Matti Haveri wrote: … So maybe ColorComponents=1 is the most reliable method for this?
As you say, this doesn't really work for monochrome.
[1955. My father is the Master Sargent. I think that this was the entire Marine Corps contingent in Thailand]
This is clearly monochrome, but ColorComponents=3.
It looks like most monochrome pictures I have were scanned with the "color" setting. I found some scanned with the B&W setting, and those say ColorComponents=1.
Setting the B&W in Photos Edit keeps ColorComponents=3 in exports.