Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Monterey Login Screen is Stuck on Chroma Red (different than the Pink Monterey Valley screen!)

There seem to be two divergent problems emerging from the Login Screen with Monterey Pink Valley.


This came up in the thread below and it seems to be different from the OP, "Can I change login screen with OS Monterey" and similar threads where I first saw that I wasn't the only person with the problem.


On our shared case, the system's login screen has been locked into the "Chroma Red" screen as shown below.


Unlike other similar requests for assistance, this login background cannot be changed back to the [comparatively more soothing] Monterey Pink Valley or when following the guidance on the thread to a customizable background.


This includes the following remedies.


For personalization using your own image, this approach isn't working.


  1. System Preferences > Users & Groups.
  2. Open lock to make changes.
  3. Right click on user in left column > Advanced Options.
  4. Copy UUID value.
  5. Go to /Library/Caches/Desktop Pictures.
  6. If it doesn't exist create Desktop Pictures folder.
  7. Inside Desktop Pictures create folder with UUID value as name.
  8. If it exists, just open folder and put the picture you want in it and name it as "lockscreen.png".  It has to be a .png picture.
  9. Then close folder and right-click on folder > Get Info.
  10. Open lock to make changes.
  11. Grant permission to Read & Write to user, admin, everyone.
  12. Close lock
  13. Open System Preferences >FileVault and disable it.
  14. (The new startup screen will work.
  15. Restart computer
  16. If you enable the File Vault again, the startup screen won’t work anymore.


For an alternative approach, this approach below also is not working.


  1. Under "Security and Privacy," Turn of File Vault
  2. Under "Users & Groups"
    1. Guest User is disabled
    2. "Display login in the users & groups preference pane you have a window as List of users" checked, and not checked "name and password".


Hopefully separating the two problems out will facilitate helping both problems.


Cheers,

Bill



37 replies

I've been looking into this quite a bit. Turns out, this is not a bug. I'm not sure if it's all M1 Macs or just the new M1 MBPs, but I can at least now confirm that all M1 MBPs show Chroma Red/Chrome Blue by design.


A LOT has changed in macOS since the Intel Catalina/Pre-Catalina days and M1/Monterey. I did not realize that the macOS I knew is long gone. I learned quite a bit by reading through the articles here: https://eclecticlight.co/m1-macs/ The author, Howard Oakley, has done an absolutely incredible job documenting the changes that have been made to macOS in the last 4-5 years.


These wallpapers are either part of the SSV (Sealed Snapshot Volume) or part of the new iBoot on M1 Macs—I'm not sure which. In any event they are (practically speaking) unchangeable. They are part of the OS that is signed and distributed by Apple and can be (and likely are) model number specific. I say that because that's how it's been on iOS for a while, it's just less noticeable—iOS default wallpapers are different based on model.


The reason behind locking down this wallpaper is security. All parts of the system that load before login are designed to be signed and bit-for-bit unmodified by Apple. How/why Apple allows the user profile icons to load I'm not sure. If you notice, they are extremely low resolution before you login. If I had to guess what Apple is doing here is saying that user profile photos are okay to load because they are heavily compressed, so they may feel there isn't a practical way to include a malicious payload into a user profile picture that is only a few kilobytes, so it is not deemed a security risk. A high resolution desktop wallpaper, on the other hand, could be a security risk so it is not allowed; and the alliterative—compressing a desktop wallpaper to a few kilobytes would be quite ugly. How and why they decided to make it Chroma Red/Chrome Blue I have no idea, but it is what it is.


One final note: it might be technically possible to change this, but to do so you would have to turn off almost all of the security features and really dig around to find out where this screen is. You'd also have to enable Permissive Security mode and turn off SIP. The wallpaper would also be reset with any future macOS update. It may cause all sorts of other unintended problems, since system integrity will no longer be bit-for-bit verified.

It is with great delight to report that my screen went back to pink montery bathymetric nirvana after my upgrade to MacOS 12.2.


May everyone's 12.2 upgrades be as satisfying! If someone else can verify that this has fixed their problem, please report so we can clear this item as "solved!"


I am never touching the "change background" settings again. Ever.


Bill

Well said Ralph!


There can be different software running the login screens for Intel-based Macs and Macs with Apple silicon, if FileVault is enabled. On Intel-based Macs (AFAIK), they boot to a special login screen stored in the Preboot volume (/System/Volumes/Preboot). In contrast, Macs with Apple silicon start up from the SSV and show the real login screen, but because the Data volume is locked, they use a default background and rely on info stored in the Preboot volume (user icons, names, SecureTokens, etc.) to let the user unlock their Mac for the first time.


