggest that they don't allow rants is ludicrous in the extreme. First, the whole point of these Forum is surely to provide feedback, good and bad. If so many have entered into the discussion on this subject, then clearly it is one on which many have taken issue, and perhaps Apple should use their time and effort listening to the users, rather than dismantling individual contributions.

Plus (why FR and not ATV)

The content accessed by ATV needs to be managed via iTunes on the Mac computer. This is very tedious and inflexible. With FR I use file aliases to place new videos in folder named new in my Movies folder. FR accessed this with a couple of clicks. With ATV I have to work my way through endless menus to find a particular video (provided I remember to add it to iTunes and manually set the genre when i save the MP4 file on the imac)


I am still running snow leopard on my media imac so that i can use FR. It is also the server for my ATV. I am playing around with Airplay to stream the FR video &amp; audio to the ATV but it is not perfect. Airplay makes it worth having an ATV as other mac and ios devices can stream video and audio.

I *wanted* Front Row back, I was one of the first posters here and I have kept watch on this thread for a long time.


Now, I'm glad it's gone. I have adopted the following:


* iFlicks to import movies and TV shows into iTunes. Most downloadable movies are already h.264 so this only takes a few seconds, plus it gets the artwork

* Remote app on iPhone to browse and control media. It's so much better than scrolling through hundreds of items on the big screen with a push button remote. With fullscreen support now, iTunes works perfectly


I experimented with this method while I was waiting for Apple to beef up their TV, or release a new version of front row, But before I knew it I didn't miss front row at all. Even though I had it sitting on Snow Leopard in my media room, I hadn't used it in months, so I just upgraded to Mavericks. I highly, highly recommend others try this way. iFlicks is a beautiful piece of software, as is Apple's Remote app.

I use the Apple remote app too for my Apple TV. It's great and it's the reason I made our entire family switch to iPhones from the more capable Samsung smart-phones we all used to use (I miss text voicemail). Nice apps, but that doesn't solve the question of the interface on my television screen. My wife for example REFUSES to use or even install the remote app on her phone...period! I can't get her to change her mind - she simply refuses to use her phone as a remote control and she won't let me buy her an iPad.


Nice options, but we still either need Front Row or a real Apple TV with a Front Row like interface.

Thank you for your hint. Sounds interesting...


Unfortunately I did not found a demo version (one major problem of the AppStore in my opinion) do give it a trial. And I searched all web sides to get further information, but did not found the answers.


So I would like to ask you for further informations: most of my movies are DVDs or EyeTV movies - can iFlicks handle this? And do I need another 2 TB harddisk for that?


iTunes might support fullscreen, but it is totally new for me that I can activate this mode with my remote. I will give it a try - but as far as I know, iTunes is far away from a media center solution.


And I have one more problem which might be uninteresting: if I use an application which re-organizes my folder structure by adding my movies to albums: how much work is it (and how can I simplify it) to keep my already organized structure? If it works like Plex or XBMC then I do not need another solution which is (in my opionion) useless.


Last but not least: if iFlicks is retrieving metadata for all movies, does it rename my movies based on these informations like Plex or XBMC do?


Sorry for being complicated and asking so many questions, but I just want a simple media center solution. And not a next trial with lots of frustrations.

If we are talking about Front Row and - may be - an alterative, I can not understand why anybody is mentioning Apple TV! May be you can help me?


Can I connect any TB harddisk to "remote play" my movies? Or can I start DVDs and EyeTV movies?


Someone mentioned iTunes to watch movies by iTunes via AirPlay on Apple TV: no EyeTV movies, no DVDs, no "direct" solution, not a remote control solution... and far away from something I could explain my wife. Or did I miss something - then please give me some help.


My wife just tried to get the idea of "... iTunes to watch movies ... via AirPlay on Apple TV..." and said: "find a simple solution, please".


And please give my an idea how can I connect Apple TV to my iMac - I bought it because we liked the idea of less hardware & cable.

Yes there's a full screen button on the Remote app. To switch to EyeTV I use Rowmote Pro, not perfect but it's pretty good. I don't even have a keyboard or mouse plugged into my mini, just iPhone.


I just keep EyeTV recordings in EyeTV and use the iPhone EyeTV app. As for DVD, I haven't used them in years so I can't help you there sorry.

My understanding is that AppleTV is mainly geared to download music and video from the internet. This works fine but most of us have many videos stored in MP4 format on a Mac (or Windows) computer or an external hard drive attached to that computer. ATV can access these videos (plus music and photos) provided that "home sharing" is activated on the computer, the computer and ATV are on the same (home) network and the video is available in iTunes on that computer. From the ATV menu the "Computer" icon is selected and any video or music that is linked to iTunes on that computer shows up in the menus.


It is similar for DVDs that are loaded on the computer - they appear on the ATV via the Computer icon. ATV will not play video directly from an external hard drive or DVD player. It also won't play digital TV broadcasts (I used to run an extension to FR that added an EyeTV item to the FR menu - allowing me to watch TV from FR). ATV is really only a slightly smart streaming device.


My main lament about the loss of FR is that, with the ATV, there are several extra steps needed to be able to play a recently recorded video. With FR I just put the file (or an alias) in the Mac computer Movie folder and it appeared in the FR menu. I will look at iFlicks for this.

I have a Mac Mini in the dash of my car and depend on Front Row. Because of the lack of Front Row in the newer OS's I am stuck with outdated software. Too bad Apple will never look back and help us out on this one. It was nice while it lasted. When it's time to upgrade my carputer I wonder what I'm going to switch to... I really wish I could say Apple xxx 😟

Then you should investigate the newly developed CarPlay from Apple.

Sorry, forgot to supply the link:


http://www.macworld.co.uk/feature/iphone/what-is-apples-carplay-in-car-ios-syste m-3505663/

I see two problems with this.

1. I'm not in bye market for a new car.

2. I like having my car independent from my phone. I have a 750GB SSD that holds way more than a phone will for the foreseeable future.

It is interesting that Front Row still appears prominently on the OSX Discussions page. Maybe there is hope yet?

User uploaded file

yes front row would be good to have back.

I want front row back. Bring it back.


<Edited by Host>

I do not think that there is hope - neither yet nor in the future. Apple's solution is AppleTV, I guess.


But can find an alternative in the Mac App Store: nessMediaCenter

The MAS version does not offer any internet content (like movie trailers), but at its support web page you can download other versions including a demo. And these versions are newer...

Another voice asking for Front Row back!

hello... sorry that i was not onvolved in FrontRow...

BUT its possible to access every data saved on microsd-cards saved long time ago when they are plugged inside your []mobile [multiple devices usage ability] mobile hotspot .these works of course if its not simlocked with every gsm or producersupported signal and sim card.


with devices like i used since some years ago your are then able to watch all your saved content on the mounted microsd card directly in html over the ip in your browser and with your personal ssid.

Because Apple removed Front Row, I now must buy a separate monitor / TV and an Apple TV, just to listen to my music from my couch.

What on earth made Apple deliberately downgrade their Macs? They gave us candy and took it away.


They must be able to understand that some people are just renting a room somewhere and do not want a TV just to use Front Row aka Apple TV.


To me this is the nr. 1 on the list of odd business decisions.


I hope they don't think it will make more people buy Apple TVs ???


None of the other solutions out there got it right, not by a long shot.
BRING FRONT ROW BACK !