84 replies
Aug 28, 2009 3:41 PM
Delete the file (in the same place)
com.apple.finder.plist.
Logout/in.
Set them the way you want them.
*Note: Other Finder pref's will reset.
Scott
Aug 28, 2009 7:41 PM
Scott,
Thanks for the quick reply. I did as you suggested, and (of course) all of my Finder preferences reset (including the dock placement). I went about changing everything back to how I like it, and it was fine for the initial logout/login. After that, it keeps rearranging the icons on my desktop. Now when I log back in (in any fashion), the icons are in alphabetical order - even if I have "none", "size", "kind", or any of the other options selected from the "View Options" menu. It seems, to me, like the icons are being arranged in alphabetical order before OS X puts the dock on the right-hand side. Then, when the dock is placed there, it overlays the icons. I'm just assuming this is the case, since I see the icons appear before the dock.
Is there anything else you might recommend? I don't understand why it was working just fine then, all of a sudden, it is doing this. I didn't install any additional software or software updates, and this preceded my 10.6 install.
Aug 28, 2009 7:46 PM
Are you sure you're not setting the view for a Window and not the Desktop?
Close all Finder windows.
Now, select Command-J and make sure it's set the way you wish.
Logout/in.
Scott
Aug 28, 2009 7:52 PM
Scott,
Yep. Just to double-check, I did as you suggested. I'm making changes in the "View Options" window (Grab won't let me take a screenshot of it). The title of the window is "Desktop." The window also allows me to change things like icon size, grid spacing, and text size. It is driving me crazy! The changes take effect just fine. It's the post login that always is messed up.
I did manage to get it to log back in and have the icons arranged, but this only works when I have them set to arrange by name. The desktop icons pop-up to the very far right (see my second screenshot). Then, when the dock appears a split second later, the row of icons "jump" over to the left (to clear the dock). This only happens when I have them set to auto arrange by name. If I have it set to "align to grid" (which is what I prefer, so I can arrange them as I see fit), the "Macintosh HD" is in the right spot, but the other icons never get that "jump;" they stay partially obfuscated by the dock.
I do appreciate all of your help and tips thus far.
Aug 29, 2009 7:10 AM
I decided to do a fresh install of 10.6 to fix the problem. It probably wouldn't annoy some (most?) people, but it was frustrating me to no end. On a positive note, the install went smoothly and everything is up-and-running exactly as before (but without the odd icon problem). I'm fairly confident it was an issue in some settings file (maybe another plist file) that was causing my icons to automatically arrange by name on the desktop. What was even more odd was that, towards the end, it would only do the rearrangement every 3-4 times I restarted. The other times my icons would be right where I put them. I changed nothing; I just logged in, looked at the icons, the logged out.
Aug 29, 2009 9:19 AM
Sorry it came to that, but as you discovered, sometimes it's best to "nuke and pave" to get rid of things that may have carried-over from years of use.
Glad you're working now - sometimes it's an easy fix, sometimes not.
BUT - the experience you gain from doing this makes your knowledge stronger and you become a better user for it.
Enjoy!
Scott
Aug 29, 2009 12:38 PM
Definitely true. I'd only had this machine since March of this year (2009), so I was hoping to do an in-place upgrade. Alas, that was not to be.
I will say that fresh installations have become so much easier than they used to be. Sure, they take a little longer, but at least I don't have to make copies of my CONFIG.SYS or, even worse, HIMEM.SYS files so I can recreate them when I load DOS 6.22 back on a PC. I didn't have much experience with the Mac OS before v8 (Classic), so I can't really speak to their historical installation procedures. I do have to give Apple a lot of credit with 10.6; the installation was flawless, extremely fast, and well-documented. Now if I could only convince them that I don't speak 15 languages and have a need for all of those language translations. 🙂 At least they're easier to uncheck these days!
Aug 29, 2009 2:37 PM
I did not have the problem described in this topic before upgrading to Snow Leopard. After upgrading, I had it all the time.
The culprit in my case was BlueHarvest. The latest version is Snow Leopard savvy, however, it defaults to nonsensical settings for the .DS_Stores file.
