Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Using Photos with all images stored externally

Hello, I have been trying to find a way to store my photos, but also access and find what I need, without storing them on my laptop. I have an Android phone and a MacBook Air and all my photos are automatically uploaded to Dropbox. I followed the instructions here:


Move your Photos library to save space on your Mac – Apple Support (UK)


I moved all my photos to a Lacie drive and then I moved my Photos library there too. But now when I try to import my images to Photos they disappear.


It may be that I forgot to check my drive's format, which I now noticed is ExFAT. Is this the reason for my problem? And if so, is there any way to remedy this situation? I tried to convert it to APFS, but the option in the menu is greyed out.


Thank you.


7 replies

marcynewman wrote:

ExFAT. Is this the reason for my problem? And if so, is there any way to remedy this situation? I tried to convert it to APFS, but the option in the menu is greyed out.

Only APFS and MacOS Extended are supported and other formats might corrupt the library.


So copy all data from the disk elsewhere, and with Disk Utility > View > Show All Devices and select the topmost device, and erase as APFS (choose GUID Partition Map first, then change the format to APFS, if it is not shown).


Then copy the data back. And remember to backup also the external disk to another external disk!

marcynewman wrote:

APFS is greyed out and these are the only options available to me. What do I do?

You must first select partition scheme GUID, then you can select APFS. I wish Apple makes this more obvious.

marcynewman wrote: ... I moved all my photos to a Lacie drive and then I moved my Photos library there too.

This confuses me a bit. Normally "all my photos" would be inside the Photos Library package. In your Photos>Settings>General,

do you have "Copy Items to the Photos Library" checked? This is the default setting. Removing the check makes this a Referenced Library, a situation that we've seen cause lots of problems.


You don't mention iCloud-- do you use iCloud Photos?


Your biggest problem is certainly the ExFat format-- don't try to use the Library on that format-- it could lead to corruptions.


The ExFAT format will not support a Photos library's complex ecosystem. As Richard pointed out if you try to open the library on the ExFAT drive it will corrupt the library.


If you want to keep your library on an external drive IT MUST BE FORMATTED either APFS for SSDs or OS X Extended (journaled) or HDDs.


Depending on the size of your library this portable SSD, 250GB, 500GB, 1TB, 2TB OWC Envoy Pro mini is an excellent choice to carry along with a laptop.



Do not, I repeat do not mess with ExFAT. It's a receipt for disaster with a Photos library.


marcynewman wrote: APFS is greyed out and these are the only options available to me. What do I do?
Matti Haveri wrote: You must first select partition scheme GUID, then you can select APFS. I wish Apple makes this more obvious.

Wow-- I completely forgot about that! I remember having to figure it out-- not at all obvious!

I don't use iCloud at all. And I haven't used Photos on my Mac in many, many years. I'm trying to go back to Photos, but don't have room on my Mac for them, which is why I want to keep everything stored on an external hard drive. I'm going to try to deal with the ExFAT formatting and see if that helps. Thank you for your feedback.

Hello helpful people - I bought a brand new drive to format correctly but APFS is greyed out and these are the only options available to me. What do I do?