Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

How to Simulate Star Rating in Photos 5 on Catalina

Because of the changes in Photos 5 when searching for text, the old work-around for simulating rating stars with keywords has been broken. The search cannot find a text in the middle of a word, we have to search for the start of a word. And the search term must not start with a "*". So it is no longer possible to search for "***" in the middle of a rating keyword 5*****, to find all ratings of at least 3 (3***, 4****, 5*****) with one search rule in a smart album.


Here is a work-around for Photos 5 on Catalina: How to Simulate Star Rating in Photos 5 on Catalina - Apple Community

We have to rename the rating keywords again, so all rating keyword will start with the same alphanumeric letter.


This old version does no longer work fully: How to Simulate Star Ratings in Photos

10 replies

I use the five keywords:


★★★★★

★★★★☆

★★★☆☆

★★☆☆☆

★☆☆☆☆


with shortcuts "5", "4", "3", "2" & "1". Searching seems to work fine with macOS Catalina 10.15.4. If you want to find items with a specific number of stars, you just search for items with a specific keyword. However, if you can also find items with, e.g., "3 or more stars" or "2 or fewer stars" by using the smart album "Text" criterion. For example, to find items with "3 or more stars", I use the following smart album:



Here, the criterion "Text is ★★★" selects items that have keywords that contain the string "★★★", which means the items will have any one of the keywords:


★★★★★

★★★★☆

★★★☆☆


There is one caveat that I think is work mentioning: Although the smart album "Text" criterion does work correctly for me in the way that I show in the image above, it appears to me (Read: I am only guessing, but experience shows that this is likely true) that the smart album "Text" criterion is dependent on metadata that background macOS processes are responsible for maintaining. As a result, smart albums that use this criterion do not return the correct results until this metadata is updated. This means that you may need to wait some seconds or even minutes after you make changes in Photos before such smart album return the correct items. Sometime, it even seems to help to quit and then restart Photos, although I may just be acting overly cautious here.


Presumably, the smart album I show above will also find items where the string "★★★" appears in the title or description of an item, but this situation is unlikely, since "★" & "☆" are unicode characters that one does not normally type when entering text with the keyboard.


Of course, you need to ensure that you do not assign multiple keywords for different numbers of stars to items, but that can be monitored and corrected with special smart albums to locate such items.

I use the five keywords:


★★★★★

★★★★☆

★★★☆☆

★★☆☆☆

★☆☆☆☆


with shortcuts "5", "4", "3", "2" & "1". Searching seems to work fine with macOS Catalina 10.15.4. If you want to find items with a specific number of stars, you just search for items with a specific keyword. However, if you can also find items with, e.g., "3 or more stars" or "2 or fewer stars" by using the smart album "Text" criterion. For example, to find items with "3 or more stars", I use the following smart album:



Here, the criterion "Text is ★★★" selects items that have keywords that contain the string "★★★", which means the items will have any one of the keywords:


★★★★★

★★★★☆

★★★☆☆


There is one caveat that I think is work mentioning: Although the smart album "Text" criterion does work correctly for me in the way that I show in the image above, it appears to me (Read: I am only guessing, but experience shows that this is likely true) that the smart album "Text" criterion is dependent on metadata that background macOS processes are responsible for maintaining. As a result, smart albums that use this criterion do not return the correct results until this metadata is updated. This means that you may need to wait some seconds or even minutes after you make changes in Photos before such smart album return the correct items. Sometime, it even seems to help to quit and then restart Photos, although I may just be acting overly cautious here.


Presumably, the smart album I show above will also find items where the string "★★★" appears in the title or description of an item, but this situation is unlikely, since "★" & "☆" are unicode characters that one does not normally type when entering text with the keyboard.


Of course, you need to ensure that you do not assign multiple keywords for different numbers of stars to items, but that can be monitored and corrected with special smart albums to locate such items.

That is working like a charm, thank you.


That is smart solution, to use the ASCII code for a star, Jeffrey. It looks much more pleasing and allows us to use a text rule to search for star ratings.


I can confirm your caveat about the background updating. I am quitting and restarting Photos a lot to get the searches and sorting updated quickly.





The new features keep coming, but in very small helpings. I did not see any mention of star ratings in the Big Sur announcements. macOS Big Sur Preview - Features - Apple

We'll be getting captions, vibrance, and a better retouch tool for Photos.

Lets keep the fingers crossed and wait for the star shine ☆☆☆☆☆

That is very interesting and useful. I will definitely make use of it.


I have found a case where it does not seem to work correctly for me. I assign keywords of the form “TakenBy: <name>” to items in order to record who took the photo or video. For example, “TakenBy: John Doe” or “TakenBy: Kari Nordmann”. I have confirmed that creating a smart album with the criterion:


Keyword is TakenBy: *


does correctly find all items that have a “TakenBy: <name>” keyword assigned. Yay. Further, the criterion:


Keyword is not TakenBy: *


finds items that do not have a “TakenBy: <name>” keyword assigned. Another yay. However this criterion also matches items that have two or more “TakenBy: <name>” keywords assigned. That does not make sense to me. Perhaps this is a bug related to an undocumented feature?

Interesting. The problem with "keyword is not ..." might be the same as with "person is not". In the early versions of Photos 5 the "person is not" rule has been true for all photos with at least one person that is not the specified person.


I'll try to use the wildcards to recreate Aperture's hierarchical keywords. Perhaps I can organise my wildlife photos this way animal:mammal: carnivore: lion etc.


Fortunately, the new behaviour that you reported is still very useful, at least for me, even with this quirk. In my example with “TakenBy: <name>” keywords, it actually has the benefit of finding photos that have two different “TakenBy: <name>” keywords assigned (which I do not want to occur), but I will not count on this behaviour in the future.

Waiting for a version op Photos that re-introduces the star rating system. Apple will call it a new feature. We've seen that in iMovie too...

I just noticed that even the keyword rules in smart albums are now treating the asterisk as a wildcard character.

We do no longer need to use the text rule and search for partial text. We can now search specifically for keywords with the wildcard * in the name using a smart album.

The smart album with the rule "Keyword is ★★*" will find all photos with a keyword starting with at least two ★s.


The only problem is, that we can only use predefined keywords in a smart album, that appear in the drop down list of defined keywords. So we have to define the search patterns ★★* as a keyword in the Keyword Manager as well, not Blythe keywords we are actually assigning to the photos.

If we want to sync the wildcard versions ★★* etc. to all photo libraries for searching, we could add theses keywords to one hidden photo, that will not appear in our searches, but ensure, that the keywords and search patterns will appear in all our Photo Libraries, that are syncing with iCloud Photos and we have to define them only once.