To fix, launch open the BlueHarvest preference pane. In the DS_Stores tab, uncheck "Startup Disk" and "File Servers".
Aug 29, 2009 2:46 PM
@mwdiers: That's a good point. I thought about BlueHarvest, so I stopped it. I guess I neglected to look at those check boxes. Like you said, I don't remember "File Servers" being checked by default in previous versions.
I also thought it might be Dropbox (although I don't know why), since the latest version is not 100% Snow Leopard friendly. It wasn't.
Aug 30, 2009 11:41 AM
Thank you thank you! I actually had this problem occurring a few days ago in Leopard, prior to upgrading to Snow Leopard on Friday. It never occurred to me to check my settings in BlueHarvest after updating to the SL-compatible version (which I did before the SL upgrade itself). I should have realized what was happening when I used TinkerTool to view the invisible files, thinking maybe it was a bad DS_Store file... the file kept appearing & disappearing, because BlueHarvest kept deleting it!
Kudos, another maddening bug squashed. 🙂
Sep 6, 2009 11:41 AM
Hello
I also use a special way of arranging icons within a binder to organize my work (like one would spread papers over a large table in a meaningful manner).
I have just upgraded to 10.6 and encountered the sale issue: "auto-Rearranging icons" when logging out and in again
Using spotlight to seek for a "organized backed version of this bonder" i have figured out it is definitely a bug :
the disorganized window looks well organized in a past state within time machine...for two seconds, before you see icons messing around "live" and back to the disorganized way.
It's like no back up is any way out from this....no presentation optio has been any solution so far.
I'm currenty copying my work to an external drive with a view to copying back to my mac, hoping this will tell the finder to stop messing around..;
I'lle let you know....
Still...HELP ! IS ANYONE FROM APPLE WILLING TO HELP US SOLVE WHAT BRINGS MAC OS (THE FIRST OBJECT ORIENTED USER INTERFACE IN IT HISTORY)... BACK TO STONE AGE ???
Sep 8, 2009 10:46 AM
hello again
It seems i found a trick that might help:
if in the presentation options of the windows (ctrl j) you set de default presentation "by list" rather than "by icon", then when arranging the icons in a "by icon" presentation, this arranement will last and not be changed randmly: loging out and in again, openning the window which will show up by default in a list presentation, manually switching to presentatiàon by icon, you might get back every icon as you organised them previously....
Sep 21, 2009 9:03 AM
{quote:title=jmm-frency wrote:}I have just upgraded to 10.6 and encountered the sale issue: "auto-Rearranging icons" when logging out and in again{quote}
I had the same problem since I did upgrade to Snow Leopard. Same problem, even with a clean install of 10.6.1 on a blank disk.
Here is how I did fix that issue.
Finder - View - Show View Options - Arrange by: (select "snap to grid")
Otherwise, it seems like the problem is related to the "Grid Spacing" adjustment feature, but selecting "snap to grid" as a preference for the desktop should fix everything.
P-
Oct 19, 2009 2:23 AM
I also have the same problem. None of the above works for me. I have no special software installed.
Oct 22, 2009 12:10 AM
Hi all,
I have the same, very annoying, problem. I tried snapping the icons to the grid but after a couple of days it goes bananas again and all icons end up on the right hand side, in alphabetical order from right bottom and to the left... I have my Dock on the left hand side, will try putting it bac to the bottom again. No particular apps as I'm not a pro user... ; - )
Mor-san
Oct 22, 2009 12:36 AM
Folks,
A good way to quickly check if this problem is likely to be solved by a clean install of Snow Leopard is by simply creating a new user profile in System Preferences > Accounts. Then log in to that new account and see if the same problem exists. If the same problem exists then it is system wide but if not then the problem is isolated to the the user profile that was upgraded during the Snow Leopard upgrade. This is very possible and many minor issues have been spotted with upgraded user profiles such as this issue.
Hope this helps.
