Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Can't play music I already paid for on my Mac after canceling Apple Music subscription

Another group of customers had this problem and looked it up in 2023. But nothing's changed and the company never answered with a clear, helpful response. Just offered endless articles about Apple Music subscriptions.


WHY am I blocked from playing music I already paid for? It is no longer available on my Mac because I decided not to renew a subscription to Apple Music that I no longer want? I guess Apple just found a way to make money and be less helpful and friendly. But that's low. Charging people to listen to music they already PAID FOR and downloaded. That's really low. Has anyone found a good work around or another way to purchase music that one gets to keep and enjoy without a lot of extra fees and charges? Why would I pay just to "rent" it? Apple Music is not an option—too expensive for me.



[Re-Titled by Moderator]

Original Title: Music I already paid for is no longer available to play on my Mac? Just because I decided not to renew a subscription to Apple Music that I no longer wanted?



2 replies

maryspkr wrote:
WHY am I blocked from playing music I already paid for?


Are we talking about music purchased on CD, from the iTunes Store, etc.? Or "offline listening" copies of Apple Music subscription music? The latter may be "downloaded", but they are downloads tied to a subscription. The idea is to let you take advantage of your subscription when you are not connected to the Internet or when you do not want to use cellular data.


"Offline listening copies" are still rentals, and if you stop subscribing, those copies will stop working or be deleted.


(There have been cases in which these copies have apparently stuck around on iPhones after a subscription ends, fooling manual synchronization into thinking that purchased music was already loaded onto the iPhone … with the result that the iPhone is stuck with music that won't play. In those cases, doing a manual synchronization with no songs selected (to wipe all music off the phone), followed by another manual synchronization with desired songs, seems to clear the glitch and get everything back on track.)


Has anyone found a good work around or another way to purchase music that one gets to keep and enjoy without a lot of extra fees and charges? Why would I pay just to "rent" it? Apple Music is not an option—too expensive for me.


One alternative would be to purchase music on CD, and import it from CD. Another would be to purchase it from the iTunes Store.


Note that a single album of purchased music might cost you about the same as a month of Apple Music service (individual plan) would. The advantage of buying music is that it's yours forever, as long as you have equipment with which to play it. On the other hand, the Apple Music subscription offers access to tens of millions of songs, (millions of albums) which you can play in any order you want, ad-free. But only for as long as you pay.


Back of the envelope comparison: Ignoring sales tax and inflation, $6,000 might buy 500 CDs, 500 downloaded albums, or 500 months (41.7 years) of Apple Music service.