Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

iPod Classic won't sync with Ventura 13.0.1

Hi there, since I updated my MacBook Air to Ventura 13.0.1, my iPod Classic will no longer sync my library with Apple Music.


I connect it, then when I click on it in Apple Music, it tells me "This iPod is open in another window" ... I then try again and can see the songs on my iPod, but trying to sync it just gives me a swirling icon that never progresses, even if I leave it for an hour.


When I eventually yank my iPod (because it won't eject when this happens either), my files on the iPod are unchanged.


I've tried resetting the iPod and the MacBook many times, but nothing is working. I have also tried different ports on the MacBook. Any suggestions on how I can fit this? I've got music from weeks ago that I haven't been able to add and listen to yet!

29 replies

Ok I solved it. Sort of dumb in the end. The trick is to have Apple Music completely closed, go into finder and open the iPod there, and then you can sync it from there. So thank goodness, my iPod still works! haha. Thanks again for all the help tt2!

Restart the Mac, making sure the option to reopen windows is not selected.


Take a look at Corrupt iPod Classic - Apple Community. There is just a possibility that a background process on the Mac is trying to inspect the classic's hard drive. If your stats indicate there are pending sectors to clear that would also suggest there are outstanding file system repairs to be performed.


tt2


Update: I've been in touch with Apple Support and they have told me that the iPod Classic is incompatible with Ventura :(


The only option is to downgrade to Monterey

An iPod classic is a USB drive, with some additional hardware and firmware. You might try leaving the MacBook on charge overnight with any power saving options turned off and the iPod connected. Or you could try explicitly running Disk First Aid on it.


tt2

Hello TT2. I'm VERY grateful to you for posting the above. The inability to add the tracks I'd imported to iTunes onto my iPod after the upgrade to Ventura was leading me to contemplate desperate measures (no Time Machine back up of Monterey... ). I was on the verge of giving up but then found, inspired by the above, that if I loaded it in Finder first, yes, it then accessed the iPod in Music and I could add. Next issue was how to ensure artwork was loaded, how to delete and replace if it wasn't, and yes, it's all doable via Music.


It's funny because when they first ditched iTunes in favour of Music, I hated it in comparison and so installed old iTunes software. Now I'm just grateful that I can still keep my twin iPod 160gb Classics (one with 256gb upgrade) going a little while longer until they die!


I never thought several years ago when it was all about iTunes and I could spend hours curating my iPod (I had one 160gb only and couldn't get more than 20k tracks on it, so was constantly deleting and refining) that I would look back at that as a golden age of portable music usage. I always thought there'd be some super high def, affordable new device with lossless quality sound and a huge memory... It's a niche market of over-priced ugly devices that cost a fortune, no thanks. One day I know I'll have to give up and resort to only using the smart phone like everyone else, but I am putting that day off as long as I can.


Once again, very grateful indeed for the help above in allowing me to do that. Long live the iPod Classic, a beautiful device.

Fuse install the solution?

Perhaps there is a workaround; neither my macbook 2010 and Macbook 2017 could recognize the iPod classic 20GB when connected thru usb-2, usb-3 and usb-c cables. The MBP's muttered when connected to the iPod and nothing emerged, though the iPod registered a connection and suggested a wipe and restore. Then I got the idea to install Fuse through homebrew; so I entered brew install fuse... in the terminal. Also installed macfuse and restarted the MBP 2017. To be on the safe side. After that my MacBook Pro simply recognized the iPod and Apple Music and iTunes registered the music in the iPod, with all different kind of connectors. I was happy as I used the iPod for some interviews long time ago and for archiving my digitized LP collection (started in 1975). Yes, I was happy to be able to back up my files from my iPod classic.

Try rebooting the machine with the Pod connected in case the behaviour is any different. Or try with the iPod in disk mode. Did you check out my earlier Corrupt iPod Classic - Apple Community link? It would be good to know if there are any pending sectors.


tt2

iPods will no longer work with Monterey either. Get a flash drive with lots of space then load it with Big Sur or earlier. Use the flash drive just for managing ipods.

Good there are no pendings. I'm afraid I don't have any other thoughts on this open in another window issue, except that I don't think you are alone. I've seen a few similar threads. You could try Official Apple Support in case it is something they can recognize and have a fix for.


tt2


Did you miss the bit where three different users in this thread mentioned being able to sync iPod classic with Finder in Ventura? You should be able to do it too. If you really want to go back, and have a suitable backup, see Restore your Mac from a backup - Apple Support.


tt2

OK, what exactly happens when you try to sync content to your iPod with Finder? For me the device shows up twice, once with its proper name, and once in caps with no more than 11 characters. The first one is the one that lets me manage content.



I can only sync locally stored files that haven't come from the Apple Music service, but it does work.


tt2

Ventura back to Monterey, so that I can load my Ipod Mini. I wouldn't have upgraded to Ventura had I known my Ipod wouldn't load.

Make sure all of your tracks have embedded artwork. If the files show with artwork in Finder before you copy them to the iPod then they should show with art on the device.


tt2

I'd tried all those already unfortunately without luck. But I think you're right that there is some background process happening ... when I first connected it after updating it asked me if I trusted this new USB device, which seemed strange. And it almost seems to be loading as a USB drive and some process is happening with that, which is preventing the syncing from happening.

Tried that and it didn't make a difference ... and I've done diagnostic mode, it says zero Reallocs or Pending sectors. I did manage to do a Disk Utility check somehow (but it still wouldn't sync) and it came back with no problems. And I can move files on and off it in finder, too, which is what I mean when I say it's working as a usb.


It also works fine for playing music ...