Rosco
proposed | solution
Nov 26, 2009 6:09 AM
Hi,
I had the same problem on each start up: all icons went to the right side of the screen.
After changing my main computer password it didn't happen again for the last dozen of start ups!
Hope this may help you.
Dec 1, 2009 10:46 AM
Same happenned with me which is a complete and utter F$£$%^@£%$ because I had hundreds of icons on my desiktop with my entire workflow and now they're all arranged alphabetically down the side - thanks Apple - five years of workflow down the tube. Have tried everything suggested here but nothing works.
Dec 7, 2009 9:04 PM
I had the same problem of icons ending up on the right after any restart (in both 10.5 and 10.6), which was resolved by deleting the hidden .DS_Store file on the desktop. It rebuilt itself and the problem went away. YMMV
Jan 14, 2010 7:09 PM
Please forget my previous post recopied bellow..
I take it back, I still have the same annoying problem (clean install 10.6.2)
Indeed, my solution was based on false hope...
Pascal Beausoleil wrote:
{quote:title=jmm-frency wrote:}I have just upgraded to 10.6 and encountered the sale issue: "auto-Rearranging icons" when logging out and in again{quote}
I had the same problem since I did upgrade to Snow Leopard. Same problem, even with a clean install of 10.6.1 on a blank disk.
Here is how I did fix that issue.
Finder - View - Show View Options - Arrange by: (select "snap to grid")
Otherwise, it seems like the problem is related to the "Grid Spacing" adjustment feature, but selecting "snap to grid" as a preference for the desktop should fix everything.
P-
Jan 17, 2010 7:24 AM
Hi all,
I had the same annoying problem on my Mac Pro. I read that it might come from the corrupt finder file ".DS_Store". Following the instructions how to delete this hidden file by using the utility Terminal, did not work... But then I found out that using the freeware Onyx it is very easy to delete the desktop's .DS_Store file. E voilà: this fixed the problem!
Maybe this information could help you, too.
Bye, Stefan
Feb 5, 2010 8:08 AM
There also used to be a useful 'snap to grid' feature in Leopard where if you held the CMD key when drag/dropping an icon on the desktop, it would snap to the grid. This appears to be broken/non existent in Snow Leopard, which is a shame because it was incredibly useful.
Feb 28, 2010 1:37 AM
TinkerTool may be a solution!
Open Tink
00004000
erTool - Finder options - select 1st one - "Show hidden and system files"
Relaunch finder to activate changes. Trash the .DS_Store file on the right top of the screen. Wait a couple of seconds before it rebuilds or relaunch the finder again.
Before shutting down or restarting the computer I execute as explained above getting an actualized .DS_Store file for the next time.
It works with me but be careful, use it at your own risk.
Mar 25, 2010 2:34 AM
same here, i experience this problem every 10th reboot since 6 month. its annoying. (10.6)
i try the hint with tinker tool now and report back soon!
thx
Apr 2, 2010 9:01 AM
The solution proposed here worked for me as well : I trashed the hidden file .DS_Store located on the desktop. Then I chose "none" as the option for icons organization on the desktop. I find that "align to grid" behave erratically.
P.
Apr 12, 2010 1:17 PM
Hello,
I deleted the hidden .DS_Store file on the desktop, using Onyx, a few days ago.
I changed the view options to Arrange by: NONE. Previously it was to "Snap to grid".
Unfortunately after a few days, the problem came back.
😟
Since the icons on the desktop are being rearranged, I believe the problem lies in the finder window view. When you change the view (list, column or cover flow) inside a finder window, it seems that at this time something will go wrong on next login. Notice that if you change a view in one finder folder. When you go into a new finder window, the last change applies on previous window. There must be a conflict there, that affects the desktop icons.
Hope Apple find the problem...
Good luck!
P.S.: Strange that this problem does not exist in 10.5 (Leopard).
Apr 13, 2010 2:29 PM
I don´t thinks the question is solved. As for several others, the problem was NOT solved for me when deleting the DS.store file; also deleting the respective plist, in addition, did not result in a stable situation: for a few starts all is OK, but then again the icons are rearranged upon start.
