Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

"AddTrust External CA Root" Certificate Expired: Websites Won't Open

Hello!


My specs:

Model Name: MacBook Pro (Retina, 15-inch, Mid 2014)

Model Identifier: MacBookPro11,3

OS X El Capitan, v10.11.6


Over the last few days, certain websites will not open on Safari or Opera. The 'error' message states the following:

This Connection Is Not Private

This website may be impersonating “xyz.com” to steal your personal or financial information. You should go back to the previous page.

Go Back

Safari warns you when a website has an expired certificate. This website’s certificate expired 3 days ago. This may happen if the website is misconfigured, an attacker has compromised your connection, or your system clock is incorrect. Your system clock is set to Tuesday, June 2, 2020. If this is not right, fixing the clock may address this warning.

To learn more, you can view the certificate. If you understand the risks involved, you can visit this website.


The culprit seems to be 'ADDTrust External CA Root' certificate expired on 5/30/2020. All the websites that aren't opening point to the 'ADDTrust External CA Root' certificate.


Are there any solutions other than upgrading to Catalina? Can certificates be updated?


Thank you in advance for your help or time.



13 replies

I had no luck with removing certificates or the endless other things I tried. But:


Solved! Known problem in El Cap, simple fix. Grrr.


Called Apple four days ago and got an incompetent tech. She essentially ended up shrugging her shoulders, no clue, sent me packing.


That started three days of Catalina upgrade and endless reboots and calls to other software firms to TRY and solve all the ensuing problems. (Lots of old apps croak, plus problems with Apple apps/services.)


Called again today and got savvy tech who's been using Macs since '86 (newbie, by my lights... ;-) ).


Just upgrade El Cap to Sierra. Sweet mother Mary. If that first tech had just told me that...


Sierra: https://support.apple.com/kb/HT208202


The install program on this DMG installs an installer in your Applications folder. Run that.


Other, later installers:


High Sierra: https://support.apple.com/kb/HT208969


Mojave: https://support.apple.com/kb/HT210190

According to actual experience (and wikipedia) Safari version 11.1.2

for El Capitan 10.11.6, support faded (July 9, 2018). While I sought info

about Opera, lacked detail for their recent version or present status.


The "Brave" web browser is supported/runs in El Capitan 10.11.6; and

may be OK once details using it, are understood. https://brave.com/


The Opera background changed with their adapting Chrome features;

some macOS users at that time, had issue with Opera. I'd not used it

since just before major transitions; & it didn't work for me or my mac.


There had been some ability to change User Agents in certain browsers

to see if they still be useful after their sunset; some did OK for awhile. I'd

not tried this recently. (With older vintage Mac OS X, I'd tried to do that.)


The certificates idea -in previous situations- was workable; there may be

path through this shortcoming by using the 'Apple IST CA 2 - G1 Cert.'

{..Thanks BDAqua for this; to see if that's an option.!}


Good luck & happy trails!🌤☘

Expired ones are doing any good so you could delete them.


I like K Shaffer's idea of Brave browser. :)

Thank you!

I downloaded the Apple IST CA 2 - G1 Certificate and I am still experiencing the same issue.

Do you recommend I remove/delete the expired certificate, AddTrust External CA Root, from Keychain Access?


Thank you!

I was really hoping to avoid Catalina and find a solution with certificates.

Thank you for taking the time to help and your guidance.

Thank you! I will look into it.

I have Opera and experience the same certificate issues as in Safari.

Great news, take care my friend. :)

Thanks for the report! :)

Thank you!

I totally understand your frustration with Apple CS. :)

Appreciate the help and time.

There is Mojave 10.14.6, or slightly older High Sierra 10.13.6. These do not require your system apps

or drivers to be fully 64-bit compliant; and can still use 32-bit software so that you may not need

to also get newer printer, or peripherals for 64-bit only. ~ Catalina macOS 10.15.x is solely 64-bit.


• How to upgrade to macOS Mojave 10.14.6 - Apple Support

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210190


Be sure to have at least two backups of your present system prior to upgrade attempts; Time

Machine can be useful to restore from, should you wish keep older stuff into a newer system;

although some users prefer all-new content.


Other options could include using third-party Browser (Firefox) and Email client (Thunderbird)

to stay with the older El Capitan 10.11.6. ~ At least until you've figured this further along.


Good luck & happy trails!🌻🌤

Thank you, BDAqua and K Shaffer!

After deleting the expired certificates, 99% of the websites are opening up again.


Thank you again for all the help, time, and guidance. I am so appreciative.