I'm not sure if a smaller filesize can help reduce the chance of malware infecting a file. I'd rather blame the command "diskutil apfs updatepreboot /" for not providing higher-resolution pictures. Maybe the Intel pre-boot screen can only handle a lower resolution?


It is possible to disable the SSV protections (by running "csrutil authenticated-root disabled") from macOS Recovery. This isn't a good idea (since it will put you in Permissive Security on Apple silicon Macs), but if you choose to do that, the following applies:


  • When you disable SSV integrity, FileVault must be disabled. You can enable it again after the security changes have been applied.


  • The system always starts up from an immutable snapshot. The only change now is that you can create your own custom system snapshots, using apfs_systemsnapshot. Also, each file is no longer verified by Apple (since you broke the seal).


  • In order to create a custom snapshot, you would have to mount the live System volume (unmounted by default), make it read-write, and then perform any desired changes. (This may require disabling System Integrity Protection completely on Intel-based Macs, or at least the filesystem protections, unless you're fine with making your desired changes using Terminal in macOS Recovery.) Once that's done, a new system snapshot would have to be created in order to lock in the changes.


  • On an Intel-based Mac, if you reset NVRAM, that will automatically re-enable SSV integrity, and you'll likely be stuck in a boot loop if you're using a custom snapshot. To fix this, start up from macOS Recovery and either disable SSV integrity again, or reinstall macOS (which will preserve your data, but remove any system volume customizations.)


  • When the next macOS update is available, it will be much larger than normal, and it will completely rewrite the entire system volume. All of your custom snapshots will be lost, and you'll go back to the default login window wallpaper.


  • In macOS Big Sur, if you start up from a custom system snapshot, the sealed snapshot will be automatically deleted. Your only remedy of going back to the SSV is to reinstall macOS, or wait for the next update (which will do the same thing).


  • In macOS Monterey (and hopefully future), if you start up from a custom system snapshot, the sealed snapshot will be preserved. If you choose to revert back to the SSV though (by going to Full or Reduced Security, or running "csrutil authenticated-root enable"), your custom snapshot will be deleted.


The default desktop picture files are located in /System/Library/Desktop Pictures.

I’ve called Support at Apple and lodged an official complaint about this. The support person said they can see this discussion and other discussions about the problem. He said there is currently no way for a user to change the login screen. If we all write to Apple and lodge a complaint it could be fixed in a future update.

I also did this the other day and I got the same guidance from the upper level Apple tech. We tried installing a new Monterey over the existing one. Making a new temp account and a few other things and the Chroma problem persisted.


Her guidance was to document what happened and referencing this thread will suffice. Mention the Chroma Red/Blue (OK the SpaceGrey vs Silver difference would be funny if it were happening to someone else!) problem specifically. If you were on Tech Support you can also cite the trouble ticket.


https://www.apple.com/feedback


If enough of us report it there may be a critical mass. The big thing is if one of them can emulate it and it does seem that we are in a minority of unintentionally innovative users.


We will have to be stoic and suffer through our login screens for now :-(

I've had this same issue since I set up my new M1 MacBook Pro. I assumed the Chroma Red wallpaper was being cached somewhere on disk, so I tried a search for both the PNG version of the wallpaper (the one that ends up in "UUID/lockscreen.png") and the original version in "/System/Library/Desktop Pictures/Chroma Red.heic" by using the file size:


sudo find / -size 11444683c (PNG version)
sudo find / -size 41337084c (HEIC version)


Unfortunately, I couldn't find any other copies. Either it's in a directory we don't have access to as 'root', or it's in a different file format (and therefore a different size), or the system is somehow stuck looking at that original HEIC version due to some configuration file rather than a cached copy of the image.


Has anyone called Apple Support?


Hi Will:


From my understanding, we are all suffering from Chroma Red on the "LOGIN" screen when we are not already logged into our machines' consoles. I cannot speak for the others but my "LOCK" screen [when I am logged in and my machine goes to sleep] is the same as my requested desktop background.


[Also, I am not seeing a difference in the results of our login screen choice (or lack of) with the Filevault on or off.]


B


willm127 wrote:

Thank you for creating this separate thread--I got here from the one you linked above.

I really hope this gets fixed. I just got this new M1Pro MacBook Pro, and I can't believe we're already dealing with bugs. And the worst part is that this image is just so awful! Also, is there a consensus on whether this is called the 'Lock screen' or the 'Login screen?'