I had the impression that i came with updating to 10.6.3, and i have the problem definitely only since a few weeks/months. But it appears both on my desktop and on the MacBook which are completely independent; either was previously running 10.5 and updated the simple way to 10.6.
Apple should address this obvious bug - it is really extremely nasty to spent again and again time to bring the things into the old, rational order on the desktop!
Apr 13, 2010 11:22 PM
Same problem here: 2 MacPros - 1 affected, 1 smooth.
Icons on the desktop are always O.K., but most of the icons in windows with icon view are rearranged randomly from time to time - randomly means: no grid, no order (alphabetically, date), swapping... Rearranging manually helps for some days... Sometimes... The problem appeared in 10.6.
Al
00004000
l suggested solutions didn't work.
Apr 14, 2010 2:33 AM
same problem reported here :
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2379700&tstart=0
Apr 17, 2010 5:02 AM
And here:
Desktop items get unsorted after cold boot on Snow Leopard 10.6.2
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=11391937#11391937
Apr 28, 2010 11:27 PM
Perhaps a clue ?
Since the count has the administrator property, the problem didn't occur.
Apr 28, 2010 11:44 PM
Could you please elaborate? I do not understand what you say. Thanks.
Apr 30, 2010 3:29 AM
Unfortunately, the problem is always here.
May 15, 2010 12:48 PM
The problem remains here and is really frustrating:
Desktop items get unsorted after cold boot on Snow Leopard 10.6.2
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2335032
And with Snow Leopard 10.6.3.
May 22, 2010 11:38 AM
According to Apple Technical help:
Delete com.apple.windowserver.plist from Library/Preferences and restart.
It worked for me.
But now file is no longer where it was; rather it appears within System/Library/LaunchDaemons folder.
Is that bad/dangerous/normal/OK?
May 22, 2010 12:22 PM
Which "Apple Technical" document?
Thanks.
May 28, 2010 12:39 AM
In my case, deleting com.apple.windowserver.plist from Library/Preferences and restarting does NOT fix the problem at all.
Besides, the com.apple.windowserver.plist at Library/Preferences is not created again. Is such com.apple.windowserver.plist from Library/Preferences needed for anything?
Thanks.
Jun 8, 2010 10:01 AM
I'm also struggling with the same problem, both at work on my Mac Pro and at home with my brand new iMac 27" (three weeks old).
Jun 8, 2010 10:31 AM
Deleting the invisible file ".DS_Store" on the Desktop does not fix it either.
Jun 13, 2010 4:12 AM
I've the same problem. Every 1 in 10 restart [average] ends with icons moved to the right side of the desktop. This makes me start work with moving ca 20 icons to my favourite positions. I'm Mac user since Macintosh Classic and MacOS 7. It never happened in versions earlier then SnowLeopard. Apple should definitly adress this issue.
Jun 16, 2010 11:58 PM
The problem persists with Mac OS X 10.6.4.
Jun 30, 2010 1:50 AM
UPDATE
I found a utility that solves the problem "Desktility".
Tried it, it worked perfectly, so I bought it - it really saved my day, so now I can continue working and just wait for the actual bug to be fixed.
The utility can be found here:
http://www.desktility.com
Jun 30, 2010 2:15 AM
Free:
Desktop Icon Manager
http://www.macupdate.com/info.php/id/19789/desktop-icon-manager
http://www.versiontracker.com/dyn/moreinfo/macosx/211425
But what is needed is the true Apple bug fix.
Aug 15, 2010 12:16 PM
I tried most of the proposed solutions in this topic, including the plist deletions, etc. Only one worked: deleting the desktop .DS_Store file with Onyx. That worked like a charm (so far).
For me, the desktop items would revert to default alphabetical order on
every reboot/login.
This just started a few days ago and it drove me nuts!
In my case, I know
what initiated the corruption of the desktop file, if not exactly
how.
I accidentally deleted my Little Snitch app and when I went back in Time Machine to restore it and its support files, that's when the desktop issue started. It also messed with my network preferences to the point that I could no longer connect to my wife's computer, our wi-fi network, or the internet.
