File Sharing ≠ File Synchronization. Standard macOS File Sharing operates by letting a remote computer read or copy files over a network (via SMB), rather than keeping a live, two-way synchronized database or background file watcher. When you set a folder to Read Only, changes made on Computer 1 (M4 iMac) do not automatically stream or overwrite open files on Computer 2 (M1 MacBook Pro) in real time.
Why It Fails
- Static File Transfer vs. Live Sync: macOS File Sharing is designed for access/retrieval, not cloud-style synchronization. If Computer 2 opens a Pages or Numbers file, it reads a static snapshot of that file.
- Read Only Restriction: Because the share is marked "Read Only," Computer 2 cannot write back updates, and Computer 1 has no mechanism to push live document state changes into active open documents on Computer 2.
- Format Complexity: Pages and Numbers files are actually bundled package directories. Modifying them live across a basic network share frequently leads to caching issues or permission/lock conflicts.
There are a few ways to accomplish your intent, here are two (easiest first).
Use Apple’s Built-in Collaboration (Recommended for Pages & Numbers)
Instead of a network shared folder, use real-time collaboration:
- Open the Pages or Numbers document on Computer 1 (M4 iMac).
- Click the Collaborate button in the toolbar (or choose File > Share > Collaborate with Others).
- Set the permission to Anyone with the link can edit or invite Joan's Apple Account directly with Can make changes permissions.
- Both computers will now sync edits in real time through iCloud Drive.
More info: Collaborate on documents in Keynote, Pages, and Numbers - Apple Support
Mount the Folder Live via Network (SMB)
Instead of copying the folder to Computer 2's hard drive, leave the master folder on Computer 1 (M4 iMac) and access it directly over your network from Computer 2 (M1 MacBook Pro).
On Computer 1 (M4 iMac - Host):
- Go to Apple menu > System Settings > General > Sharing.
- Click the Info (i) button next to File Sharing.
- Turn on File Sharing, then click Options and make sure "Share files and folders using SMB" is enabled.
- Under the Shared Folders list, click the + button, select your "Info for Joan" folder, and set the access permission to Read Only for Joan's user account.
- Note the network address of Computer 1 (displayed in the sharing menu or under System Settings > Network).
On Computer 2 (M1 MacBook Pro - Client):
- Delete the old static copy of the "Info for Joan" folder from Computer 2's local drive so there is no confusion.
- Open Finder and press Command + K (or go to the top menu bar and select Go > Connect to Server).
- Type smb:// followed by Computer 1's IP address or local hostname (for example, smb://192.168.1.50) and click Connect.
- Log in using Computer 1's username and password, then select the shared "Info for Joan" folder.
How it works now: Whenever you edit or save changes to the Pages or Numbers files on Computer 1, Computer 2 opens the live file directly across the network and displays the updated data immediately.
More info: Set up SMB file sharing on Mac - Apple Support