For further research, and if Apple happens upon this thread:
2021 14" M1Pro MacBook Pro
MacOS Monterey - 12.0.1
Filevault - on
One user
Guest User - Off
Automatic login - Off
Display login window as: List of users
Show the Sleep, Restart, and Shut Down buttons


I have the same issue on a 1 day old iMAC. Wife says - change that screen!!! OK . . the location is system/library/desktop pictures/monterey graphic.heic. Then it is called Monterey Graphic.HEIC and called an HEIF image. The file is locked and limited, and opening the picture information will not permit a permission change. There are 5 static pictures I think, so it must change as a true screensaver.


If you can fix the permissions, and rename it the same using a different HEIC/HEIF format, please post the results. Don't go to the user directory, that is not going to work for the common login screen background anyway. I submitted a feature request, should it be a bug?

Same issue.


Something else I noticed: the UI between an Apple Silicon Mac and an Intel Mac on this "Initial Login Screen" are actually different. On an Intel Mac running Monterey (12.2), when you select a user with the arrow key on the Initial Login Screen the user profile picture and name are highlighted by a transparent rectangle with rounded corners. On the Apple Silicon Mac the user profile picture is highlighted by a white ring. Two distinctly different UI elements for the same action. This leads me to believe that the software running for the Initial Login Screen on an Apple Silicon Mac (at least on the MBP) is actually different than that on an Intel Mac. The UI was designed to be similar, but it is not exact. Wherever this software is, be it in a hidden inaccessible volume or in some kind of read-only firmware, is where I suspect this wallpaper is.

I've been affected by this issue on two different laptops, and in both cases the login screen background changed to "chroma red" after restoring the laptop from a Time Machine backup. I hope this information helps Apple reproduce and fix the issue.

Just received and am setting up my MBP 16" M1 Pro 32G 1TB. Had an all apple "ecosystem" MINUS computer, and thanks to a generous bday gift, am now all in: 2 iphones, AW7, ipad pro M1 11", apple tv and this $3500 extravagance... My last macbook allowed me to customize desktop, lock/login screen and screensaver quite easily. EVEN the default APPLE options were appealing and soothing and 'feel good,' so that when I booted up, i was greeted with the perfect mood to start off my work or play day... THIS GARISH, awful, bleak, masculine, offensive login screen TRULY is the MOST DEPRESSING graphic apple could have chosen to FORCE US TO SEE every time we boot up.... NO workaround 'works' other than turning OFF vault encryption and then you only have the possibility to have your desktop pic double as your lock/login screen...


I TRULY assumed I was missing something, but after two long calls with apple support, was reassured that i was NOT overlooking some obvious solution, but that THERE WAS NO SOLUTION and I would be stuck with this god-awful image greeting me every. single. day. AT LEAST give us a selection from which to choose our poison, but APPLE almost seems to have gone OUT OF ITS WAY to pick THE. MOST. DEPRESSING graphic they could muster....


I've now joked to APPLE CS and friends that I think I would rather compromise the security of my files by deactivating filevault encryption, then compromise my mental health... And, so....until or if APPLE changes this MOST BIZARRE forced feature, I will either just NOT use file vault encryption and just make double duty of my desktop image, or -- and I know this sounds extreme -- maybe THIS IS A SIGN that I should return this SUPER PRICEY, yet arguable capable, beautiful, and impressive piece of tech that I have coveted for MONTHS.... PLEASE, someone at APPLE MUST NOT BE AWARE OF THIS, or IF THEY ARE, it is INCONCEIVABLE that they have no geniuses at their bar (let alone top level software engineers-designers) who could come up with a fix..... SEEMS SUPER DUPER EASY TO DO; JUST ADD MORE WALLPAPER FILES TO THE DIRECTORY HOLDING THE PNG LOCK SCREEN PIC....


For the love of GOD, PUHLEASE MAKE THIS CHROMA RED INDECENCY GO AWAY.; It really makes me feel viscerally ill. It induces the OPPOSITE effect APPLE products have PREVIOUSLY had on me over the years which is, y'know, the little hug of 'hello' that we've grown to know and expect.

thank you.

Thank you for creating this separate thread--I got here from the one you linked above.


I really hope this gets fixed. I just got this new M1Pro MacBook Pro, and I can't believe we're already dealing with bugs. And the worst part is that this image is just so awful! Also, is there a consensus on whether this is called the 'Lock screen' or the 'Login screen?'


For further research, and if Apple happens upon this thread:

2021 14" M1Pro MacBook Pro

MacOS Monterey - 12.0.1

Filevault - on

One user

Guest User - Off

Automatic login - Off

Display login window as: List of users

Show the Sleep, Restart, and Shut Down buttons

Same issue here (MacBook Pro 16″ 2021 Silver, macOS Monterey 12.0.1).


