Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

apple time machine keeps destroying my external hard drives

There is obviously a problem with time machined the APFS formatting for external hard drives. why hasn't apple addressed this problem? Iv'e now lost 3 externals due to time machine destruction of drives to the point that there no longer usable and can't be reformatted.

21 replies

Wow! Before going to such extremes, try running Disk Utility First Aid while booted in Recovery.


I saw very similar errors to the above, which did seem related to Time Machine having run, while running Big Sur 11.7.


Here's the scenario:

"Time Machine" is a single APFS volume on an external disk, with another identical single-volume APFS disk in the same enclosure; both sharing a TB2 cable to the MBP.  


TM had been set to run overnight every 4 days.  Perhaps because i don't routinely use the other drive, it wasn't until several days later I'd notice the non-TM drive was not mounted.  


Running Disk Utility from normal boot, the non-TM drive had an odd, vaguely-generic name.  (Once it was shown as Time Machine!)  DU First Aid gave similar errors as you showed above, and that one drive would not mount on re-boot.  "Time Machine" drive never had a problem.


Intending to re-format, I first ran Disk Util from Recovery and noticed it correctly reported the disk name, etc.  I then ran First Aid on the drive at all levels, which ran without error. After re-booting, that second drive also mounted correctly with it's normal name.


This happened maybe 5 times.  Since I knew the work-around, I wasn't too concerned.  I chalk it up to a software problem in the OS; rather do the work-around than run Apple's gauntlet.  I just installed Monterey, haven’t seen it… yet.


It is not attributable to a drive problem. DriveDX SMART reports no errors, other than the bogus shock events.


=== DRIVE ERROR LOG ===

error log is empty


=== DRIVE SELF-TEST LOG ===


#   | LIFETIME (H)   | TEST TYPE         | PROGRESS | STATUS                          | LBA of 1st error


1          4771        Extended offline       10%     Aborted by host                      -     

2          2368        Short offline         100%     Completed without error         -     


=== DEVICE STATISTICS ===


[0x01] General Statistics (revision 2)

  0x08 Lifetime Power-on Resets                  : 2,839 

  0x10 Power-on Hours                            : 5,079 hours

  0x18 Logical Sectors Written                   : 16,639,655,832 (8.5 TB)

  0x20 Number of Write Commands                  : 161,390,899 

  0x28 Logical Sectors Read                      : 7,548,700,803 (3.9 TB)

  0x30 Number of Read Commands                   : 276,177,607 


[0x02] Free Fall Statistics (revision 1)

  0x10 Overlimit Shock Events                    : 3  (bogus; it once incremented as I watched!!)


[0x03] Rotating Media Statistics (revision 1)

  0x08 Spindle Motor Power-on Hours              : 4,983 hours

  0x10 Head Flying Hours                         : 3,159 hours

  0x18 Head Loaded Events                        : 5,963 

  0x20 Reallocated Logical Sector Count          : 0 (0 B)

  0x28 Read Recovery Attempts                    : 0 

  0x30 Mechanical Start Failure Count            : 0 


[0x04] General Errors Statistics (revision 1)

  0x08 Number of Reported Uncorrectable Errors   : 0 

  0x10 Resets Between Cmd Accept. and Compl.     : 1 


[0x05] Temperature Statistics (revision 1)


  0x08 Current Temperature                       : 32 °C

  0x10 Average Short Term Temperature            : 33 °C

  0x18 Average Long Term Temperature             : 33 °C

  0x20 Highest Temperature                       : 45 °C

  0x28 Lowest Temperature                        : 16 °C

  0x30 Highest Avg. Short Term Temperature       : 41 °C

  0x38 Lowest Avg. Short Term Temperature        : 27 °C

  0x40 Highest Avg. Long Term Temperature        : 39 °C

  0x48 Lowest Avg. Long Term Temperature         : 30 °C

  0x50 Time in Over-Temperature                  : 0 minutes

  0x58 Specified Max Operating Temperature       : 55 °C

  0x60 Time in Under-Temperature                 : 0 minutes

0x68 Specified Min Operating Temperature       : 5 °C


[0x06] Transport Statistics (revision 1)

  0x08 Number of Hardware Resets                 : 10,754 

  0x18 Number of Interface CRC Errors            : 0 

________________________


There are no pervasive reports of drive issues that can be traced back to use with Time machine that have been posted here.