Maybe I should just reformat it, if I can manage to do that ...

I do wish they wouldn't make things up. I've just synced around 100 songs to one of my old classics using Ventura. I still don't know why you're getting that open in another window warning, I don't get it here, and haven't yet run into a workaround for it, but Ventura is perfectly capable of syncing to older devices that Apple may no longer choose to actively support.


tt2

Hey 👋 Turingtest2! 

Could you please help me then, since you seem to know what you're doing, plus you've had luck with something I cannot figure out… 

I can play all the songs in my iPod classic using the iPod (quality is something terrible but it might be my headphones) and all the 2,500 plus songs are using less than 50Gb of space, is that normal? Seems low. 

And even though I can play the songs on it, when I connect it to my MacBook and it pops up like a hard drive, and I open it, there are no songs anywhere in any folder!?

If I search for a song in finder it doesn’t come up either!!

But now with iTunes, I CAN SEE THAT THE SONGS ARE ON THE IPOD IN ITUNES!?

I used….something called APERTURE on Github. I 🤔 think….. to download iTunes on my “2020 13” MacBook Pro Running Ventura” but still, I’m getting nowhere. I was at 1 point asked, in music if “I was sure I wanted to sync my iPod, BC if I Did I would lose songs on my iPod”?! Something to that effect, and I should say it’s the “Semi-Brickish IPod classic” the click wheel I think 5th version?  Not the original monster but the lesser monster, probably 1 of the last models made from idk 15 yrs ago maybe? 

And since, I’ve never done what I kept wanting to and saying I should have updated to an iPod touch or Whatever is the newest version of an iPod? Why I’m sure you might be thinking. Because I have well over 2,000 songs on there, a lot of Doubles, triples, and Quattro’s even! But not just songs purchased from iTunes.  Because at some point at the beginning of the Digital music phenomenon, I put EVERY CD I HAD ONTO IT. And might have a song or 2 Downloaded from Napster?

But even Songs that are on my current computer from CDs I download, the MacBook Pro, even they don’t show up on my iPhone in Music?! I DONT KNOW Why!? 

SMH, I’m very sorry I’m all over the place.

But the Point is, I Just DESPERATELY want to compile ALL MY MUSIC INTO 1 PLACE like an external SSD DRIVE & THEN HOPEFULLY I COULD USE it ON MY IPHONE.

Is THAT EVEN POSSIBLE?!🫣😫

Maybe that's what I should have said first?!

 I will attach screenshots of the things I mentioned, is it possible to email you? Is that allowed? Or can you can email me? If you can help me with this, I would be very grateful!! I would even pay you if you’d like, id do anything to get this resolved, I’ve been trying for months!

I Knew what I was doing more on windows because I grew up on that, but ever since I switched to Apple thinking everything else I have is apple so….. but no I’m Lost! 

Again, terribly sorry for rambling on🙄🫣!!  You’re a Saint 🙏🏼 if you Read this through! So TY!

You're welcome. 🙂


I always thought there'd be some super high def, affordable new device with lossless quality sound and a huge memory...


Can't help with the affordable bit, but Apple Music on an iPhone now does lossless, some with Dolby Atmos, from an enormous collection. You can stream anything you don't have room for so storage is only an issue if you need to be offline, or don't want to pay for all you can eat data (like me).


tt2

Yep, that's where it's at and makes sense that streaming has won out over a static collection. I'm locked in the mindset of buying the CD and ripping to a device but when the iPods die or the batteries just can't do it any more, I imagine I'll do the same. And if you can get lossless without the price being through the roof, so be it. I'll still but the CDs! I was interested in Tidal for their high quality but not Alexa compatible in UK and that's essential for me. I'm currently streaming from Amazon on a Samsung having left Spotify with Neil Young, but that can all change...

A few weeks on and the above workaround from @turingtest2 is tolerable, you just have to make sure that all the data is how you will want it to be permanently before you add tracks to the iPod, but there is one irritating element: it seems to be hit or miss as to whether the artwork appears. Sure, it looks fine in Music before you add, but then it may or may not appear on the iPod itself. I've had to repeat the process 2 or 3 times with a couple of albums to get the artwork on there, which is tedious because you have to manually find each track individually and delete (unless you've played them all in which case you can find them chronologically under 'last accessed'.


Huge thanks and kudos to anyone who knows a failsafe way of knowing the artwork will appear correctly on the iPod before you import it!

Thanks for the help again but I'm afraid that doesn't solve it, just double-checked with a recent addition to the iPod, a 2 CD set. Artwork appears under Music in Finder but not on the iPod. I always delete any automatically downloaded/embedded artwork that appears when I import the CD because experience has shown it pretty well never shows on the iPod, but I really can't see what dictates appearance or non-appearance when I add it manually.

Square .jpg images of 600px or 800px should work well. Back in the day artwork on the device was optional, and turning the option to include it off and on again would often fix issues, however that option is no longer available. Restore and reload the device is now the only way to reset if art isn't loading properly on the iPod.


tt2

Going into Disk First Aid, I get this error:



Then when I try to unmount it tells me: Failed to unmount “JAMES' IPOD” because it is currently in use by “SystemUIServer”.

It's quite impressive there's no hardrive problems considering I've had it since 2008 and use it almost daily! Thanks for all your help, I'll give Apple Support a go :)

iPod Classic 160GB (A1238) is operating normally in macOS Ventura 13.1, showing in Music.app/Finder.

Downgrade from what to what? In general to downgrade macOS you would need a full pre-upgrade backup of your machine that you can restore.


tt2

Thank you. I didn’t miss it. I tried it and it didn’t work for me.