When the boot screen ( logo & progress bar) disappears the login screen is 'Chroma Blue'.

There are 2 users I can choose between.

Once a user is selected the background of the login screen is whatever has been set as desktop background by that user.

Once logged in and whenever switching back to the login screen, the background of the login screen remains 'correct', until you decide to go back to the list of users. The background of the login screen then returns to 'Chroma Blue'.


Looks like (the ugly) 'Chrome Blue' is for the ones that opted for the silver finish and (the even uglier) 'Chroma Red' for the space grey enthusiasts.

Interesting observation regarding 'Blue' for the silver Macs and 'Red' for the grey!


I tried searching all the PLIST files on my system for any mention 'Chroma Red', but the only hit was not relevant.


I was going to try deleting the HEIC file from the Wallpapers folder to see what would happen, but deleting something from the system partition on a Mac is not easy, and I figured I might as well wait until Apple just fixes it...


Depressing is a great description of this.


I've spent hours combing the internet to come to this thread...and I'm just stunned.


With all the beautiful possibilities, why why why did they choose this? Even just a plain blue screen would be better than this.


Please - please, just change this with the next OS update? Please. We know you can do it.

I have a space gray M1 Macbook, and since I received it in February 2022 it's always been stuck on Chroma Red for the login background, and it is definitely terrible. Having a computer this nice with such a fugly login screen is weird for sure. I'm glad I haven't spent too many hours battling it, since it seems like an Apple problem, not a user problem. Apple is weird. They want to decide what's best for their users and give them that with few or no alternatives, and people seem to love that. In this case the thing they provide with no alternatives looks like a bad dream.

Simply couldn't agree more. It is the most DEPRESSING and HIDEOUS image imaginable. No, really. Give us a simple BLACK or GRAY screen, instead of this vomit of a graphic!


I have used Macs for over twenty years now, always purchasing the latest device (mostly MacBook Pros) when upgrading but I will do that NO MORE and will from now on always go for second hand as Apple Micky-Mousing the OS has been bugging me increasingly and this ugliness is really just too much.


FFS!

We have five Macs and from the very beginning in 2015 with their OS versions up thru 12.4 none of them have had any kind of problem with selecting backgrounds.


I suspect you have a specific problem and that it's not a generic "bug". But if you have it fixed and never touching backgrounds is your workaround, you' 00004000 re home free.

It’s easier to look straight into the sun, than to see what Apple has hiding behind the noxious visual they’re attempting to call login wallpaper! Steve Jobs was a brilliant friend to the creative, free thinking artist, those days are entirely gone now. This M1 Mac with Monterey 12.4 couldn’t possibly belong to an artist, I’m sending it back!

This is wrong. This thread is about the background of the login screen—the one Apple calls the "Login Window" used for switching between user accounts— not the desktop background or the background of the lock screen. If you can share an example of a login screen on a new M1 Mac running Monterey that is not Chroma Red or Chroma Blue, or better yet, if you can demonstrate how to switch away from either of these, that would be helpful.

I have the same issue.

I have two instances of the HEIC file:


/System/Library/Desktop Pictures/Chroma Red.heic
/System/Volumes/Data/System/Library/Desktop Pictures/Chroma Red.heic


and no instances of the PNG file.

I came from the original thread this thread came from. May I add another twist to this annoying saga? My MBP 16” M1 Max is stuck on the blue chroma. It looks like the screen is cracked

Same issue here. We have 12.1 out already and the bug still persists.

Same issue on macbook pro m1 pro with 12.1 and still stuck with this awful Chroma Red image.

Same. You would think apple would have fixed this very simple issue in the update.

My guess is one of the developers needs to be afflicted with this rather rare feature to troubleshoot it.

My 'Chroma Blue' & silver vs 'Chroma Red' & space grey observation seems to be consistent with Apple's own product images.

Updated to 12.2 this morning but no luck. Same ugly Chroma Red login screen. Ugh.

[Unfortunately, I have just restarted the machine to find the Chroma-Red display back.]

Also unfortunately I cannot find out how to "unsolve this thread."

(and after a reboot, mine is back to Chroma Red)

Thanx, it works on iMac 27" 2020 with macOS Monterey 12.2.1

Everyone is aware of it and there is no "fix" because it is not a bug.

I have the same problem!!!


chroma red is so jarring and produces such a strong negative reaction for me, I am at a loss for what to do. apple, please... my autistic eyes are in pain having to look at this every day.

But did it have to be such a disgusting image? Honestly.