Deleting all of the Little Snitch files resolved
all issues except the desktop rearranging. That was easily done with Onyx, and now I'm a happy camper, thanks to Steff X!
If you think this may be the cause of your problem, the file locations are here:
~/Library/Application Support/Little Snitch/
~/Library/Logs/Little Snitch Installer.log
~/Library/Logs/Little Snitch Network Monitor.log
~/Library/Logs/Little Snitch UIAgent.log
~/Library/Preferences/at.obdev.LittleSnitchConfiguration.plist
~/Library/Preferences/at.obdev.LittleSnitchNetworkMonitor.plist
~/Library/Preferences/at.obdev/LSD.plist
/Applications/Little Snitch Configuration.app/
/Library/Application Support/Objective Development/Little Snitch/ (*)
/Library/LaunchAgents/at.obdev.LittleSnitchNetworkMonitor.plist
/Library/LaunchAgents/at.obdev.LittleSnitchUIAgent.plist
/Library/LaunchDaemons/at.obdev.littlesnitchd.plist
/Library/Little Snitch/Little Snitch Network Monitor.app/
/Library/Little Snitch/Little Snitch UIAgent.app/
/Library/Little Snitch/lsd
/Library/Logs/LittleSnitchDaemon.log
/System/Library/Extensions/LittleSnitch.kext/
I hope this is helpful to someone.
Sep 15, 2010 12:55 PM
The problem still persist in 10.6.4. About once every month for me.
I noticed that it seems to happen when you get a finder popup, when for example uploading a file in safari, from the Desktop. This, only when you change the view (column, list, cover flow), in this finder popup, then you get the problem the next time you startup the Mac.
Still not 100% sure about the cause.
Just hope 10.6.5 will solve the problem...
Sep 16, 2010 1:34 AM
I don't think that the files from Little Snitch are the source of this problem.
I have this problem, about each 15/20 days, and I have not these files on my computer.
Sep 18, 2010 2:41 AM
Good Morning friends, at least here in Germany it is still morning or lunch time...
Back to the topic...
I noticed the problem, exactly the time when I left my mac mini "sleep" over night and restart it the next day. Everything was sorted new...
On my Macbook Pro this problem doesn't occur!
BUT: there I have the setting mentioned befor "sort grid", and it seems to work pretty fine for me!
Further more I don't think that any app cause this specific problem, so don't worry and delete all your apps 😀
Have a nice weekend...
Best wishes Sebastian
Nov 12, 2010 12:52 AM
The problem persists with Mac OS X 10.6.5.
Nov 29, 2010 2:20 AM
The problem still persist in 10.6.5.
The problem starts when for example:
1. Safari: Get the popup window to upload a file from desktop.
2. iPhoto: Get the popup window when importing photos
...then the next time you restart the Mac, the icons will be sorted alphabetically on desktop, and therefore "destroy" the manual arrangement of these.
Jan 9, 2011 7:34 PM
Hi all.
For what it's worth, I also have the problem...
OS X 10.6.5
Jan 19, 2011 3:48 AM
Same maddening problem here...
Got my iMac four months ago, the bug was already there.
Thing is, the problem only appears like once a week, just enough time for me to forget about it and get used to my new icons arrangement...
I have another iMac 21.5 from 2009, this one doesn't have the problem.
Just tried about every solution here, including a whole lot of onyx maintenance... now to wait...
This is so frustrating.
Jan 19, 2011 5:21 AM
Hi all.
How come it says this question is
answered???
Thanks.
Jan 20, 2011 5:06 PM
The problem is certainly NOT resolved, and it beggars belief that any such claim is made. My intel laptop, now on 10.6.6, had its icons rearranged after a normal shutdown when I started the machine the next day. I rearranged them, used the computer, and the next day Snow Leopard placed them all on the right, AGAIN. I bought this machine new in 2007, about a week after the release of Leopard, and never had the problem with Leopard. I did not upgrade to Snow Leopard until 10.6.4 - because of the bugs (you know the ones: bugs that wiped out user accounts when remotely logging into other computers; and of course, the best one being when Apple so botched 10.6.3 so bad, that they pulled it within a few days of its release replacing it with 10.6.3 v1).
