Thanks for the advice!
I was on the phone with Apple support about some other things today and brought this item up as well. They had a solution:
settings/touch ID & Passwords, then uncheck "use Touch ID to autofill passwords".
Touch ID for autofill gives you the option to press the Touch ID button or enter the Mac password. Sorry I didn't clarify this in the OP. Touch ID is new to me.
My usecase is, 90% of the time I use my MacBook connects to an external monitor, KB etc. and the laptop is not within reach to easily press the touch ID button like I think they were expecting people would do rather than enter the Mac password.