Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Photos App import fail from camera card *or* internal hard drive

Recently got a new M4 chip MBP and the Photos app has been completely unwilling to import photos from a camera card in any way that makes sense to me. Mac OS 15.4.1, Photos App 10.0 (751.0.104). The camera card is formatted by my Canon camera as ExFAT, and I've found here that Photos doesn’t like anything other than Apple formats, so I’ve stopped trying to import straight from the camera card and am copying to the internal drive, then importing to Photos.


Here are the two ways I'm trying, and what's happening with each of them:

  1. drag and drop from finder window to Photos: sometimes nothing happens at all, other times the number of photos I'm dragging appears in place of the mouse cursor, but then snaps back to the finder window when I release the mouse button, but sometimes the import window opens with some of the pictures and some previews that refuse to load
  2. command-shift-i from the Photos App (or menu File... Import), navigate to a folder containing the photos I want to import, select all, click Review for Import (or type Enter key): if there are only 30-40 photos, this seems to work, BUT if there are more photos, some of them either don't show up in the import window at all, or show up as blank and a preview never loads. But the most annoying thing it does is just plain not import some of them.


Like I said, the most annoying part is when it imports some of the files, but not all of them.

9 replies

Photos is perfectly happy importing from ExFat cards, in fact pretty much every camera card if formatted ExFat. The problem arises if the Photos Library in on an inappropriately formatted location. So: first question: where is your library stored?

OTOH, the problem might be that I have to close the app and reopen it to see accurate import information. Which is weird, but that's what happened. The files I thought hadn't even showed up on the import screen are, in fact, in the library now. This is the kind of behavior I expect from open source software running on a Linux rig I built, not from Apple software on a new Mac.

What size is the disk on that Mac and how much free space on it?

Internal hard drive of the MBP, as formatted when I purchased it.


The library database sure is acting like it's corrupted. Is there a way to rebuild it, or should I just do that manually by starting a new one?

kingtorcodes wrote: … This is the kind of behavior I expect from open source software running on a Linux rig I built, not from Apple software on a new Mac.

Something else was going on-- most likely you weren't looking in the right place-- a problem that plagues me independently of the platform I'm working on. But Photos Import has always worked as it should, for me.

Alas.... that's not all that's happening. I just noticed it hasn't imported all of the pictures I intended to import. And I ran this quick little test on a new library, so apparently the problem is not the database: https://youtu.be/9EtcEoQIpKE


There are two things that make no sense to me shown in that video:

1. There are 320 photos in the folder I'm importing, not only 84

2. None of the 84 that showed up in the import window were actually imported

Then there's this bizarre [um, I suspect feature but seems more like a] bug in the Finder and in any Import or Open window of any app I've used on this computer that when you want to select a lot of files, when you scroll down, it takes a moment for the file names to turn from grey to black. https://youtu.be/xFY1JOTFhzQ