Unofficial archive. This is a read-only, community-run archive of the Apple Support Community. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc.

Safari 13.0.4 Broken on Apple ID Logins?

Hi:


Safari 13.0.4 on my High Sierra MBP broke yesterday It works fine on all logins except those requiring my Apple ID. I can login to everything requiring my Apple ID, and everything else, using Firefox and Chrome on this machine. Also, Safari works fine in all contexts on my Catalina MBA. Below is a screenshot showing the type of message I get when Safari on my High Sierra MBP fails to get me to a login screen where I would need to use my Apple ID. Help?


29 replies

Eric and macjack:


Victory is sweet. I decided to upgrade my problem machine, the 2017 MBP, to Mohave. Yes, Safari now works again as it should. My victory is just a lucky one me thinks, but still yay!!! Try it Eric?

Yes, that is what I meant. As mention above, I solved my High Sierra problem by upgrading to Mohave. Also, I had two Sierra machines. Safari worked correctly on both of them. One of them is a mid 2011 11" MBA. Contacts weren't syncing on it, and I could not figure out why not. So, I upgraded it to High Sierra. Contacts now sync, and Safari on High Sierra works correctly. Go figure.


I now have decided that the problem is not as widespread as I thought. Indeed, given the number of posts here, I think it is was restricted to only my 2107 High Sierra MBP and your High Sierra/Safari 12.1.2 machine. 😂

I solved it by upgrading to Mohave. See above. Thank you though.

Still being worked on. Reports of re-installing from a Time Machine backup did not work. The issue seems to be on the back end so any fix users attempt will not work. The frustrating part is that on some Macs it is working but not on others.

If you mean High Sierra/Safari, based on what I have read, that is the only affected OS where Safari can't sign into Apple sign ins. Older OS versions work and newer OS versions work.

I'm having the same problem starting yesterday too (Firefox is working).

https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251109069


I have High Sierra and Safari 13.0.5 (I was having the same problem with Safari 12). I have Sierra on an external drive, I tried it from there and it worked (it had Safari 11.0.3). I can upgrade to Mojave if neccessary, but not Catalina because I need 32 bit app support.

The issue isn't on your end. Interesting that it works in Safari 11.0.3. That's the tough part because it works on some model Macs but not on others. Also works on the same models but with different versions of Safari.


Sure, you can upgrade to Mojave, you probably should anyway because Sierra is no longer supported and Mojave should be supported for almost 2 years.


At any rate, engineering is aware of this and is working on it.

You are welcome. I have access to a computer that is running Mojave. Safari will connect to the Support Community, iCloud.com, and allow you to log into your Apple ID. I don't know anything else about the Mojave software, so I can't make a recommendation about upgrading to it.

Hi donv! Yes, it's been broken since yesterday afternoon. Same here with Safari 13.0.5. The PTB are aware of it and they are working on it. Hopefully, they'll get it sorted soon. I really don't like Firefox and I refuse to use Chrome as I do not like being tracked!

Thank you much mj. Why an I having no problem with Safari on my Catalina MBP? "Also, Safari works fine in all contexts on my Catalina MBA." I am with you on Firefox and Chrome. Firefox is ugly, and Chrome is as you say. And, actually, I had tried upgrading to 13.0.5. Glad I didn't start cloning back or reinstalling High Sierra otherwise. I was tempted. I'm in 13.0.4 in Catalina.

I'd bet that's it. 😇 But, hey, I worked hard to get a Catalina MBA. I went to an Apple Store and questioned "everyone" thoroughly to make sure that if I bought a machine at the store, then I would get a Catalina machine. Got home, set it up, and, well, ugh, it was a Mohave. I wanted to start with a perfectly clean slate so I took the MBA back. A few days later I felt returners remorse because I didn't know how long it would be before I would have been absolutely guaranteed to get a Catalina MBA. I got the Store to get me one from their latest delivery, knowing that was no real insurance on getting a Catalina. And, I didn't. So I upgraded immediately to Catalina. All has been good with the MBA except maybe a few minor things I pay no attention to. I am glad I didn't get an MBP, especially a 16."

Wow! We have a 2017 still running Sierra. I see no reason to move higher on it. I only upgraded my 2017 MBP to High Sierra so I could get Office Home/Student 2019. The move to the Catalina machine is part of my march to 32-bit freedom and leaving some other applications behind. I also got Office 2019 for the Catalina machine.

Are there any stats out there on which machines/OS X installations are having the problem. I just found out that I don't have a problem on either of my Sierra machines. And, as noted above, I don't have a problem on my Catalina machine. The only bad Apple (🤣) is my High Sierra machine, my work horse machine.

Like I said, it's a difficult one to pin down, it works on some model Macs but not on others. Also works on the same models but with different versions of Safari. I'm hoping short of something they can fix in the back end, there will be an update for one or the other that solves it.

It still isn't working for me with OS High Sierra and Safari 12.1.2 and it has been 4 days since the Apple Software Destruction Engineers made a change to the Apple Support Community software. I am beginning to wonder if the Apple Software Destruction Engineers are even going to try to fix it.

Thank you for your reply Eric. I am sorry to hear about your High Sierra installation. I have been wondering if a fix is coming. I wish I had the figures to make a guesstimate of the probability of fixing Safari by upgrading to Mohave or Catalina and not ending up with a more serious problem, particularly in the case of Catalina. I hope the ASDEs choose to behave responsibly and fix Safari or tell us they are not going to do so and why not.

I'm not sure it's newsworthy. It's nothing like a security issue and it seems very few folks are experiencing it. I haven't seen any other posts here related to it and even this thread doesn't appear to be getting much traction.

00004000

Interesting, before I posted I saw that Eric's was the last post in My Subscriptions but when I posted it was not showing. Now after posting. I see there were a few posts after that. More fun and games!

Yes, more fun and games. Maybe the problem isn't all that widespread. I guess we'll see. It would be annoying if Apple wouldn't take responsibility for breaking something that is of significance to undoubtedly quite a few faithful users, something that is connected to its Apple's cornerstone, the Apple ID, and the Apple software that is suppose to feed into this cornerstone, Safari.

I have a couple of applications I use on a regular basis that aren't compatible with Mojave, so I am in no hurry to upgrade. Maybe the Apple Software Destruction Engineers will fix the High Sierra/Safari problem, but I doubt they will.

I don't know why it works in Catalina. But folks are reporting that it does. Maybe Apple is trying to get all of us to upgrade? 😎

Nice! But I'm hanging onto my mid 2010 iMac until the wheels fall off.

Thank you much. I guess something good will happen some day soon.

I am not sure the Mohave upgrade will be better. But, good luck.

Thanks. Apple still seems to being very secretive about the problem. As far as I know, it has not been on the news, and it's sort of a big deal.

I see. If so, no kudos to the ASDEs. Do you feel that the problem is confined to just those two?

It worked!