They sure look the same-- same resolution, same filename, same time. The third one is highly compressed, so the picture will look fuzzier when you zoom in. Throw it away!
If I were you, I'd not worry about it for awhile. A new macOS, Sequoia, will release in September, and upgrading should cause re-scans of the Photos Library. It may all fix itself then.
A big advantage in merging duplicates detected by Photos is that when you merge duplicates, their attributes are combined, and the result goes in every album either picture was in. I have many pictures imported from old backups that duplicate some pictures, but they are in different albums. Merging will reduce that to one picture that's listed in all the original albums. This is very cool!