As for the culprits… I don't have "blue harvest" (whatever that is), or "little snitch" (whatever that is), or any of the other programs cited as the cause.
A Windows exec, when comparing Windows 7 with 10.6.2 (a while ago now), described OSX 10.6 as an "experimental" OS. OSX, in the 10.6 version, is certainly too buggy to be anything but an experiment! It is really amateurish stuff from Apple.
I resolved my problem with Tech Tool Pro. I defragmented the files and then defragmented the entire volume into one contiguous block.
It seems that the problem has to do with Apple. I had optimised the volume & consolidated all the files to one contiguous block after 10.6.4. Apple's own "optimisation" which occurred with the upgrade to 10.6.6 RE-fragmented the entire volume.
I don't think Apple care, they're working on their next experiment, Lion….
Jan 22, 2011 1:34 PM
I wonder if it might be an issue with "permissions"… Maybe your user account does not have the permissions to change these parameters.
Try using the Disk Utility to "Repair permissions", then change the desktop parameters, then restart…
Then come back here to tell us if this worked.
Good luck!
Jan 28, 2011 4:40 AM
So?
Did my solution solve your problem?
Feb 9, 2011 9:33 AM
Not to rub you the wrong way, but this is one of the first things I tried. Nothing suggested here works. And it's a blasphemy to dare call the issue resolved.
I'm now reduced to making screenshots of various folders so that I waste as little time as possible whenever this bug happens again (every 3-4 restarts). This is a total aberration.
Anyone from Apple reading this? I've used Macs since System 6, and never had such a MAJOR bug. I regret very much ever upgrading to 10.6. As far as I'm concerned, Snow Leopard should be an extinct species.
Feb 9, 2011 12:27 PM
Patrick,
this suggestion HAS worked for some friends here.
You need to repair the authorizations, and also trash the Finder preferences files, in order to create new pref files with the necessary authorizations for you to modify these prefs… Then restart the Finder, then change your desktop file preferences. These last changes should be permanent…
Feb 9, 2011 2:43 PM
Hi Vakras.
For what it's worth: on 2011-01-23 I changed my View Options for the desktop to "None". (They were set at "Align to grid" or something like that).
As of 2011-02-09 they're still holding. Holding my breath!
Feb 10, 2011 2:30 PM
1. "Ctrl-Click" on the desktop
2. From the menu that pops up, choose the option "Show View Options"
3a. If the window that opens is titled "Desktop": Choous "Arrange by": None
3b(1). If the window that opens is NOT titled "Desktop": put the following file on the desktop: Home/Library/Preferences/com.apple.desktop.plist
3b(2). Go to System Preferences>Desktop & Screen Saver and enter your new preferences in order to regenerate the Home/Library/Preferences/com.apple.desktop.plist (you may then trash that file on the desktop).
Feb 11, 2011 4:01 PM
boucher - you can wonder all you like - - It is a given that someone, anyone, who defragments their entire machine and volumes would also have their permissions in order. And, since i made my volume into a contiguous block it has been unproblematic in this sense.
This Apple OS 10.6 shortcoming is not limited to desktop icons. Copying one folder from an external drive onto the desktop to replace a folder of the same name that already exists on the desktop ALSO rearranges the contents of that folder, and sometimes, just erases the entire contents of that folder leaving nothing in it. This does not happen on the G3 which runs Jaguar, or the G4 which is on Tiger, and never did so on the Intel laptop when it was on Leopard until a few months ago.
Maybe it's the way that the still very buggy SnowLeo which erased User Profiles when linked remotely to other computers works... Hardly the kind of OS that a professional would want to use.
Feb 11, 2011 4:17 PM
thanks Michel, my View Options were set to "none" when the desktop was rearranged again, and again ... My view settings are still set at "none".