Drives have a limited lifespan, and rotating magnetic drives in particular are exceeding complex devices that are subject to arbitrary and captious errors for no particular reason. The most common end-of-life failure mechanism is when a drive accumulates a few errors, then a few more, then it snowballs into dozens, then hundreds, then unusable.


After erasing a drive that had errors, if it continues to cause problems, it is likely not good enough to hold you precious data any longer, and should be retired.


Time Machine does not use drives in an especially arduous way. But drives do get old and die, some long before their expected lifespan. Occasionally, the drive maker will replace a drive under warranty if it failed too soon.

You should have selected GUID partition Map.


if you did not, and selected the outdated Master Boot Record instead, Time machine may try to convert the drive to Apple File System (APFS) and that could fail, or the backup could later fail.


You may end up where you were before, with the disk unusable.

use the little View menu to choose Show all devices.


The select the PHYSICAL drive by its immutable manufacturer suppled name, and ERASE everything.



If that is not successful, immediately ask again (without leaving Disk Utility).


if it fails after that, then the drive itself may have failed.


Inspect the label on the drive. if the manufacturer's warranty still applies, return it to them for exchange.

I had to use my wife's PC to erase the disk first. Only then would disk utilities allow me to erase and reformat my external. It's now preparing time machine's 1st backup (again). We'll see what happens after a couple of weeks (again)

please try my suggestion above.


the important step is selecting the ENTIRE physical device (Not just the Volume) and attempting to ERASE.


If that works or does not work, please let readers know.

thanks for your comments Paul, I haven't had this problem with any other OS but Monterey. The external Ssd in the only drive in the case. all I can do at this point its wait. It usually takes a couple of weeks before it acts up again. The only way I could access the drive again was by reformatting it on my wife's PC in EXFAT. Only then mac disk utilities allowed eraser and reformat.

Apple File system (APFS) is the latest File system, first widely used in 10.13 High Sierra. Seeing Time machine convert the drive from MacOS Extended to APFS is expected behavior.


What you need to have done to support that is to have used GUID partition Map (first widely used in MacOS 10.4 Leopard) when creating the Volume in the fist place, so that it does not make mistakes.

what message do you get when you click ERASE.

Hello babowa. The 1st drive was a seagate 2TB external hd formatted in Mac OS Extended (journaled). When selecting the disk for Time machine backup it automatically reformatted the disk to APSF and within 2weeks of time machine us the disk was corrupted and unrepairable.the 2nd was a Kensington 2TB ssd external (thunderbolt). Original format was again Mac OS Extended (journaled) once setup by time machine it changed format again to APSF and after 3 weeks disk corrupted and unrepairable. 2 brand new disked destroyed, and I need answers.

Thanks for the response, but both disk were brand new when I started to use them as Time machine backups. The 1st was a seagate 2Tb external and the 2nd was a Kensington external thunderbolt 2TB ssd. I never had a problem with Time machine backups on my older MacBook pro. Its only on this new M1 max pro (OS Monterey) that it's killing my external drives to the point where they're unrepairable.

<< "unrepairable" >>


what do you mean by that, exactly?

So you say that you cannot erase those disks?

That is correct! See uploaded screen shots.

disk utilities can't repair or erase them

I contacted apple support in August of last year with no resolution.

Disk utilities can't even access the disk, see screen shot. I tried fixing, reformatting and erasing.

Thats the problem. No matter what I select Time machine converts the drive to APFS, and yes thats exactly what TM did.

When TM reformats drive to APFS it automatically selects GUID Partition Map. see screenshot.

GREAT!


on of the screenshots you showed before, where you said the drive could not be repaired, said the drive was Master Boot Record (MBR).