Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Spotlight not indexing external drive - old problem

After trying to find an answer to Spotlight on my MBP not indexing an external drive it would seem from this community that this problem is not a new one.

I'm running MacOS Ventura with a APFS formatted LaCie external drive and have gone through all the permutations of changing permissions of the drive. I have forced the Mac to start the indexing procedure by adding and removing a drive from the privacy pane of Spotlight in Settings but on completion it doesn't remember what it has just taken ages to do.

I haven't bothered with terminal commands as it would seem from others who have tried it that it doesn't solve the problem either.

Reading elsewhere on the Apple Community it may be a file with corrupt metadata causing the Spotlight problem (not too convinced of this). It may however be worth turning off individual search locations to try to home in where the problem may lie if corrupt metadata can indeed cause Spotlight to fail its indexing.

I have in fact three drives (although one is reserved for Time Machine backups and will not be included in Spotlight) and each fails so it must be a wider problem than a file with corrupt metadata. If someone knows more on this subject please step forward but please do not repeat a procedure I have already tried.

3 replies

Further follow up...

looks like the Mac writes the hidden .Spotlight-V100 file to the external disk, it just doesn't return data to Spotlight. Privileges are fine so that shouldn't be the problem.

Just wanted to add that when the external drive is double clicked the search area at top right of the window will find any file I require. It just seems Spotlight from the MBP will not penetrate further than its own hard drive.

After further research it would seem Spotlight will not retain the index of an APFS formatted drive.