Feb 28, 2011 8:48 AM
fdboucher: I do not dispute that this "solution" might have helped some people. But like I said before, it is what I tried first because it is so obvious. And it DOESN'T solve the problem, ciboire.
Vakras is absolutely right, the problem remains UNSOLVED, and is not limited to the desktop.
What a mess.
May 19, 2011 7:39 AM
Hi all.
For what it's worth: on 2011-05-17, all my desktop icons were re-arranged (
00004000
in alphabetical order!) without my doing anything special.
Thank goodness I had kept a snapshot of my personnalized arrangement.
So the problem still lurks in there!
(I'm now on OS X 10.6.7)
May 24, 2011 6:15 PM
Hi again.
Re-arranged again today. (I think after downloading a program from ambrosiasw.com...)
Still not fixed, eh!?
Jun 7, 2011 6:36 PM
Michael, you're right, 10.6.7 did not fix that nasty bug.
With Lion install not requiring a reboot (so says Engadget today), I'm rather scared that the Finder will keep screwing us over.
But who knows, maybe they FINALLY fixed it. That said, Snow Leopard remains a sick beast.
Jun 14, 2011 1:43 PM
A question to anyone who's seen this problem:
How many icons do you have on your desktop?
My hypothesis is that the problem occurs when the number of icons exceeds some arbitrary limit (which I believe is about 100 icons).
Jun 14, 2011 2:11 PM
Justin,
Sorry to shoot down your hypothesis. Had the same idea, since I had lots of stuff on my desktop. So I moved everything to a folder (and took a snapshot, as I;m now compelled to do for every folder arranged in icon view). Since then, I've never had more than 10 icons on the desktop (and that's counting the two internal drive icons).
Well guess what. The arbitrary re-arrangement of icons in alpha order still strikes every now and then.
It's a Finder- and/or windowing subsystem-related bug, as it happens either after a restart, a logout, or a Finder crash.
There's at least 3 other Mac power users in my dept (we're all molecular biologists) who are reduced to making screenshots of folder contents. All of them seasoned Mac veterans who see 10.6 as the only unworthy Mac OS iteration since System 6 (to be honest,10.0 wasn't exactly great either, but only because it felt unfinished).
Jun 14, 2011 2:14 PM
Forgot to say that I've had fewer than 10 icons on the desktop for 3 months now. Bug strikes every 3-4 restarts since then (or right after a Finder crash if system is on continuously for over a week).
Jun 14, 2011 6:43 PM
Hi Justin (and all the others).
If I remember right, the first time this happened to me, I must have had about 50-60 icons on the desktop.
The last time it happened, I had about 15.
(And as soon as I get around to it, I'll finally have only one icon on the desktop; and hope that Lion has figured out how to leave things where it finds them...)
Best regards.
Jun 16, 2011 1:10 PM
Thank you, Patrick and Michel, for shooting down my false hypothesis.
I'm starting to get used to an alphabetical desktop... it's easier than rearranging all those icons every few weeks.
Jul 20, 2011 1:22 PM
Hi all.
For what it's worth, I just turned the computer on and all my desktop icons have been re-arranged (in alphabetical order). Yet I did absolutely nothing out of the ordinary in my previous session.
I'm now down to only 10 desktop icons, but still, it's painful to see this bug live so long with no response at all (to my knowledge) from Apple...
Regards.
Jul 24, 2011 11:54 AM
Mac OS X 10.6.8 has the same bug. Why has not been fixed yet?
BTW, I have never installed BlueHarvest.
See also
Desktop items get unsorted after cold boot on Snow Leopard 10.6.2
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/2335032?start=30&tstart=0
Apple, are you listening?
Aug 16, 2011 9:08 AM
Same sorry mess under 10.6.8. After over a month of smooth sailing, the bug struck me twice in the last 2 weeks on my main machine. Sigh. Hopefully Lion will solve it for good… whenever I find the time to migrate my various Macs (i.e. after grantwriting). Because it's clear Snow Leopard never will. No wonder it's a threatened species.
Aug 16, 2011 10:41 AM
Sep 15, 2011 12:41 PM
I think I found a solution, at least it worked for me:
- Open a Finder folder and access the Desktop folder from there (click on the Desktop and Cmd+N, then browse to your Desktop folder)
- Switch the view to icon view (Cmd+1)
- Open View options panel (Cmd+J)
- Change the sort option to None, I had sort option set to by Name and by default to all new views.
Make sure to do this from a view in a Finder window an not the Desktop itself, otherwise the option is not shown.
After that, I rebooted and the Desktop icons stay in place.
I think this issue applies to all Mac OS X versiones since Tiger at least.
I'd not call it a bug, but definitely a big usability issue.
Hope this work for everyone
Regards
Sep 15, 2011 12:57 PM
It
000031B2
does not work here. I have had the sort option to None for ages. The poblem with this bug is that it is not 100% consistent; it strikes one in five times or so.
Sep 15, 2011 1:03 PM
Agreed. There are already reports that this does not solve the bug. More compellingly, this has been filed in Apple's bug database under Bug ID# 8657884. Become a developer (it's free), and report this bug, using the ID given here. The more people do this, the more incentive for Apple engineers to solve it. Especially since the bug is also present in Lion.
Sep 15, 2011 2:39 PM
The thing is, I also had the sorted option to None, BUT in the option for the Desktop viewed in the usual way, selecting the Desktop itself, but if you look at the desktop folder inside
00004000
your user folder, there are options available that you don't have otherwise.
Having the sort option by default was one of them that was NOT shown in the View options as seen from the Desktop.
So far my icons had not been moved again.
Are you sure that you are viewing the View options like I said?
Sep 15, 2011 3:26 PM
In my case it was just as you indicate. It has been like that always for years. And I get rearranged Desktop icons once in every five reboots or so. Even with just three or four Desktop icons. Really frustrating.
Sep 15, 2011 3:51 PM
Too bad.
I wonder why it seem to work for me, so far at least.
And yes, I know is VERY annoying, much more due to the fact that the problem had persisted for several major Mac OS versions.
I also went back to Snow Leopard, too much anoyances like these on Lion as it is right now.
Not holding my breath on Apple fixing them though...
Best of luck, guys.
Aug 20, 2012 6:22 AM
I've noticed that every time my icons get unsorted it is because Finder deletes the /Desktop/.DS_Store file.
It seems like Finder cannot recreate/update the .DS_Store after a while.
Anybody else noticed this?
Open Terminal and enter this command "ls -latr Desktop".
This will display all files and sort them with last created in bottom.
The .DS_Store should be in the bottom of the list and be recreated when for example a file is put on the Desktop.
Running Mac OS X 10.6.8.
Feb 5, 2013 10:02 AM
I've the same problem since 10.6.
I've reported this to apple via Bug Report on 2013-01-17 (Bug ID 13031916) - the first answer was: "We can not reproduce this, we have no other reports of this, and we are not planning any fixes in this area for Snow Leopard "
a workaround is this:
Download Desktop Icon Manager for Mac - Saves/restores icon positions on the desktop. MacUpdate.com
Running Mac OS X 10.6.8 / MacPro / 8GB
Sep 19, 2013 4:33 PM
I have been having this issue as well.
Have tried various solutions suggested across multiple threads with this topic, and nothing worked...
I asked my programmer husband, and he asked the simple question to me:
"Have you tried using Safari?"
I'm a steadfast Chrome user, so I had not.
Opened Safari, tried dragging and dropping, and lo and behold, the behavior had reverted to dropping images where I wanted to (instead of snapping to the upper right).
So far, I have seen no one else mention their browser of choice. Just thought I would post this to see if somehow this is a Chrome issue, and not an OS X issue at all.
Any thoughts, anybody?
(FWIW, I am not switching to Safari just to drag-and-drop properly. There needs to be a solution that doesn't require me switching to what I consider an i
00004000
nferior browsing experience.)
Dec 2, 2014 11:38 AM
Today I got this bug for the first time I ever had my Macbook 5.1
under 10.5 never got this bug now under 10.6.8 the first time